did
12251 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
They said to him: Did you really say this? He replied, No. Rava said: By God! He did say it and I learned it from him.
Why then did he retract? On account of the difficulty raised by R. Mari. For R. Mari raised the following difficulty: After the sanctification of Shiloh there is permission [for altars], but after the sanctification of Jerusalem there is no such permission. We have also taught: After they [the Israelites] came to Jerusalem, the altars were forbidden, and they were never permitted again, and it was the “inheritance.”
Rather it follows the following Tannaim: R. Ishmael son of R. Yose said: Why did the Sages list these? Because when the exiles returned they found these cities [still walled] and sanctified them; the others were annulled when the land’s [sanctity] was annulled. Thus he holds that the first holiness sanctified it for its time but not for the future.
And they raised a contradiction with the following: R. Ishmael son of R. Yose said: Were these all? Has it not already been said, “Sixty cities, all the region of Argob”, And it is written, “All these were fortified cities with high walls” (Deuteronomy 3:4-5)? Why then did the Sages list these? Because when the exiles returned, they found these [still walled] and sanctified them.
Now did we not say that they did not need to be sanctified?! Rather: they found these and listed them.
Now did we not say that they did not need to be sanctified?! Rather: they found these and listed them.
That which was said by R. Shmuel b. Nahmani in the name of R. Yonathan: Every bride who is modest in the house of her father-in-law is rewarded by having kings and prophets among her descendants. How do we know this? From Tamar, as it is written, “And Judah saw her and thought her to be a harlot; for she had covered her face” (Genesis 38:15). . Just because she covered her face did he think her to be a harlot?
Rather, what it means is that because she had covered her face in the house of her father-in-law and he did not know her, she was rewarded by having among her descendants kings and prophets; kings from David, and prophets — as R. Levi said It is a tradition handed down to us from our ancestors that Amoz and Amaziah were brothers’, as it is written, The vision of Isaiah son of Amoz.
Hanina b. Papa began his discourse on this section with the following text: “You have caused men to ride over our heads, we went through fire and through water” (Psalms 66:12). Through fire in the days of the wicked Nebuchadnezzar, and through water in the days of Pharaoh. “But you did bring us out into abundance,” in the days of Haman.
Yohanan began his discourse on this section with the following text: “He has remembered his mercy and his faithfulness to the house of Israel, all the ends of the earth have seen the salvation of our Lord” (Psalms 98:3). When did all the ends of the earth see the salvation of our Lord? In the days of Mordecai and Esther.
Shmuel said from here: “I did not reject them, neither did I abhor them to destroy them utterly” (Leviticus 26:44). “I did not reject them” in the days of the Greeks; “neither did I abhor them” — in the days of Nebuchadnezzar; “to destroy them utterly” — in the days of Haman; “and to break my covenant with them” — in the days of the Persians; “for I am the Lord their God” — in the days of Gog and Magog.
Shmuel said from here: “I did not reject them, neither did I abhor them to destroy them utterly” (Leviticus 26:44). “I did not reject them” in the days of the Greeks; “neither did I abhor them” — in the days of Nebuchadnezzar; “to destroy them utterly” — in the days of Haman; “and to break my covenant with them” — in the days of the Persians; “for I am the Lord their God” — in the days of Gog and Magog.
Shmuel said from here: “I did not reject them, neither did I abhor them to destroy them utterly” (Leviticus 26:44). “I did not reject them” in the days of the Greeks; “neither did I abhor them” — in the days of Nebuchadnezzar; “to destroy them utterly” — in the days of Haman; “and to break my covenant with them” — in the days of the Persians; “for I am the Lord their God” — in the days of Gog and Magog.
Shmuel said from here: “I did not reject them, neither did I abhor them to destroy them utterly” (Leviticus 26:44). “I did not reject them” in the days of the Greeks; “neither did I abhor them” — in the days of Nebuchadnezzar; “to destroy them utterly” — in the days of Haman; “and to break my covenant with them” — in the days of the Persians; “for I am the Lord their God” — in the days of Gog and Magog.
In a baraita it was taught: “I have not rejected them” — in the days of the Chaldeans, when I raised up for them Daniel, Hananiah, Mishael and Azariah; “Neither did I abhor them” — in the days of the Greeks, when I raised up for them Shimon the Righteous and the Hasmonean and his sons, and Mattathias the High Priest; “To destroy them utterly” — in the days of Haman, when I raised up for them Mordecai and Esther; “To break my covenant with them” — in the days of the Persians, when I raised up for them the members of the house of Rabbi and the Sages of the various generations. “For I am the Lord their God” — in the time to come, when no nation or people will be able to rule over them.
“Seven and twenty and a hundred provinces”. R. Hisda said: At first he ruled over seven, then over twenty [more], and finally over a hundred [more]. But if so, [what did you do with the verse], “And the years of the life of Amram were seven and thirty and a hundred years?” (Exodus 6:20). How do you expound this? It is different here, because the whole text is superfluous, since it is written, “From Hodu to Cush,” what would I then do with, “seven and twenty and a hundred provinces”? You must conclude that it is for a special lesson.
(Mnemonic: Sh”S”D”K”) But are there no more? Is there not Solomon? He did not retain his kingdom [till his death].
But was there not Sanheriv, as it is written, “Who are they among all the gods of these countries that have delivered their country out of my hand” (Isaiah 36:20). There was Jerusalem which he did not subdue.
But was there not Darius, as it is written, “Then king Darius wrote unto all the peoples, nations and languages that dwell in all the earth, Peace be multiplied unto you” (Daniel 6:26). There were the seven over which he did not rule, as it is written, “It pleased Darius to set over the kingdom a hundred and twenty satraps” (Daniel 6:2).
Granted all this, how many years are short? Eleven. How long did he reign? Fourteen. Consequently in the fourteenth year of his reign he ought to have rebuilt the Temple. Why then is it written, “Then ceased the work of the house of God which is at Jerusalem” (Ezra 4:24)? Rava said: The years were not full ones.
“And when these days were fulfilled” (Esther 1:5). Rav and Shmuel, One said he was a clever king, and the other said that he was a foolish king. The one who said he was a clever king said that he did well in entertaining his distant subjects first, because he could win over the inhabitants of his own city any time he wished. The one who held that he was foolish says that he ought to have entertained the inhabitants of his city first, so that if the others rebelled against him, these would have supported him.
His disciples asked R. Shimon b. Yohai, Why did the enemies of Israel in that generation deserve extermination? He said to them: You answer. They said: Because they enjoyed the feast of that wicked one. [He said to them]: If so, those in Shushan should have been killed, not those throughout the rest of the world? They then said: You answer. He said to them: It was because they bowed down to an image.
They said to him, Did God then show them favoritism? He replied: They only pretended to worship, and He also only pretended to exterminate them; and so it is written, “For he afflicted not from his heart” (Lamentations 3:33).
“In the court of the garden of the king’s palace” (Esther 1:5). Rav and Shmuel— One said that those who were fit for the court were [entertained] in the court, and those who were fit for the garden in the garden, and those who were fit for the palace in the palace. The other said He first put them in the court, and it did not hold them — Then he took them into the garden and it did not hold them; and finally he had to take them into the palace, and it fit them. In a baraitha it was taught: He took them into the court and opened two doors for them, one into the garden and one into the palace.
“In the court of the garden of the king’s palace” (Esther 1:5). Rav and Shmuel— One said that those who were fit for the court were [entertained] in the court, and those who were fit for the garden in the garden, and those who were fit for the palace in the palace. The other said He first put them in the court, and it did not hold them — Then he took them into the garden and it did not hold them; and finally he had to take them into the palace, and it fit them. In a baraitha it was taught: He took them into the court and opened two doors for them, one into the garden and one into the palace.
None did compel. R. Elazar said: This teaches that each one was given to drink from the wine of his own country. That they should do according to every man’s [ish, ish] pleasure. Rava said: This means that they should do according to the will of Mordecai and Haman. Mordecai [is called ish] as it is written, “A Jewish man;” and Haman, [as it is written], “A man (ish), an adversary and an enemy.”
“And the king was very angry”: Why was he so angry? Rava said: She sent back to him: Son of my father’s stable master, my father drank wine in the presence of a thousand, and did not get drunk, and that man has become senseless with his wine. Straightway, his wrath burned within him.
with good reason, since it is written, “Moab has been at ease from his youth, and he has settled on his lees, and has not been emptied from vessel to vessel, neither has he gone into captivity. Therefore his taste remains in him, and his scent is not changed” (Jeremiah 48:11). Straightway [he did so, as we read], and the next unto him was Carshena, Shethar, Admatha, Tarshish [etc.].
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Carshena: the ministering angels said to the Holy One, blessed be He: Master of the Universe, did they ever offer before you lambs of the first year [karim bene shanah] as Israel offered before You? Shethar: did they ever offer before You two pigeons [shte torim]? Admatha: did they ever build before You an altar of earth [adamah]? Tarshish: did they ever minister before You in the priestly garments, of which it is written [that they contained] a beryl [tarshish], an onyx and a jasper? Meres: did they ever stir [mersu] the blood [of the sacrifice] before You? Marsena: did they ever stir [mersu] the grain-offerings before You? Memukhan: did they ever prepare [hekhinu] a table before Thee?
Rabbah b. Bar Hanah said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: His father was from Benjamin and his mother from Judah. The Rabbis, however, said: The tribes competed with one another [for him]. The tribe of Judah said: I am responsible for the birth of Mordecai, because David did not kill Shimei the son of Gera. And the tribe of Benjamin said: He is actually descended from me.
Rava said: The community of Israel explained [the two designations] in the opposite sense: “See what a Judean did to me and how a Benjamite repaid me!” What a Judean did to me,
Rava said: The community of Israel explained [the two designations] in the opposite sense: “See what a Judean did to me and how a Benjamite repaid me!” What a Judean did to me,
that David did not kill Shimei from whom was descended Mordecai who provoked Haman. “And how a Benjamite repaid me”, that Saul did not slay Agag from whom was descended Haman who oppressed Israel.
that David did not kill Shimei from whom was descended Mordecai who provoked Haman. “And how a Benjamite repaid me”, that Saul did not slay Agag from whom was descended Haman who oppressed Israel.
Yohanan said: He did indeed come from Benjamin. Why then was he called “a Jew”? Because he denied idolatry. For anyone who denies idolatry is called ‘a Jew’, as it is written, “There are certain Jews etc.” (Daniel 3:13).
R. Judah says: Hadassah was her name — Why then was she called Esther? Because she concealed [masteret] the facts about herself, as it says, “Esther did not make known her people or her kindred” (Esther 2:20).
“For she had neither father nor mother…And when her father and mother died” (Esther 2:7). Why did it need to say this again? Aha said: When her mother became pregnant with her, her father died; when she was born, her mother died.
“In the evening she went and in the morning she returned” (Esther 2:14). R. Yohanan From the disgrace of that wicked man we can learn something to his credit, that he did not have sexual relations by day.
“Then the king made a great feast” (Esther 2: 18). He made a feast for her, and she did not tell him [who she was]. He remitted taxes, and she did not tell him. He sent gifts, and she [still] did not tell him.
“Then the king made a great feast” (Esther 2: 18). He made a feast for her, and she did not tell him [who she was]. He remitted taxes, and she did not tell him. He sent gifts, and she [still] did not tell him.
“Then the king made a great feast” (Esther 2: 18). He made a feast for her, and she did not tell him [who she was]. He remitted taxes, and she did not tell him. He sent gifts, and she [still] did not tell him.
“And when the virgins were gathered together the second time, etc” (Esther 2: 19). He went and took counsel from Mordecai who said, The way to cause a woman to be jealous is to show her other women” and even so she did not tell as it says, “And Esther did not reveal her birthplace.”
“And when the virgins were gathered together the second time, etc” (Esther 2: 19). He went and took counsel from Mordecai who said, The way to cause a woman to be jealous is to show her other women” and even so she did not tell as it says, “And Esther did not reveal her birthplace.”
When night came, she said to herself, Now my sister will be put to shame. So she handed over the tokens to her. So it is written, “And it came to pass in the morning that, behold, it was Leah.” Up to now she was not Leah? Rather, what it means is that on account of the tokens which Rachel gave to Leah he did not know until then. Therefore she was rewarded by having Saul among her descendants.
What modesty did Saul display? — As it is written, “But concerning the matter of the kingdom of which Shmuel spoke he told him not” (I Samuel 10:16).He merited that Esther should descend from him. R. Elazar further said: When the Holy One, blessed be He, assigns greatness to a man, he assigns it to his sons and his sons’ sons for all generations, as it says, “[With kings on the throne;] He sets them forever and they are exalted” (Job 36:7). If, however, he becomes arrogant, God humiliates him, as it says, “And if they be bound in fetters etc” (Job 36:8).
"For Esther did the commandment of Mordecai" (Esther 2:20). R. Jeremiah said: [This means] that she used to show her menstrual blood to the Sages. "As when she was brought up with him" (Esther 2:20). Rabbah b. Lema said in the name of Rav: [This means] that she used to rise from the lap of Ahashverosh and bathe and sit in the lap of Mordecai.
R. Yohanan said: Bigtan and Teresh were two Tarseans and conversed in the Tarsean language. They said: From the day this woman came we have been able to get no sleep. Come, let us put poison in the dish so that he will die. They did not know that Mordecai was one of those who had seats in the Chamber of Hewn Stone, and that he understood seventy languages.
“They cast a pur, that is the lot”. A Tanna taught: When the lot fell on the month of Adar, he rejoiced greatly saying: The lot has fallen for me on the month in which Moses died. He did not know, however, that Moses died on the seventh of Adar and was born on the seventh of Adar.
“There is one people” (Esther 3:8): Rava said: No one was ever as skillful at evil language as Haman. He said to Ahashverosh: Come, let us destroy them. He replied: I am afraid of their God, lest He do to me as He did to my predecessors. He replied: They are “negligent” (yashu) of the precepts.
“And the king removed his ring” (Esther 3:10): R. Abba b. Kahana said: This removal of the ring was greater than forty-eight prophets and seven prophetesses who prophesied to Israel; for all these were not able to turn Israel to do good, and the removal of the ring did turn them to do good.
How did they derive it [from the Torah]? R. Hiyya b. Abin said in the name of R. Joshua b. Korha: If for being delivered from slavery to freedom we chant a hymn of praise, should we not do so all the more for being delivered from death to life?
There were actually very many, as it has been taught, Many prophets arose for Israel, double the number of [the Israelites] who came out of Egypt only the prophecy which contained a lesson for future generations was written down, and that which did not contain such a lesson was not written.
R. Shmuel b. Nahmani said: This [Ramataim-Tzophim] means, a man who came from two heights (ramot) which faced (tzophot) one another. R. Hanin said: It means: a man who came from ancestors of the most exalted position (rumo). And who were they? The sons of Korah, as it says, And the sons of Korah did not die. A Tanna taught in the name of our Teacher: A special place was assigned to them in Gehinnom and they stood on it.
Hulda, as it is written, “So Hilkiah the priest and Ahikam and Achbor…and Shafan and Asayah went to Hulda the prophetess” (II Kings 22:14). But if Jeremiah was there, how could she prophesy? It was said in the school of Rav in the name of Rav: Hulda was a near relative of Jeremiah, and he did not object to her doing so.
“Now when Mordecai knew all that was done” [etc.] (Esther 4:1). What did he cry out? Rav said: He said: Haman has raised himself above Ahashverosh. Shmuel said: The upper king has prevailed over the lower king.
“And they told Mordecai Esther’s words.” But he did not go to him on this occasion. This shows us that a recalcitrant answer need not be taken back [by the messenger].
“Let the king and Haman come to a banquet” (Esther 5:4). Our Rabbis taught: What did Esther see that she invited Haman? R. Elazar said: She set a trap for him, as it says. “Let their table before them become a snare” (Psalms 69:23). R. Joshua said:
Rabbah said: [She said], “Pride goes before the fall” (Proverbs 16:18). Abaye and Rava both of whom said: [She said], “With their poison I will prepare their feast” (Jeremiah 51:39). Rabbah b. Abbuha found Elijah and said to him: Which of these reasons prompted Esther to act as she did? He replied: [All] the reasons given by all the Tannaim and all the Amoraim.
“Then said Harbonah,” (Esther 7:9) etc. R. Elazar said: Even Harbonah was a wicked man and was part of that plot. When he saw that his plan was not succeeding, he at once abandoned, and so it is written, “And he cast on him and did not pity, from his hand he surely flees” (Job 27:22).
“And he fell upon his brother Benjamin’s necks” (Genesis 45:14). How many necks did Benjamin have? R. Elazar said: He wept for the two Temples which were destined to be in the territory of Benjamin and to be destroyed. “And Benjamin wept upon his neck”: he wept for the tabernacle of Shiloh which was destined to be in the territory of Joseph and to be destroyed.
These were necessary. For it might have occurred to you to understand “hear” as did the Sages. Therefore God wrote “and they shall be.”
What reason did they have for saying “understanding” after holiness? Because it says, “They shall sanctify the Holy One of Jacob and shall stand in awe of the God of Israel” (Isaiah 29:23), and next to this, “They also that err in spirit shall come to understanding” (Isaiah 29:24). What reason did they have for saying “repentance” after “understanding”? Because it is written, “Understanding with their heart, they will repent and be healed” (Isaiah 6:10).
What reason did they have for saying “understanding” after holiness? Because it says, “They shall sanctify the Holy One of Jacob and shall stand in awe of the God of Israel” (Isaiah 29:23), and next to this, “They also that err in spirit shall come to understanding” (Isaiah 29:24). What reason did they have for saying “repentance” after “understanding”? Because it is written, “Understanding with their heart, they will repent and be healed” (Isaiah 6:10).
But what did you see to rely on this verse? Rely rather on the other! There is written another verse, “Who forgives all your iniquity, who heals all your diseases, who redeems your life from the pit”(Psalms 103:3-4). This implies that redemption and healing come after forgiveness. But it is written, “And he will repent and be healed”? That refers not to the healing of sickness but to the healing [power] of forgiveness.
What reason did they have for saying redemption in the seventh blessing? Rava said: Because they [Israel] are destined to be redeemed in the seventh year [of the coming of the Messiah], therefore the mention of redemption was placed in the seventh blessing. But a Master has said, In the sixth year will be thunder, in the seventh wars, at the end of the seventh the son of David will come? War is also the beginning of redemption.
But say that he did this before worship? Do not think such a thing. For it is written, “And he came down from offering the sin-offering.” Is it written ‘to offer’? It is written, “from offering.”
What did you see to rely on this verse? Why not rely on the other? It is reasonable that worship and thanksgiving are one.
Since hundred and twenty elders, among whom were many prophets, established the prayers in the proper order, what did Shimon the Pakulite arrange? They forgot them, and he went back and arranged them.
If one reads it with interruptions [serugin], he has fulfilled his obligation. The Rabbis did not know the meaning of serugin. They heard the maidservant of Rabbi’s household, saying to the rabbis on seeing them enter at intervals, “How long are you going to come in serugin serugin?
The Rabbis did not know the meaning of haluglugot. One day they heard the maidservant of the household of Rabbi, on seeing a man peeling purslane, say to him, How long will you be peeling your haluglugot?
The Rabbis did not know the meaning of “Salseleah and she will exalt you” (Proverbs 4:8). One day they heard the maidservant of the house of Rabbi say to a man who was curling his hair, she said to him: How long will you be mesalsel with your hair?
The Rabbis did not know the meaning of, “Cast upon the Lord your yehav” (Psalms 55:23) Rabbah b. Bar Hanah said: One day I was travelling with a certain Arab and was carrying a load, and he said to me, “Lift up your yehav and put it on [one of] the camels.”
The Rabbis did not know the meaning of “And ta’atihah bemetateh of destruction” (Isaiah 14:23). They heard the maidservant of Rabbi’s household say to her friend, ” “Take the broom ta’atitah and sweep (ta’ate) the house.
R. Hisda found R. Hananel writing scrolls without a written copy. He said to him: The whole Torah could be written by you by heart, but the Sages have ruled: It is forbidden to write one letter except from a copy. Since he said: The whole Torah could be written by you by heart, we may conclude that he could produce them correctly. But we see that R. Meir actually did write? In case of emergency it is different.
Abaye allowed the members of the household of Bar Habu to write tefillin and mezuzot without a copy. Whose authority did he follow? The following Tanna, as it has been taught: R. Jeremiah says in the name of our Teacher: Tefillin and mezuzot may be written out without a copy, and do not require to be written upon ruled lines.
GEMARA. Rava said: They taught this only if he intends to return on the night of the fourteenth; but if he does not mean to return on the night of the fourteenth, he reads with the rest. Rava said: From where do I derive this ruling? As it is written, “Therefore do the Jews of the villages who dwell in the unwalled towns” (Esther 9:19). Since it is written, “the Jews of the villages” why did it need to write, “who dwell in the unwalled towns”? This teaches us that one who is a villager for one day is called a villager.
He who says that the whole of it must be read [interprets thus]: What did Ahashverosh see to make him use the vessels of the Temple? “In that matter”, in that he reckoned seventy years and they had not yet been redeemed; “And what came upon them?” That he killed Vashti.
He who says that it is to be read from “After these things,” [interprets thus]: What did Haman see to make him provoke all the Jews? “In that matter”, that Mordecai did not bow down or prostrate himself; “And what came upon him”? They hung him and his sons on the tree.
He who says that it is to be read from “After these things,” [interprets thus]: What did Haman see to make him provoke all the Jews? “In that matter”, that Mordecai did not bow down or prostrate himself; “And what came upon him”? They hung him and his sons on the tree.
He who says that it is to be read from “On that night” interprets thus: What did Ahashverosh see to make him order them to bring the Chronicles? “In that matter” that Esther invited Haman with him. “And what came upon them”? A miracle occurred.
Why did they not say to him: Proof cannot be brought from the testimony of a minor? They gave one answer and then another. First, they said, you were a boy and moreover, even had you been an adult, proof cannot be brought from the very one who allows it.
Rav said he should repeat. Why did he not say “divide”? He was of opinion that any verse which Moses had not divided, we may not divide.
And Shmuel held that we may divide. But did not R. Hananiah the Bible teacher say: I was in great pain in the house of R. Hanina the Great, for he would not allow me to make [additional verse] divisions except for the school children, because they are there to be taught?
Shmuel said that he divides. Why did he not say that he repeats? It is a decree to prevent error on the part of those coming in and going out.
Come and hear: Rav happened to be at Babylon during a public fast. He got up and read in the scroll [of the Torah]. He blessed when he began but he did not bless when he finished. The whole congregation [afterwards] fell on their faces, but Rav did not fall on his face.
Come and hear: Rav happened to be at Babylon during a public fast. He got up and read in the scroll [of the Torah]. He blessed when he began but he did not bless when he finished. The whole congregation [afterwards] fell on their faces, but Rav did not fall on his face.
Since Rav read as a lay Israelite, why did he not bless after finishing? Was it not because another was to read after him?
It is also reasonable to assume that Rav read as kohen, because if you should think that he read as an Israelite, why did he say a blessing before reading? It was after the enactment.
but did not go out [during the Torah reading].
The text [above stated]: Rav happened to be in Babylon on a public fast day. He got up forward and read in the Torah scroll. He blessed before beginning, but when he finished he did not bless. The whole congregation [subsequently] fell on their faces, but Rav did not fall on his face. Why did not Rav fall on his face?
The text [above stated]: Rav happened to be in Babylon on a public fast day. He got up forward and read in the Torah scroll. He blessed before beginning, but when he finished he did not bless. The whole congregation [subsequently] fell on their faces, but Rav did not fall on his face. Why did not Rav fall on his face?
The text [above stated]: Rav happened to be in Babylon on a public fast day. He got up forward and read in the Torah scroll. He blessed before beginning, but when he finished he did not bless. The whole congregation [subsequently] fell on their faces, but Rav did not fall on his face. Why did not Rav fall on his face?
Let him then go among the congregation and fall on his face? He did not want to trouble the congregation. Or if you like I can say that Rav usually spread out his hands and feet [when he fell on his face], and he followed the opinion of Ulla, who said, The Torah forbade only the spreading out of the hands and feet.
But let him fall on his face without spreading out his hands and feet? He did not want to change his custom.