should
12262 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
He said to him, "Thus spake R. Johanan : From the day the Temple was destroyed, a decree was issued that the houses of the righteous should be destroyed ; as it is said, 'In mine ears said the Lord of hosts : Of a truth many houses shall be desolate, even great and fair, without inhabitant' (Is. v. 9). Also said R. Johanan: The Holy One, blessed be He, will restore them to habitation ; as it is said, 'A Song of Ascents. They that trust in the Lord are as Mount Zion' (Ps. cxxv. 1) — just as the Holy One, blessed be He, will restore Mount Zion to habitation, so will He restore the houses of the righteous to habitation." He perceived that his mind was still not at rest, so he said to him, "It is enough for the slave to be like his master."
But He should have restored [the original stars]! "A pit cannot be filled with its own clods"; or also, "An accuser cannot become a defender."
Then He should have created two other stars ! "There is nothing new under the sun" (Eccles. i. 9). Rab Nahman said : The Holy One, blessed be He, will hereafter restore them; as it is said, "And the 'Ajish will be comforted for her children."
And for earthquakes. What is an earthquake? Rab Kattina said : A subterranean rumbling. Rab Kattina was journeying by the way, and when he reached the entrance of the house of a necromancer a rumbling noise broke forth. He said, "Does the necromancer know what this rumbling is?" The latter called to him, "Kattina, Kattina ! Why should I not know? When the Holy One, blessed be He, remembers His children who dwell in misery among the nations of the world. He causes two tears to descend to the Ocean, and the sound is heard from one end of the world to the other ; and that is the rumbling."
Rab Kattina said, "The necromancer lies and his words are false; for in that case, there should be one rumbling noise followed by another!" But it is not so ; there is really one rumbling noise followed by another, and the reason that Kattina did not acknowledge the necromancer's statement was that people should not be led astray after him.
Rab Kattina said, "The necromancer lies and his words are false; for in that case, there should be one rumbling noise followed by another!" But it is not so ; there is really one rumbling noise followed by another, and the reason that Kattina did not acknowledge the necromancer's statement was that people should not be led astray after him.
What is to be deduced therefrom? That one should offer supplication. This applies only to the night, but in the morning there is no significance in them.
R. Alexander said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi : Thunder was only created to break the pride of the heart ; as it is said, "God hath so made it that men should fear before Him" (Eccles. iii. 14). Also said R. Alexander in the nanie of R.Joshua b. Levi : Who sees the rainbow should prostrate himself upon his face; as it is said, "As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud...and when I saw it, I fell upon my face" (Ezek. i. 28). In the West they curse one who acts thus, because it has the appearance as though he worships the rainbow ; but he should certainly pronounce a benediction. What is the benediction ? "Blessed. ..Who remembrest the Covenant." It has been taught in a Baraita : R. Ishmael, the son of R. Johanan b. Baroka says: [The benediction is, "Blessed...] Who art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word." Rab Pappa said: Let us therefore say both : "Blessed ... Who remembrest the Covenant, art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word."
R. Alexander said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi : Thunder was only created to break the pride of the heart ; as it is said, "God hath so made it that men should fear before Him" (Eccles. iii. 14). Also said R. Alexander in the nanie of R.Joshua b. Levi : Who sees the rainbow should prostrate himself upon his face; as it is said, "As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud...and when I saw it, I fell upon my face" (Ezek. i. 28). In the West they curse one who acts thus, because it has the appearance as though he worships the rainbow ; but he should certainly pronounce a benediction. What is the benediction ? "Blessed. ..Who remembrest the Covenant." It has been taught in a Baraita : R. Ishmael, the son of R. Johanan b. Baroka says: [The benediction is, "Blessed...] Who art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word." Rab Pappa said: Let us therefore say both : "Blessed ... Who remembrest the Covenant, art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word."
R. Alexander said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi : Thunder was only created to break the pride of the heart ; as it is said, "God hath so made it that men should fear before Him" (Eccles. iii. 14). Also said R. Alexander in the nanie of R.Joshua b. Levi : Who sees the rainbow should prostrate himself upon his face; as it is said, "As the appearance of the bow that is in the cloud...and when I saw it, I fell upon my face" (Ezek. i. 28). In the West they curse one who acts thus, because it has the appearance as though he worships the rainbow ; but he should certainly pronounce a benediction. What is the benediction ? "Blessed. ..Who remembrest the Covenant." It has been taught in a Baraita : R. Ishmael, the son of R. Johanan b. Baroka says: [The benediction is, "Blessed...] Who art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word." Rab Pappa said: Let us therefore say both : "Blessed ... Who remembrest the Covenant, art faithful with Thy Covenant and fulfillest Thy word."
But in a case where there is not another [sharing] with him, does he not use the benediction "Who art good and dispensest good"? Lo, there is a teaching : Should they announce to him "Thy wife has given birth to a son," he says "Blessed... Who art good and dispensest good" ! Even here, his wife [shares the joy] with him, because she has a preference for a son.
Come and hear : If the wine is changed [for a better kind during the meal] there is no necessity to utter another benediction; but if he changed his place [and other wine is brought to him] he should utter a further benediction ; and Rab Joseph b. Abba said in the name of R. Johanan : Although it has been stated that if the wine is changed another benediction is unnecessary, still he says, "Blessed... Who art good and dispensest good" ! Here also there are the other members of the company who drink with him.
Or if thou wilt I can say that the incident of Leah occurred within forty days [of conception], according to the teaching : During the first three days [of the conjugal act] a man may pray that [his seed] should not become abortive ; from the third to the fortieth day he may pray that a male-child shall be born to him ; from the fortieth day to the third month he may pray that it should not be a monstrosity; from the third to the sixth month he may pray that it should not be a premature birth ; from the sixth to the ninth month he may pray that it should issue in safety.
Or if thou wilt I can say that the incident of Leah occurred within forty days [of conception], according to the teaching : During the first three days [of the conjugal act] a man may pray that [his seed] should not become abortive ; from the third to the fortieth day he may pray that a male-child shall be born to him ; from the fortieth day to the third month he may pray that it should not be a monstrosity; from the third to the sixth month he may pray that it should not be a premature birth ; from the sixth to the ninth month he may pray that it should issue in safety.
Or if thou wilt I can say that the incident of Leah occurred within forty days [of conception], according to the teaching : During the first three days [of the conjugal act] a man may pray that [his seed] should not become abortive ; from the third to the fortieth day he may pray that a male-child shall be born to him ; from the fortieth day to the third month he may pray that it should not be a monstrosity; from the third to the sixth month he may pray that it should not be a premature birth ; from the sixth to the ninth month he may pray that it should issue in safety.
Or if thou wilt I can say that the incident of Leah occurred within forty days [of conception], according to the teaching : During the first three days [of the conjugal act] a man may pray that [his seed] should not become abortive ; from the third to the fortieth day he may pray that a male-child shall be born to him ; from the fortieth day to the third month he may pray that it should not be a monstrosity; from the third to the sixth month he may pray that it should not be a premature birth ; from the sixth to the ninth month he may pray that it should issue in safety.
But is it of any avail to pray [during the first forty days that it should be a male child]? For lo, R. Isaac b. R. Ammi has said : If it is the man who first emits seed his wife bears a daughter ; but if the woman first emits seed she gives birth to a son ; as it is said, "If a woman emits seed and bare a male child" (Lev. xii. 2)! With what are we here dealing ? For instance, if they both emit seed simultaneously.
He who enters a town should offer prayer twice.
Our Rabbis have taught : Who enters a bath-house says, "May it be Thy will, O Lord my God, to deliver me from this and anything similar, and may no disgrace or iniquity befall me; but should any disgrace or iniquity befall me, may my death be an atonement for all my sins."
Abbai said : Let not a man speak thus, so as not to open his mouth to Satan. For said R. Simeon b. Lakish, and it has been similarly taught in the name of R. Jose : A man should never open his mouth to Satan.
Rab Joseph said: What is the Scriptural authority? For it is written, "We should have been as Sodom, we should have been like unto Gomorrah" (Is, i. 9). What did the prophet answer them? "Hear the word of the Lord, ye rulers of Sodom" (ibid. v. 10).
Rab Joseph said: What is the Scriptural authority? For it is written, "We should have been as Sodom, we should have been like unto Gomorrah" (Is, i. 9). What did the prophet answer them? "Hear the word of the Lord, ye rulers of Sodom" (ibid. v. 10).
[As R. Aha said:] Who goes in to have himself cupped should say, "May it be Thy will, O Lord my God, that this operation be a cure for me, and do Thou heal me for Thou art a faithful Healer and Thy cure is certain, since it is not the way of human beings to cure, but thus are they accustomed."
How is it to be concluded? Rab said, "[Blessed art Thou, O Lord,] Who healest the sick." Samuel said: Does Abba regard the whole world as sick? Nay, [the conclusion of the benediction should be : "Blessed...] Who healest all flesh." Rab Sheshet said : [It should conclude : "Blessed...] Who doest wondrously." Rab Pappa said : Let us therefore say both : "Who healest all flesh and doest wondrously."
How is it to be concluded? Rab said, "[Blessed art Thou, O Lord,] Who healest the sick." Samuel said: Does Abba regard the whole world as sick? Nay, [the conclusion of the benediction should be : "Blessed...] Who healest all flesh." Rab Sheshet said : [It should conclude : "Blessed...] Who doest wondrously." Rab Pappa said : Let us therefore say both : "Who healest all flesh and doest wondrously."
A man is in duty bound, etc. What means : A man is in duty bound to utter a benediction for the bad even as he utters one for the good? Are we to suppose that as for the good he says the benediction "...Who art good and dispensest good," he is to make the same benediction for the bad? For lo, our Mishnah teaches : For good tidings he says "Who art good and dispensest good" and For bad tidings he says "Blessed be the true Judge"! Raba said : It is only necessary that he should receive [the bad] with gladness.
Rab Huna stated that Rab said in the name of R. Meir, (and it has been similarly taught in the name of R. 'Akiba) : A man should always accustom himself to say, "Whatever the All-merciful does, He does for the best."
Rab Huna stated that Rab said in the name of R. Meir : A man's words should always be few before the Holy One, blessed be He ; as it is said, "Be not rash with thy mouth, and let not thy heart be hasty to utter a word before God ; for God is in heaven, and thou upon earth, therefore let thy words be few" (Eccles. v. 1).
"And He brought her unto the man" (ibid.). R. Jeremiah b. Eleazar said : This means that the Holy One, blessed be He, constituted Himself Adam's "best man"; hence the Torah teaches a rule of conduct, viz. : that an eminent man should accompany one of less importance as "best man," and it will not injure [his dignity].
According to him who said [Eve was made from] a face, which of them went in front? Rab Nahman b. Isaac said : It is more probable that the masculine countenance went in front ; for there is a teaching : A man should never walk behind a woman along the road, even his own wife. Should a woman meet him on a bridge he should let her pass by on the side ; and whoever crosses a stream behind a woman will have no portion in the world to come.
According to him who said [Eve was made from] a face, which of them went in front? Rab Nahman b. Isaac said : It is more probable that the masculine countenance went in front ; for there is a teaching : A man should never walk behind a woman along the road, even his own wife. Should a woman meet him on a bridge he should let her pass by on the side ; and whoever crosses a stream behind a woman will have no portion in the world to come.
According to him who said [Eve was made from] a face, which of them went in front? Rab Nahman b. Isaac said : It is more probable that the masculine countenance went in front ; for there is a teaching : A man should never walk behind a woman along the road, even his own wife. Should a woman meet him on a bridge he should let her pass by on the side ; and whoever crosses a stream behind a woman will have no portion in the world to come.
R. Johanan said : A man should walk behind a lion rather than behind a woman, behind a woman rather than behind an idolater, behind an idolater rather than behind a Synagogue when the Congregation is at prayer.
But this last is only meant when he is not carrying a load ; should he, however, be carrying a load, there is no objection. It is only meant when there is no other entrance ; but should there be another entrance, there is no objection. It is further only meant when he is not riding upon an ass ; but should he be riding upon an ass, there is no objection. It is likewise only meant when he is not wearing Tefillin ; but if he is wearing Tefillin, there is no objection.
But this last is only meant when he is not carrying a load ; should he, however, be carrying a load, there is no objection. It is only meant when there is no other entrance ; but should there be another entrance, there is no objection. It is further only meant when he is not riding upon an ass ; but should he be riding upon an ass, there is no objection. It is likewise only meant when he is not wearing Tefillin ; but if he is wearing Tefillin, there is no objection.
But this last is only meant when he is not carrying a load ; should he, however, be carrying a load, there is no objection. It is only meant when there is no other entrance ; but should there be another entrance, there is no objection. It is further only meant when he is not riding upon an ass ; but should he be riding upon an ass, there is no objection. It is likewise only meant when he is not wearing Tefillin ; but if he is wearing Tefillin, there is no objection.
the lungs absorb all kinds of liquids, the liver arouses anger, the gall lets a drop fall upon it and stills it, the milt produces laughter, the large intestine grinds [food], the maw induces sleep and the nose awakens. Should the organ which induces sleep arouse from sleep, or should the organ which arouses from sleep induce sleep, the person pines away. It has been taught : Should both of them induce sleep or arouse from sleep simultaneously, one immediately dies.
the lungs absorb all kinds of liquids, the liver arouses anger, the gall lets a drop fall upon it and stills it, the milt produces laughter, the large intestine grinds [food], the maw induces sleep and the nose awakens. Should the organ which induces sleep arouse from sleep, or should the organ which arouses from sleep induce sleep, the person pines away. It has been taught : Should both of them induce sleep or arouse from sleep simultaneously, one immediately dies.
the lungs absorb all kinds of liquids, the liver arouses anger, the gall lets a drop fall upon it and stills it, the milt produces laughter, the large intestine grinds [food], the maw induces sleep and the nose awakens. Should the organ which induces sleep arouse from sleep, or should the organ which arouses from sleep induce sleep, the person pines away. It has been taught : Should both of them induce sleep or arouse from sleep simultaneously, one immediately dies.
"And thou shalt love the Lord thy God" (Deut. vi. 5). There is a teaching : R. Eliezer says : If it is stated "With all thy soul," why is it stated "With all thy might"? And if it is stated "With all thy might," why is it stated "With all thy soul"? But should there be a man whose body is dearer to him than his money, therefore it is stated "With all thy soul"; and should there be a man whose money is dearer to him than his body, therefore it is stated "With all thy might." R. 'Akiba says: "With all thy soul" [means,] even if He take thy soul.
"And thou shalt love the Lord thy God" (Deut. vi. 5). There is a teaching : R. Eliezer says : If it is stated "With all thy soul," why is it stated "With all thy might"? And if it is stated "With all thy might," why is it stated "With all thy soul"? But should there be a man whose body is dearer to him than his money, therefore it is stated "With all thy soul"; and should there be a man whose money is dearer to him than his body, therefore it is stated "With all thy might." R. 'Akiba says: "With all thy soul" [means,] even if He take thy soul.
Our Rabbis have taught : Once the wicked government decreed that Israel should no longer occupy themselves with Torah. There came Pappos b. Judah and found R. 'Akiba attracting great assemblies and studying Torah. He said to him, "'Akiba, art thou not afraid of the wicked government?"
A man should not behave with levity towards the East Gate [of the Temple], since it is directed towards the Holy of Holies, etc. Rab Judah said in the name of Rab : This is only meant from Sophim inwards, and only applies to one who can see [the Temple]. It has been similarly reported : R. Abba b. R. Hijya. b. Abba said : Thus declared R. Johanan : This is only meant from Sophim inwards, and only applies to one who can see [the Temple] and when there is no barrier [between him and it], and at the time when the Shekinah rests [upon the Sanctuary].
Our Rabbis have taught : He who wishes to exercise his natural functions, if in Judea he should not face East or West but North or South ; if in Galilee, he should only face East or West. R. Jose, however, permits it [in any direction] because he used to say that the prohibition only applies to one who can see [the Temple], when there is no barrier, and at the time when the Shekinah rests [upon the Sanctuary]. But the Sages prohibit it.
Our Rabbis have taught : He who wishes to exercise his natural functions, if in Judea he should not face East or West but North or South ; if in Galilee, he should only face East or West. R. Jose, however, permits it [in any direction] because he used to say that the prohibition only applies to one who can see [the Temple], when there is no barrier, and at the time when the Shekinah rests [upon the Sanctuary]. But the Sages prohibit it.
There is a teaching : R. 'Akiba said : Once I went into a privy behind R. Joshua and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. Ben 'Azzai said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
There is a teaching : R. 'Akiba said : Once I went into a privy behind R. Joshua and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. Ben 'Azzai said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
There is a teaching : R. 'Akiba said : Once I went into a privy behind R. Joshua and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. Ben 'Azzai said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
There is a teaching : Ben 'Azzai said : I once went into a privy behind R. 'Akiba and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. R. Judah said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
There is a teaching : Ben 'Azzai said : I once went into a privy behind R. 'Akiba and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. R. Judah said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
There is a teaching : Ben 'Azzai said : I once went into a privy behind R. 'Akiba and learnt from him three things. I learnt that we should not evacuate East or West, but North or South. I learnt that we should not expose ourselves standing but sitting. I also learnt that we should not wipe ourselves with the right hand but with the left. R. Judah said to him, "Wert thou so impudent with thy master?" He replied, "It was a matter of Torah and I wished to learn."
Why should we not wipe with the right hand but only with the left? Raba said : Because the Torah was given with the right hand ; as it is said, "At His right hand was a fiery law unto them" (Deut. xxxiii. 2). Rabbah b. Bar Hannah said : Because it is near the mouths. R. Simeon b. Lakish said : Because he binds the Tefillin with it. Rab Nahman b. Isaac said: Because he points to the accents of the Torah with it.
Abbai reared a lamb to accompany him into the privy. But he should have roared a goat! A satyr may be changed into a goat.
But it is not so ! For lo, Rab Judah said in the name of Rab : A man should always accustom himself [to perform his natural functions] morning and evening so that it will be unnecessary for him to go far [and find a secluded spot]. And further, Raba used to go as far as a Mil by day ; but at night he would say to his attendant, "Prepare for me a place in the street of the town." Similarly used R. Zera to say to his attendant, "See whether there is anybody behind the Seminary, as I wish to relieve myself"! Read not [in the Baraita] "in the same place," but read "in the same manner that he relieves himself by day."
It was stated above : "Rab Judah said in the name of Rab : A man should always accustom himself [to perform his natural functions] morning and evening, so that it will be unnecessary for him to go far [and find a secluded spot]."
There is a teaching to the same effect : Ben 'Azzai says : Rise early and go out, and act likewise after dusk so that thou needest not go a distance ; feel the need and then sit down, but do not sit down and then [wait to] feel the need, for whoever does so, even should they practise sorcery in Aspamia it will befall him.
But should he through forgetfulness act thus, what is his remedy ? On rising, let him say as follows, "Not to me, not to me ; no Tahim and no Tahtim ; not these and not from these ; no charms of a sorcerer and no charms of a sorceress."
Rab Pappa said to Raba (other versions : Rabina to Raba ; Rab Adda b. Mattena to Raba) : Why should one derive it [by analogy] from a shoe ; let him derive it from the short cut !
He replied : The Tanna derives it from the shoe, and thou sayest [it should be derived] from the short cut — how can that be? For there is a teaching : A man must not enter the Temple Mount with his staff in his hand, his shoe upon his foot, and his money tied up in his cloth or in his money-bag thrown over his shoulder, nor may he make it a short cut ; and [the prohibition of] expectoration is derived a fortiori from the shoe — as in the case of a shoe which is not in itself contemptible the Torah declares, "Put off thy shoes from off thy feet" (Exod. iii. 5), must not expectoration, which is in itself contemptible, be all the more forbidden !
It is possible to think that all benedictions should have one praise; therefore there is a teaching to state, "Above all blessing and praise" — for each benediction give Him praise.
It was further ordained that a man should greet his friends by mentioning the Divine Name, etc. What means "And it is said"?
Bar Kappara expounded : A man should always teach his son a clean and light trade. Which is such? Rab Hisda said : Needle-stitching.
There is a teaching: Rabbi says : A man should never multiply friends in his house; as it is said, "There are friends that one hath to his own hurt" (Prov. xviii. 24).
There is a teaching : Rabbi says : Why does the section of the Nazirite adjoin the section of the woman suspected of adultery? To tell thee that whoever sees such a woman in her disgrace should separate himself from wine.
Rab Nahman b. Isaac said : Should he duly hand them over, in the end he will grow rich ; as it is said, "Whatever any man giveth the priest, it shall be his" (Num. v. 10) — i.e. much wealth shall be his.
R. Tanhum b. R. Hiyya, of the town of Acco, said : Thou mayest know from this that should a man recite the Shema' morning and evening, but omit it a single evening, he is like one who has never recited it at all.
Another explanation of "Attend [hasket] and hear, O Israel": Be silent [has] and then discuss [kattet]; according to the statement of Raba who said : A man should always study Torah first and afterwards meditate thereon.
"So the forcing of wrath bringeth forth strife" — a disciple with whom his master is the first and second time angry but he remains silent [under the rebuke] is worthy to distinguish between suits involving money and suits involving life. For there is a Mishnaic teaching: R. Ishmael says : Who wishes to grow wise should study money-suits, for there is no branch of Torah more [complex] than these ; they are like a well.
for Rab Joseph [was nicknamed] "Sinai[6]" and Rabbah "the uprooter of mountains[7]. "The time needed them[8]; so [the electors] sent [a message] there[9], "Of 'Sinai' and 'the uprooter of mountains,' which should be given preference?" They returned answer, "'Sinai' should be preferred, because all stand in need of an owner of wheat[10]." Nevertheless Rab Joseph did not accept the offer, because the Chaldeans[11] told him, "Thou wilt reign only two years[12]."
for Rab Joseph [was nicknamed] "Sinai[6]" and Rabbah "the uprooter of mountains[7]. "The time needed them[8]; so [the electors] sent [a message] there[9], "Of 'Sinai' and 'the uprooter of mountains,' which should be given preference?" They returned answer, "'Sinai' should be preferred, because all stand in need of an owner of wheat[10]." Nevertheless Rab Joseph did not accept the offer, because the Chaldeans[11] told him, "Thou wilt reign only two years[12]."
R. Abin the Levite also said : What means that which is written, "The Lord answer thee in the day of trouble; the name of the God of Jacob set thee up on high" (Ps. xx. 2)? The God of Jacob, but not the God of Abraham and Isaac ! From this we learn that the owner of a beam should go in with the heaviest part of it[1].
R. Abin the Levite also said : One who takes leave of his friend should not say to him, "Go in peace" but "Go to peace"; because in the case of Jethro who said to Moses "Go to peace" (Exod. iv. 18), the latter advanced and prospered ; but in the case of David who said to Absalom "Go in peace" (II Sam. xv. 9), the latter went and was hanged.
R. Abin the Levite also said : One who takes leave of the dead should not say to him, "Go to peace" but "Go in peace" ; as it is said, "But thou shalt go to thy fathers in peace" (Gen. xv. 15).
GEMARA. We have learned elsewhere : [The crossbeam] of an alley [whose entrance] is more than twenty cubits high should be lowered. Rabbi Judah says: this is unnecessary.
This, furthermore, may be deduced also [from the wording], for it was stated, ‘If his head and the greater part of his body were within the Sukkah but his table was within the house, Bais Shammai [says] it's pasul, and Bais Hillel [says] it's Kosher;' but if it is [as you say] it should read, [If the Sukkah can] contain, or cannot contain [his head, etc.].
Mar Zutra said: The wording of this Mishnah also proves it, since is says: ‘Bais Shammai declare it pasul, and Bais Hillel says it's Kosher’, and if it were [as you say] it should read Bais Shammai say’, He has not fulfilled his obligation while Bais Hillel say that he has.
We should say rather, Eruv's of courtyards [are placed] in a house of the courtyard, and the Shittufs of alleys in a courtyard of the alley; and this is no worse than a courtyard in an alley.
But have we not learnt, A courtyard should not be divided unless there is four amos to each [of the parties]?
Go and deduce it from the smallest of the vessels, concerning which it is said, ... "And you shall make for it a border of a handbreadth around" (Exodus 25:25) Just as there the height was a handbreadth so was it here also a handbreadth But why should our deduction not be made from the vessels themselves? If you seized a large amount, you have not seized anything; but if you seized the lesser amount you have seized.
But why should we not derive it from the golden headplate (ציץ), as it was taught: The tzitz was in the shape of a plate of gold two finger-breadths broad and stretching from ear to ear, and upon it were engraved two lines, Yod and Heh above, and Kodesh [followed by a] Lamed below, and R. Eliezer son of R. Yose said, I saw it in Rome and it had Kodesh Ladonai on one line.
Why then should we not deduce from the crown, of which a master stated: The crown was on the smallest possible size? We deduce the size of a vessel from that of another vessel, but not from an accessory to a vessel. If so, [it may be objected] was not the border also an appurtenance of a vessel? The border was below [the top of] the table.
But why should we not learn from the ‘face’ above concerning which it is written, "As one sees the face of God, and You were pleased with me?" (Genesis 33:10). If you seized a large amount, you have not seized anything; but if you seized the lesser amount you have seized.
But are not [the laws of] interposition from the Torah, as it is written, "And he shall wash his body in water" (Leviticus 14:9) [which implies] that nothing should interpose between him and the water?
And as for the rabbis? — It means that the veil should bend over a little [at the top] so that it might look like a covering.
But consider: By how much is a square greater than its [inscribed] circle? By a quarter. Should it then not suffice if only sixteen [men can be seated around it]?
But consider: If the side of a square is a cubit, its diagonal is approximately one and two fifths cubits. Should not then [a circumference equivalent to] sixteen and four fifths [cubits] suffice? [R. Johanan] gave only an approximate figure.
But why should this be so? Why shouldn't the outer one be regarded as the gate-house of the inner one, and therefore be obliged to have a mezuzah? Because neither [booth] is of a permanent nature.
When I repeated this in the presence of Shmuel he said to me: Even if from a tuft [sewn to a garment] they are also not valid, because it is necessary that the weaving shall be done specifically for its purpose. Here too then we should require a sukkah be made specifically for its purpose?
If the branches were interwoven, why mention the case at all? One might have thought that it should be prohibited where it is interwoven lest he regard it as valid even where it was not interwoven, [therefore the mishnah] informs us that we don't decree against it.
This is obvious! The statement: "the lower one is valid and the upper one is invalid" was necessary. For what might you have said: we should invalidate [the lower sukkah] as a preventive measure lest one also joins invalid skhakh with valid skhakh, therefore it teaches us [that it is valid].
How much [space] should there be between [the roof of] one sukkah and that of the other to invalidate the lower one?
‘With male arrow-shafts it is valid’; but is not this obvious? I might have said that these should be forbidden on account of female ones, therefore he teaches us [that they are not forbidden].
R. Hisda said: The bundling of one thing [to itself] is not considered bundling; of three things, it is considered bundling; of two, there is a dispute between R. Yose and the rabbis, as we have learned: The mitzvah of the hyssop: it should have three stalks bearing three buds. Rabbi Yose says: the mitzvah of the hyssop is that it should have three stalks, and on them three buds, but its remnants need only have two, while its stumps may be of the smallest size.
R. Hisda said: The bundling of one thing [to itself] is not considered bundling; of three things, it is considered bundling; of two, there is a dispute between R. Yose and the rabbis, as we have learned: The mitzvah of the hyssop: it should have three stalks bearing three buds. Rabbi Yose says: the mitzvah of the hyssop is that it should have three stalks, and on them three buds, but its remnants need only have two, while its stumps may be of the smallest size.
Now we should assume that since its remnants [are valid] with two, at the outset also two are valid, and that the reason he teaches three is to indicate what is the most proper observance of the commandment And since R. Yose requires three only for the most proper observance of the commandment according to the rabbis three are indispensable.
Mishnah: A [wooden] roof that has no plastering: Rabbi Judah says: Bet Shammai say that he should loosen [the planks] and remove one from between each two. And Bet Hillel say he should either loosen [the planks] or remove one from between two. Rabbi Meir says, he removes one from between two, but he does not loosen [the planks].
Mishnah: A [wooden] roof that has no plastering: Rabbi Judah says: Bet Shammai say that he should loosen [the planks] and remove one from between each two. And Bet Hillel say he should either loosen [the planks] or remove one from between two. Rabbi Meir says, he removes one from between two, but he does not loosen [the planks].
GEMARA. It is well according to Bet Hillel; their reason is that ‘You shall make’, but not from that which is [already] made. If he loosens [the planks] he performs an action, and if he removes one from between two he performs an action. But what is the reason of Beth Shammai? If it is ‘You shall make’ but not from that which is [already] made, one act only should be sufficient; if it is because of a decree lest one use ordinary roofing, it should suffice if he removes one from between two?
GEMARA. It is well according to Bet Hillel; their reason is that ‘You shall make’, but not from that which is [already] made. If he loosens [the planks] he performs an action, and if he removes one from between two he performs an action. But what is the reason of Beth Shammai? If it is ‘You shall make’ but not from that which is [already] made, one act only should be sufficient; if it is because of a decree lest one use ordinary roofing, it should suffice if he removes one from between two?
If so, read the concluding [part:] R. Meir ruled, he should remove one from between two, but not loosen. Is not R. Meir's view thus identical with that of Beth Shammai?