r
6334 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
GEMARA. Who is the Tanna that holds that [even if] the deaf person has read, it does not count? R. Matanah said: R. It is R. Yose, as we have learned: One who read the Shema but doesn’t make it heard to his ears, he has fulfilled his obligation. R. Yose says that he has not fulfilled his obligation.
But how do we know that [our Mishnah] follows R. Yose and even if the deaf person has read, it does not count? Perhaps it follows R. Judah, and [what it means is that] the deaf person should not read, but if he has read, his reading is accepted?
But how do we know that [our Mishnah] follows R. Yose and even if the deaf person has read, it does not count? Perhaps it follows R. Judah, and [what it means is that] the deaf person should not read, but if he has read, his reading is accepted?
But perhaps there is one rule for the one and another rule for the other? Since it teaches in the final clause that R. Judah validates a minor, we may conclude that the first clause does not state the opinion of R. Judah.
But perhaps there is one rule for the one and another rule for the other? Since it teaches in the final clause that R. Judah validates a minor, we may conclude that the first clause does not state the opinion of R. Judah.
(But perhaps the whole of the Mishnah states the opinions of R. Judah? — Is it possible that he should disqualify in the first and permit in the second?)
But perhaps the whole [of the Mishnah] is R. Judah, and he teaches of two kinds of minors, and the Mishnah is lacking and it should teach this: All are qualified to read the Megillah, except a deaf man, an imbecile and a minor. What is this speaking of? Of a minor who is not old enough to be educated in the mitzvot. But a minor who is old enough to be educated in the mitzvot may read even ab initio, since R. Judah declares a minor qualified!
But perhaps the whole [of the Mishnah] is R. Judah, and he teaches of two kinds of minors, and the Mishnah is lacking and it should teach this: All are qualified to read the Megillah, except a deaf man, an imbecile and a minor. What is this speaking of? Of a minor who is not old enough to be educated in the mitzvot. But a minor who is old enough to be educated in the mitzvot may read even ab initio, since R. Judah declares a minor qualified!
How then have you explained [the first clause of the Mishnah]? Like R. Judah and ex post facto.
Then that which was taught by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi: One who can speak but not hear may set aside terumah ab initio. Whose view is this? If you say, R. Judah, he holds that this is only ex post facto, but not ab initio. If you say R. Yose, he invalidates the action even ex post facto.
Then that which was taught by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi: One who can speak but not hear may set aside terumah ab initio. Whose view is this? If you say, R. Judah, he holds that this is only ex post facto, but not ab initio. If you say R. Yose, he invalidates the action even ex post facto.
Then that which was taught by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi: One who can speak but not hear may set aside terumah ab initio. Whose view is this? If you say, R. Judah, he holds that this is only ex post facto, but not ab initio. If you say R. Yose, he invalidates the action even ex post facto.
Then that which was taught by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi: One who can speak but not hear may set aside terumah ab initio. Whose view is this? If you say, R. Judah, he holds that this is only ex post facto, but not ab initio. If you say R. Yose, he invalidates the action even ex post facto.
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
In fact it follows R. Judah, and he holds that the deaf person can read even ab initio, and there is no difficulty: in the first quotation he is giving his own opinion, in the second that of his teacher,
as it has been taught: R. Judah says in the name of R. Elazar b. Azariah: One who recites the Shema should make it heard to his ears, as it says, “Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One”—Make heard to your ear what your mouth says. R. Meir says: “Which I command you this day upon your heart” according to the words follow the intention of the heart.
as it has been taught: R. Judah says in the name of R. Elazar b. Azariah: One who recites the Shema should make it heard to his ears, as it says, “Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One”—Make heard to your ear what your mouth says. R. Meir says: “Which I command you this day upon your heart” according to the words follow the intention of the heart.
as it has been taught: R. Judah says in the name of R. Elazar b. Azariah: One who recites the Shema should make it heard to his ears, as it says, “Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One”—Make heard to your ear what your mouth says. R. Meir says: “Which I command you this day upon your heart” according to the words follow the intention of the heart.
Now that you have come to this, you may even say that R. Judah was of the same opinion as his teacher, and the statement made by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi follows R. Meir.
Now that you have come to this, you may even say that R. Judah was of the same opinion as his teacher, and the statement made by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi follows R. Meir.
Now that you have come to this, you may even say that R. Judah was of the same opinion as his teacher, and the statement made by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi follows R. Meir.
Now that you have come to this, you may even say that R. Judah was of the same opinion as his teacher, and the statement made by R. Judah the son of R. Shimon b. Pazzi follows R. Meir.
R. Judah declares a minor qualified. It has been taught: R. Judah said: When I was a young boy, I read it [the Megillah] in front of R. Tarfon and the elders in Lod. They said to him: Proof cannot be brought from the testimony of a minor.
R. Judah declares a minor qualified. It has been taught: R. Judah said: When I was a young boy, I read it [the Megillah] in front of R. Tarfon and the elders in Lod. They said to him: Proof cannot be brought from the testimony of a minor.
R. Judah declares a minor qualified. It has been taught: R. Judah said: When I was a young boy, I read it [the Megillah] in front of R. Tarfon and the elders in Lod. They said to him: Proof cannot be brought from the testimony of a minor.
It has been taught: Rabbi said: When I was a young boy, I read it before R. Judah. They said to him: Proof cannot be brought from the very one who allows it.
Gemara. From where do we know this? Because the verse says, “And these days should be remembered and kept” (Esther 9:28) by day, but not by night. Shall we say that this is a refutation of R. Joshua b. Levi; for R. Joshua b. Levi said: One must read the Megillah by night and a second time by day? When the mishnah taught it, it referred to the day.
Gemara. From where do we know this? Because the verse says, “And these days should be remembered and kept” (Esther 9:28) by day, but not by night. Shall we say that this is a refutation of R. Joshua b. Levi; for R. Joshua b. Levi said: One must read the Megillah by night and a second time by day? When the mishnah taught it, it referred to the day.
Rather R. Zera said: We derive it from here: “And so we worked on; and half of them held the spears from the rising of the morning till the stars appeared” and it says, “That in the night they may be a guard for us, and that we may work in the day” (Nehemiah 4:15-16).
Gemara. From where do we know this? Because the verse says, “And these days shall be mentioned and kept” (Esther 9:28). For reading the Hallel: As it is written, “From the rising of the sun to its going down” (Psalms 113:3). R. Joseph says: Because it is written, “This is the day which the Lord has made” (Psalms 118:24). For the taking of the lulav: As it is written, “And you shall take for yourself on the first day” (Leviticus 23:40).
And for breaking the neck of the heifer. In the school of R. Yannai they said: [The word] “atonement” is applied to it as to holy things. And for the purification of the metzora: as it is written, “This shall be the law of the metzora on the day of his cleansing” (Leviticus 14:2).
This is the general principle: Any matter whose commandment is during the day, is valid all day. Any matter whose commandment is during the day, is valid all day. To include the arrangement of the cup and the removal of the cups, and like R. Yose,
as it has been taught: R. Yose says: If he removed the old [showbread] in the morning and set the new one in the evening, there is no harm.
It includes eating the pesah sacrifice, and it disagrees with R. Elazar b. Azariah, as it has been taught: “And they shall eat the meat on that night” (Exodus 12:8): R. Elazar b. Azariah said: It says here, “On that night”, and it says elsewhere, “And I shall pass through the land of Egypt on that night” (Exodus 12:12): just as there up to midnight [is meant], so too here up to midnight [is meant].
It includes eating the pesah sacrifice, and it disagrees with R. Elazar b. Azariah, as it has been taught: “And they shall eat the meat on that night” (Exodus 12:8): R. Elazar b. Azariah said: It says here, “On that night”, and it says elsewhere, “And I shall pass through the land of Egypt on that night” (Exodus 12:12): just as there up to midnight [is meant], so too here up to midnight [is meant].
GEMARA: A Tanna stated: This is not the case with [the public reading of] the Torah. From where does this rule come? R. Abbahu said: As the verse says, "But as for you, stand here with me" (Deuteronomy 5:28). R. Abbahu also said: Were it not written in the Scripture, it would be impossible for us to say it: as it were, the Holy One, blessed be He, also was standing.
GEMARA: A Tanna stated: This is not the case with [the public reading of] the Torah. From where does this rule come? R. Abbahu said: As the verse says, "But as for you, stand here with me" (Deuteronomy 5:28). R. Abbahu also said: Were it not written in the Scripture, it would be impossible for us to say it: as it were, the Holy One, blessed be He, also was standing.
R. Abbahu further said: How do we know that a rabbi should not sit on a couch and teach his students while they sit on the ground? Because it says, "But as for you, stand here with me." (Deuteronomy 5:27)
One verse says, "And I sat [va'eshev] on the mountain" (Deuteronomy 9:9), and another verse says, "And I stood on the mountain"(Deuteronomy 10:10): Rav says: He [Moses] stood when he learned and sat while he repeated [what he had learned]. R. Hanina said: He was neither sitting nor standing, but stooping. R. Yohanan said: Sitting here means only "staying", as it says, "And you stayed [teshvu] in Kadesh many days" (Deuteronomy 1:46). Rava said: The easy things [he learned] standing and the hard ones sitting
One verse says, "And I sat [va'eshev] on the mountain" (Deuteronomy 9:9), and another verse says, "And I stood on the mountain"(Deuteronomy 10:10): Rav says: He [Moses] stood when he learned and sat while he repeated [what he had learned]. R. Hanina said: He was neither sitting nor standing, but stooping. R. Yohanan said: Sitting here means only "staying", as it says, "And you stayed [teshvu] in Kadesh many days" (Deuteronomy 1:46). Rava said: The easy things [he learned] standing and the hard ones sitting
How do we know that this “passing” means “before”? R. Nahman b. Isaac said: Scripture says, “Then Ahimaaz ran by way of the plain and overran [wa-ya’avor] the Cushite” (II Samuel 18:23). Abaye said: We prove it from here: “And he himself passed over before them” (Genesis 33:3). Or, if you want, I can say: “And their king passed on before them and the Lord at the head of them” (Micah 2:13).
What blessing is said before the reading of the Megillah? Shesheth from Katrazya happened [once to read] in the presence of R. Ashi, and he blessed M”N”H.
Shesheth from Katrazya happened [once to read] in the presence of R. Ashi, and he blessed M”N”H. Blessed are You, O Lord our God, king of the universe, [the God] who fought our fight and judged our judgment and avenged our vengeance and punished our adversaries for us and paid back retribution on all the enemies of our lives. Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel. Rava Says: [The concluding words are], “The God who saves.” R. Papa said: Therefore we should say both: “Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel, the God who saves.”
Shesheth from Katrazya happened [once to read] in the presence of R. Ashi, and he blessed M”N”H. Blessed are You, O Lord our God, king of the universe, [the God] who fought our fight and judged our judgment and avenged our vengeance and punished our adversaries for us and paid back retribution on all the enemies of our lives. Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel. Rava Says: [The concluding words are], “The God who saves.” R. Papa said: Therefore we should say both: “Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel, the God who saves.”
On Mondays and Thursdays and on Shabbat at minhah three read. What do these three represent? R. Assi said: The Torah, the Prophets and the Writings. Rava said: Priests, Levites, and Israelites.
But that which R. Shimi taught, They do not read less than ten verses [of the Torah] in the synagogue, and the verse “And [God] spoke to [Moses saying]” counts as one of the ten:” What do these ten represent?
R. Joshua b. Levi said: The ten men of leisure in the synagogue. R. Joseph said: The ten commandments which were given to Moses on Sinai. R. Levi said: The ten times Hallels [praises] which David said in the book of Psalms.) R. Yohanan said: The ten statements with which the world was created.
R. Joshua b. Levi said: The ten men of leisure in the synagogue. R. Joseph said: The ten commandments which were given to Moses on Sinai. R. Levi said: The ten times Hallels [praises] which David said in the book of Psalms.) R. Yohanan said: The ten statements with which the world was created.
R. Joshua b. Levi said: The ten men of leisure in the synagogue. R. Joseph said: The ten commandments which were given to Moses on Sinai. R. Levi said: The ten times Hallels [praises] which David said in the book of Psalms.) R. Yohanan said: The ten statements with which the world was created.
R. Joshua b. Levi said: The ten men of leisure in the synagogue. R. Joseph said: The ten commandments which were given to Moses on Sinai. R. Levi said: The ten times Hallels [praises] which David said in the book of Psalms.) R. Yohanan said: The ten statements with which the world was created.
“If the middle one reads four verses, he is praiseworthy”, as it has been taught: ‘[The seven lamps] shall give light in front of the candlestick” (Numbers 8:2); this teaches that they leaned in to face the western lamp and the western lamp faced the Shekhinah. And R. Yohanan said: This shows that the middle one is praiseworthy.
“If the last reads four verses he is praiseworthy”: Because of the principle that “in dealing with holy things we go up but never go down.” R. Papa was once in the synagogue of Ave Govar, when the first one [who was called up] read four verses, and R. Papa praised him.
“If the last reads four verses he is praiseworthy”: Because of the principle that “in dealing with holy things we go up but never go down.” R. Papa was once in the synagogue of Ave Govar, when the first one [who was called up] read four verses, and R. Papa praised him.
And Shmuel held that we may divide. But did not R. Hananiah the Bible teacher say: I was in great pain in the house of R. Hanina the Great, for he would not allow me to make [additional verse] divisions except for the school children, because they are there to be taught?
And Shmuel held that we may divide. But did not R. Hananiah the Bible teacher say: I was in great pain in the house of R. Hanina the Great, for he would not allow me to make [additional verse] divisions except for the school children, because they are there to be taught?
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
Rabbah the son of Raba sent to R. Joseph: What is the law? He sent him back: The law is that the verse is repeated, and it is a middle reader who repeats.
No, Rav read as kohen, for R. Huna also read as kohen.
I can understand that R. Huna read as kohen, because even R. Assi and R. Ammi who were important kohanim of Eretz Israel were subject to the authority of R. Huna. But as for Rav, there was Shmuel, who was a kohen and who took precedence over him?
I can understand that R. Huna read as kohen, because even R. Assi and R. Ammi who were important kohanim of Eretz Israel were subject to the authority of R. Huna. But as for Rav, there was Shmuel, who was a kohen and who took precedence over him?
I can understand that R. Huna read as kohen, because even R. Assi and R. Ammi who were important kohanim of Eretz Israel were subject to the authority of R. Huna. But as for Rav, there was Shmuel, who was a kohen and who took precedence over him?
I can understand that R. Huna read as kohen, because even R. Assi and R. Ammi who were important kohanim of Eretz Israel were subject to the authority of R. Huna. But as for Rav, there was Shmuel, who was a kohen and who took precedence over him?
R. Ashi said: But we have not taught this way: This is the general rule: wherever there is a musaf but not a festival four read: What does this come to include? Does it not include a public fast and the ninth of Av?
But according to R. Ashi, who is the author of the Mishnah? It is neither the First Tanna nor R. Yose, as it has been taught: If it [the ninth of Av] falls on Monday or Thursday, three read and one [of them] says a haftarah. If on Tuesday or Wednesday, one reads and [the same] one says the haftarah. R. Yose, however, says that in all cases three read and one [of them] says the haftarah.
But according to R. Ashi, who is the author of the Mishnah? It is neither the First Tanna nor R. Yose, as it has been taught: If it [the ninth of Av] falls on Monday or Thursday, three read and one [of them] says a haftarah. If on Tuesday or Wednesday, one reads and [the same] one says the haftarah. R. Yose, however, says that in all cases three read and one [of them] says the haftarah.
But according to R. Ashi, who is the author of the Mishnah? It is neither the First Tanna nor R. Yose, as it has been taught: If it [the ninth of Av] falls on Monday or Thursday, three read and one [of them] says a haftarah. If on Tuesday or Wednesday, one reads and [the same] one says the haftarah. R. Yose, however, says that in all cases three read and one [of them] says the haftarah.
Or if you like I can say that an important man is different, as R. Elazar; for R. Elazar said: An important man is not permitted to fall on his face unless he is [sure of being] answered like Joshua son of Nun, as it is written, “And God said to Joshua why have you fallen on your face” (Joshua 7:10).
Or if you like I can say that an important man is different, as R. Elazar; for R. Elazar said: An important man is not permitted to fall on his face unless he is [sure of being] answered like Joshua son of Nun, as it is written, “And God said to Joshua why have you fallen on your face” (Joshua 7:10).
But did this cause his lameness? Did not R. Elazar Say: One should never cast words against Heaven, because a great man complained against heaven and he became lame; and who was he? Levi? Both things caused it.
On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six etc. Whose view is that of the Mishnah? It is neither R. Ishmael nor R. Akiba, as it has been taught: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six, and on Shabbat seven. They may not decrease or increase this number, the words of R. Ishmael. R. Akiva says: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur seven and on Shabbat six. They may not decrease this number, but they may increase it.
On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six etc. Whose view is that of the Mishnah? It is neither R. Ishmael nor R. Akiba, as it has been taught: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six, and on Shabbat seven. They may not decrease or increase this number, the words of R. Ishmael. R. Akiva says: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur seven and on Shabbat six. They may not decrease this number, but they may increase it.
On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six etc. Whose view is that of the Mishnah? It is neither R. Ishmael nor R. Akiba, as it has been taught: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six, and on Shabbat seven. They may not decrease or increase this number, the words of R. Ishmael. R. Akiva says: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur seven and on Shabbat six. They may not decrease this number, but they may increase it.
On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six etc. Whose view is that of the Mishnah? It is neither R. Ishmael nor R. Akiba, as it has been taught: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur six, and on Shabbat seven. They may not decrease or increase this number, the words of R. Ishmael. R. Akiva says: On festivals five read, on Yom Kippur seven and on Shabbat six. They may not decrease this number, but they may increase it.
Whom [does the Mishnah follow]? If R. Ishmael, it conflicts with him over the additional number, if R. Akiva, it conflicts with him over the question of six and seven!
Whom [does the Mishnah follow]? If R. Ishmael, it conflicts with him over the additional number, if R. Akiva, it conflicts with him over the question of six and seven!
Rava said: It follows the Tanna of the school of R. Ishmael, for in the school of R. Ishmael it was taught: On festivals five, on Yom Kippur six, on Shabbat seven, they may not add to decrease this number but they may increase it, the words of R. Ishmael.
Rava said: It follows the Tanna of the school of R. Ishmael, for in the school of R. Ishmael it was taught: On festivals five, on Yom Kippur six, on Shabbat seven, they may not add to decrease this number but they may increase it, the words of R. Ishmael.
Rava said: It follows the Tanna of the school of R. Ishmael, for in the school of R. Ishmael it was taught: On festivals five, on Yom Kippur six, on Shabbat seven, they may not add to decrease this number but they may increase it, the words of R. Ishmael.
R. Ishmael is now a difficulty on R. Ishmael! Two tannaim in the name of R. Ishmael.
R. Ishmael is now a difficulty on R. Ishmael! Two tannaim in the name of R. Ishmael.
R. Ishmael is now a difficulty on R. Ishmael! Two tannaim in the name of R. Ishmael.
Who taught the following which has been taught: On festivals people come late to synagogue and leave early. On Yom Kippur they come early and leave late. On Sabbath they come early and leave early? Shall I say it is R. Akiva who makes an extra man [read on Yom Kippur]? You may also say it is R. Ishmael, [his reason being that] the order [of the service] of the day is very long.
Who taught the following which has been taught: On festivals people come late to synagogue and leave early. On Yom Kippur they come early and leave late. On Sabbath they come early and leave early? Shall I say it is R. Akiva who makes an extra man [read on Yom Kippur]? You may also say it is R. Ishmael, [his reason being that] the order [of the service] of the day is very long.
What do these three, five and seven represent? This was a dispute between R. Isaac b. Nahmani and one who was with him, and who was he, R. Shimon b. Pazzi, or, according to others, by R. Shimon b. Pazzi and one who was with him, and who was with him, R. Isaac b. Nahmani, or according to others, R. Shmuel b. Nahmani. One said that [these represent] the [number of Hebrew words in the three verses of the] priestly blessings, while the other said "the three keepers of the door" (II Kings 25:18); [the five represent] "five of them that saw the king's face" (II Kings 25:19) [and the seven] "seven men of them that saw the king's face" (Esther 1:14).
What do these three, five and seven represent? This was a dispute between R. Isaac b. Nahmani and one who was with him, and who was he, R. Shimon b. Pazzi, or, according to others, by R. Shimon b. Pazzi and one who was with him, and who was with him, R. Isaac b. Nahmani, or according to others, R. Shmuel b. Nahmani. One said that [these represent] the [number of Hebrew words in the three verses of the] priestly blessings, while the other said "the three keepers of the door" (II Kings 25:18); [the five represent] "five of them that saw the king's face" (II Kings 25:19) [and the seven] "seven men of them that saw the king's face" (Esther 1:14).
What do these three, five and seven represent? This was a dispute between R. Isaac b. Nahmani and one who was with him, and who was he, R. Shimon b. Pazzi, or, according to others, by R. Shimon b. Pazzi and one who was with him, and who was with him, R. Isaac b. Nahmani, or according to others, R. Shmuel b. Nahmani. One said that [these represent] the [number of Hebrew words in the three verses of the] priestly blessings, while the other said "the three keepers of the door" (II Kings 25:18); [the five represent] "five of them that saw the king's face" (II Kings 25:19) [and the seven] "seven men of them that saw the king's face" (Esther 1:14).
What do these three, five and seven represent? This was a dispute between R. Isaac b. Nahmani and one who was with him, and who was he, R. Shimon b. Pazzi, or, according to others, by R. Shimon b. Pazzi and one who was with him, and who was with him, R. Isaac b. Nahmani, or according to others, R. Shmuel b. Nahmani. One said that [these represent] the [number of Hebrew words in the three verses of the] priestly blessings, while the other said "the three keepers of the door" (II Kings 25:18); [the five represent] "five of them that saw the king's face" (II Kings 25:19) [and the seven] "seven men of them that saw the king's face" (Esther 1:14).
What do these three, five and seven represent? This was a dispute between R. Isaac b. Nahmani and one who was with him, and who was he, R. Shimon b. Pazzi, or, according to others, by R. Shimon b. Pazzi and one who was with him, and who was with him, R. Isaac b. Nahmani, or according to others, R. Shmuel b. Nahmani. One said that [these represent] the [number of Hebrew words in the three verses of the] priestly blessings, while the other said "the three keepers of the door" (II Kings 25:18); [the five represent] "five of them that saw the king's face" (II Kings 25:19) [and the seven] "seven men of them that saw the king's face" (Esther 1:14).
R. Joseph taught: Three, five and seven: "three keepers of the door", "five of them that saw the king's face", and "seven that saw the king's face". Abaye said to him: Up until now why did you not explain this to us? He replied: I did not know that you wanted to know. Did you ever ask me anything which I did not tell you?
Jacob the Min asked R. Judah: What do the six of Yom Kippur represent? He replied: The six who stood at the right of Ezra and the six who stood at his left, as it says, "And Ezra the scribe stood on a stand of wood which they had made for the purpose, and beside him stood Matatyah, Shema and Aniaah and Uriah and Hilkiah and Maasiyah, on his right hand; and on his left hand, Pedaiah, and Mishael and Malchiyah and Hashum and Hashbaddanah, Zechariah, Meshullam" (Nehemiah 8:14).
The question was raised: Should the person who takes the Maftir Aliyah be counted among the seven? R. Huna and R. Jeremiah b. Abba: One said that he does count and the other that he does not count. The one who says he does count, for he too reads, while the
The question was raised: Should the person who takes the Maftir Aliyah be counted among the seven? R. Huna and R. Jeremiah b. Abba: One said that he does count and the other that he does not count. The one who says he does count, for he too reads, while the
But where the subject is not completed, we do not [read less than twenty-one verses]? Didn't R. Shmuel b. Abba say: Many times I stood before R. Yohanan, and when I had read ten verses he said, Stop! In a place where there is a translator it is different, since R. Tahlifa b. Shmuel has taught: They only taught this in a place where there is no translator, but where there is a translator a stop may be made [earlier].