do
12645 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
Our rabbis taught: One who has to perform many commandments [simultaneously] shall say, “Blessed . . . who has sanctified us by His commandments and commanded us concerning the commandments.” R. Judah said: One must recite a blessing over each one separately. R. Zera or, as some say, R. Hanina b. Papa said: The halakhah is according to R. Judah. R. Zera or, as some say, R. Hanina b. Papa further stated: What is the reason of R. Judah? Because it is written, “Blessed be the Lord day by day” (Psalms 68:20). Now do we bless Him by day and not by night? Rather this comes to teach you: Give Him every day His appropriate blessings. So too here: Give Him for every single thing, its appropriate blessings.
What do they disagree about? One Master holds that it is set aside only for the performance of its commandment, while the other Master holds that that it is set aside for the whole day.
The following dispute is based on the same principles] as the one between R. Yohanan and Resh Lakish. For it was stated: If one set apart seven etrogs for the seven days: Rav said: He may fulfil his obligation with each one and eat it immediately. R. Assi said: He may fulfil his obligation with each one and eat it the next day. What do they argue about? One Master holds that it is set apart for its mitzvah while the other holds that it is set apart for the whole day.
And as for us who have two days [of the Festival] what are we to do? Abaye said: On the eighth day which may be the seventh it is forbidden; on the ninth day which may be the eighth, it is permitted. Meremar said: Even on the eighth day, which may be the seventh, it is permitted.
the blessing. According to him who regards the day as the seventh in respect of the Sukkah, we also recite the blessing [of the Sukkah], while according to him who holds that it is regarded as the eighth in respect of both, we do not recite the blessing [of the Sukkah]. R. Yoseph said: Hold fast to the ruling of R. Yohanan, since R. Huna b. Bizna and all the greats of his generation were in a Sukkah on the eighth day which may have been the seventh, they sat there, but they did not recite the blessing.
There are those who say that all agree that one does not recite the blessing [on the Sukkah], and that they only disagree over whether one must sit [in the Sukkah] according to the one who ruled that it is regarded as the seventh day in respect of the Sukkah, we must indeed sit in it, while according to the one who ruled that it is regarded as the eighth day in respect of both, we do not even sit in it. R. Yoseph said:... Hold fast to the ruling of R. Yohanan. For who is the authority of the statement? R. Judah the son of R. Shmuel b. Shilath, and he himself sat outside the Sukkah on the eighth day which might be the seventh. And the law is that we must indeed sit in the Sukkah but may not recite the blessing.
R. Yohanan said: We recite the blessing of the season (shehiyanu) on the Eighth Day of the Festival [of Sukkot], but we do not recite the blessing of the season on the seventh day of Pesah.
Can we say that [the following statement] supports [the view of R. Yohanan]: The bullocks, the rams and the lambs each prevent the fulfillment of the other. But R. Judah says, The bullocks do not prevent the fulfillment of the other, since they diminish in number progressively.
Does R. Judah hold that the Eighth Day requires staying overnight? Has it not been taught: R. Judah says: From where do we know that Pesah Sheni does not require staying overnight? As it is said, "And you shall turn in the morning and go to you tents" (Deuteronomy 16:7) and [immediately afterwards] it is written, "Six days you shall eat matzot" thus implying that that which has six days [of observance] requires staying overnight, but that which does not have six days [of observance] does not require staying overnight. What does this exclude? Does this not exclude also the Eighth Day of the festival?
For it has been taught: R. Judah said "And you shall set it down" (Deuteronomy 26:8)— this refers to waving. You say that it refers to waving but perhaps it means literally "setting it down"? When it says, "And set it down," (26:4) setting down is mentioned. How then do I fulfill, "And you shall set it down"? That refers to waving
What is the decision? R. Nahman said: We say [the blessing of the] season on the Eighth Day of the Festival But R. Shesheth said: We do not say [the blessing of the] season on the Eighth Day of the Festival. And the law is that we say [the blessing of the] season on the Eighth Day of the Festival.
GEMARA. How do we know this? As our Rabbis taught, The verse], “And you shall be altogether joyful” (Deuteronomy 16:15) includes the night of the last day of the Festival. But perhaps it only refers to [the night of] the first day of the Festival? When it says, “akh” it divides.
GEMARA. If he has no vessels to remove, what should he do? If he has no vessels! What then did he use when he was in [his Sukkah]? Rather say: If he had no place to put his vessels what shall he do? R. Hiyya b. Ashi said, He removes four handbreadths [of the roof], And R. Joshua b. Levi said, he should kindle a lamp in it.
GEMARA. If he has no vessels to remove, what should he do? If he has no vessels! What then did he use when he was in [his Sukkah]? Rather say: If he had no place to put his vessels what shall he do? R. Hiyya b. Ashi said, He removes four handbreadths [of the roof], And R. Joshua b. Levi said, he should kindle a lamp in it.
In fact, however, they do not disagree, the latter referring to us [Babylonians], and the former to them [the Palestinians].
GEMARA. From where do we know this? R. Ena said, As the verse says, “You shall draw water with rejoicing” (Isaiah 12:3).
And this is what R. Elazar said: What is the implication of the text, “It has been told to you, O man, what is good, and what the Lord requires of you: Only to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?” (Micah 6:8): ‘To do justly’ means [to act in accordance with] justice; ‘to love mercy’ refers to acts of loving kindness’, ‘and to walk humbly with your God’ refers to attending to funerals and providing a bride with a dowry for her wedding. Now can we not make an a fortiori deduction: If in matters which are normally performed publicly the Torah says ‘to walk humbly’, how much more so in matters that are normally done privately?
And this is what R. Elazar said: What is the implication of the text, “It has been told to you, O man, what is good, and what the Lord requires of you: Only to do justly, and to love mercy, and to walk humbly with thy God?” (Micah 6:8): ‘To do justly’ means [to act in accordance with] justice; ‘to love mercy’ refers to acts of loving kindness’, ‘and to walk humbly with your God’ refers to attending to funerals and providing a bride with a dowry for her wedding. Now can we not make an a fortiori deduction: If in matters which are normally performed publicly the Torah says ‘to walk humbly’, how much more so in matters that are normally done privately?
R. Elazar stated: Greater is he who performs charity than [he who offers] all the sacrifices, for it is said, “To do charity and justice is more acceptable to the Lord than sacrifice” (Proverbs 21:3). R. Elazar further stated: Acts of loving kindness (gemilut hasadim) are greater than charity (tzedakah), for it is said, “Sow to yourselves according to your charity (tzedakah), but reap according to your hesed” (Hosea 10: 12); when one sows, it is doubtful whether he will eat [the harvest] or not, but when one reaps, he will certainly eat.
R. Elazar further stated: He who performs acts of charity and justice is regarded as though he had filled all the world with kindness, for it is said, “He who loves charity and justice, he has filled the earth with the loving kindness of God” (Psalms 33:5). But lest you say that whoever wishes to do good succeeds without difficulty, Scripture says, “How precious is Your loving kindness, O God” (Psalms 36:8). One might say that this applies also one who fears God, Scripture says, “But the loving kindness of the Lord is from everlasting time to everlasting time on those that fear Him” (Psalms 103:17).
If he were to bring it in a sanctified vessel it would have been rendered invalid by remaining in there overnight. Hezekiah said: Ministering vessels do not sanctify their contents where there was no intention, but [the use of a sanctified vessel was here forbidden] as a preventive measure lest it be assumed that there was intention that the contents should be sanctified.
R. Yannai said in the name of R. Zera: You may even say that there is a fixed amount for the water [of libation] and that ministering vessels of ministry do not sanctify their contents unless there was intention, [but the use of a sanctified vessel was nevertheless forbidden] as a preventive measure lest people will think that it was filled with the water for the purpose of using it for the washing of the hands and the feet [of the High Priest].
R. Yoseph said: From where do I derive that the dispute concerns only [the flute that accompanies the sacrifices]? From that which has been taught: Ministering vessels made of wood: Rabbi declares them invalid and R. Yose b. Judah declares them valid. Now do they not differ on this: the one who declares them valid is of the opinion that the essential feature of the [Temple] music is with an instrument and [its validity may, therefore,] be deduced from that of the reed-flute of Moses. While he who holds them to be invalid is of the opinion that the essential feature of the Temple music is the vocal singing and its validity, therefore, cannot be deduced from that of the reed-flute of Moses?
R. Yoseph said: From where do I derive that the dispute concerns only [the flute that accompanies the sacrifices]? From that which has been taught: Ministering vessels made of wood: Rabbi declares them invalid and R. Yose b. Judah declares them valid. Now do they not differ on this: the one who declares them valid is of the opinion that the essential feature of the [Temple] music is with an instrument and [its validity may, therefore,] be deduced from that of the reed-flute of Moses. While he who holds them to be invalid is of the opinion that the essential feature of the Temple music is the vocal singing and its validity, therefore, cannot be deduced from that of the reed-flute of Moses?
No; both of them may agree that the essential feature of the [Temple] music is with an instrument, but in this case they differ over whether we may deduce what it is possible [to manufacture from another material] from that which it is impossible [to manufacture from another material]. He who declares them valid is of the opinion that we do deduce that which it is possible [to manufacture from another material], from that which is impossible [to manufacture from another material], whereas he who holds them to be invalid is of the opinion that we do not deduce the possible from the impossible.
No; both of them may agree that the essential feature of the [Temple] music is with an instrument, but in this case they differ over whether we may deduce what it is possible [to manufacture from another material] from that which it is impossible [to manufacture from another material]. He who declares them valid is of the opinion that we do deduce that which it is possible [to manufacture from another material], from that which is impossible [to manufacture from another material], whereas he who holds them to be invalid is of the opinion that we do not deduce the possible from the impossible.
And if you want you may say that all are in agreement that the essential feature of the [Temple] music is the vocal singing, and that we do not deduce the possible from the impossible, but in this case they differ on the question whether, in making the deduction concerning the candlestick, we apply the principle of “the general and the particular” or the rule of “inclusion and exclusion.” Rabbi applies the principle of “the general and the particular” while R. Yose b. Judah applies the principle of “exclusion and inclusion.”
R. Hanina b. Antigonus says: They were Levites. Now do they not differ on the following principles: He who says that they were slaves is of the opinion that the essential feature of the [Temple] music was the vocal singing, while he who says that they were Levites holds the opinion that the essential feature of the [Temple] music was the instrument?
But do you really think this? What then does R. Yose really hold? If he is of the opinion that the essential feature of the [Temple] music was the singing, then even slaves [should be allowed to play the instruments], and if he is of the opinion that the essential feature was the instrument, then only Levites should [be allowed to play] but not Israelites?
they were slaves holds that we don’t elevate from the platform to genealogy; he who says that they were Israelites [from good families] holds that we that we do elevate from the platform for matters of genealogy, but not for tithes; while he who says that they were Levites holds that we do elevate from the platform for matters of genealogy and tithes.
they were slaves holds that we don’t elevate from the platform to genealogy; he who says that they were Israelites [from good families] holds that we that we do elevate from the platform for matters of genealogy, but not for tithes; while he who says that they were Levites holds that we do elevate from the platform for matters of genealogy and tithes.
But how could they do so? Is it not written, “All this [do I give you] in writing as the Lord has made me wise by His hand upon me?” (I Chronicles 28:19).
But how could they do so? Is it not written, “All this [do I give you] in writing as the Lord has made me wise by His hand upon me?” (I Chronicles 28:19).
4) Solomon called it the enemy, as it is said, “If your enemy is hungry, give him bread to eat and if he is thirsty give him water to drink. For you will heap coals of fire upon his head, and the Lord will reward you” (Proverbs 25:21); do not read, “will reward you” but “will cause it to be at peace with you.”
It was taught: And they were superior to the son of Martha bat Baytos It was said of the son of Martha the daughter of Boethus, that he could take two sides of a huge ox which cost one thousand zuz and walk with them, heel to toe, but the Sages would not permit him to do so because in the multitude of the people is the King’s glory.
It was taught: They said of R. Shimon b. Gamaliel that when he rejoiced at the Simchat Bet Hashoevah, he used to take eight fire torches and throw them in the air and catch one and throw one and they did not touch one another; and when he prostrated himself, he used to dig his two thumbs in the ground, bend down, kiss the ground, and stand himself up again, a feat which no other man could do, and this is what is meant by Kidah.
We are the Lord’s and our eyes are turned to the Lord etc But can it be so? Did not R. Zera say, One who says Shema, Shema is as though he said Modim, Modim [and he is silenced]? Rather this is what they used to say, “They worshipped toward the east” but as for us we give thanks to the Lord, and to the Lord do our eyes hope.”
But do we postpone it? Have we not in fact learned: The fats [of offerings performed on] Shabbat may be offered on Yom Kippur; And R. Zera stated:
R. Yohanan said: To let people know that the New Moon has been fixed at its proper time. Do we then use this as a distinguishing sign? Do we not in fact use another distinguishing sign, as we have learned: “The fats of the Morning Tamid offering were placed on the lower half of the Ascent [of the altar] on its east side, while those of the additional offerings were placed on the lower half of the Ascent on its west side; while those of the New Moon were placed beneath the rim of the altar below,”
R. Yohanan said: To let people know that the New Moon has been fixed at its proper time. Do we then use this as a distinguishing sign? Do we not in fact use another distinguishing sign, as we have learned: “The fats of the Morning Tamid offering were placed on the lower half of the Ascent [of the altar] on its east side, while those of the additional offerings were placed on the lower half of the Ascent on its west side; while those of the New Moon were placed beneath the rim of the altar below,”
And we who keep two days [of the Festival], how do we proceed? Abaye ruled: The [paragraph for the] second day is to be omitted. Raba ruled,
You may even say that it represents the view of the Rabbis, for do not two watches still require the casting of lots?
R. Elazar stated: These seventy bulls [that were offered during the seven days of the Festival], to what do they correspond? To the seventy nations. To what does the single bull [of the Eighth Day] correspond?
R. Yohanan said: Woe to the idolaters, for they had a loss and do not know what they have lost.When the Temple was in existence the altar atoned for them, but now who shall atone for them?
Our Rabbis taught: From where do we know that all the watches share equally in the sacrifices of the Festival? Scripture says, "And he comes with all the desire of his soul ... and he serves" (Deuteronomy 18:6). It might have been that the same applies to all the days of the year, Scripture says "From one of your gates" [meaning this:] I have said so, [says the Lord], Only when all Israel enters by one gate.
And in the division of the showbread. Our Rabbis taught: From where do we know that all the watches share equally in the division of the showbread?
Scripture says, "They shall receive equal portions to eat," (Deuteronomy 18:8) meaning, as the division of the service [is equal for all], so is the division of the food. Now what food [could this mean]? If you will say that it means the sacrifices, do we not deduce that from a different verse, "It shall be the priest's that offers it?" (Leviticus 7:9). Rather this must refer to the showbread.
Rav Judah said: [And so too] do they divide the musaf offerings. They objected: "The outgoing watch offered the morning Tamid and the musaf offerings, and the incoming watch offered the evening Tamud and the incense dishes" and it does not state, that they divided the musaf offerings? — This Tanna does not deal with the question of division.
It goes well according to the one who stated that this watch was late in arriving, since for this reason the whole course might be penalized; but according to the one who stated that it was because of Miriam the daughter of Bilgah who apostatized, do we penalize [even a] father on account of his daughter? Abaye said: Indeed, as people say, “The talk of a child in the market-place, is either that of his father or of his mother.” May we then penalize the whole watch on account of her father or mother?
R. Judah says in the name of Ben Bathyra: Of those who go before the ark as readers on the concluding day of the feast of Tabernacles, the last one should make mention of the rain, but the first one should not do so; conversely, on the opening day of Passover the first is to mention the rain, but not the last.
How do these verses bear out the idea?
But whence do we know that it is in the prayer that one is to mention the rain?
Some say that R. Abahu had a tradition for this statement; others maintain that he had a Baraita as his authority. What Baraita? The Baraita reads as follows: At what time should one begin to mention the Power of rain? R. Eliezer says: At the time one begins to wave the lulab; R. Joshua says: At the time when it is discarded. Said R. Eliezer: Inasmuch as the Four Species are used only in order to obtain the favor of God that He may give rain, one must argue that just as these four species cannot exist without water, so the world cannot exist without rain. R. Joshua replied: Is not rain during the feast of Tabernacles but the sign of divine displeasure? Said R. Eliezer, I did not say that one should pray for rain, but that one should make mention of it. For just as one mentions the resurrection of the dead throughout the year, although it is to take place at a particular time only, so one may mention also the rain during the whole year, although it is to fall only at a given time, and hence if one actually desires to mention it throughout the year, he may do so.
R. Joshua might answer, that it is quite right to mention the resurrection of the dead (during the year), because resurrection would always be in time whenever it came, but is it true of rain that it would be in time whenever it came? Do we not read: If rain falls after Nisan is passed it is a sign of a curse?
We read in a Baraita: The Sages did not make it obligatory to mention the dew and the winds in the prayer, but if one wishes to mention them, he may do so. What is the reason? Said R. Ḥanina, because dew and winds are never withheld. Whence do we know that dew is never withheld? It is written (I Kings, 17.1): "And Elijah the Tishbite, who was of the settlers of Gilead, said unto Ahab: 'As the Lord, the God of Israel, liveth, before whom I stand, there shall not be dew nor rain these years, but according to my word.'" Further on it is written (ib. 18.1): "Go show thyself unto Ahab, and I will send rain upon the land," but dew is not mentioned. Now, what is the reason for this omission? Certainly the reason is
We read in a Baraita: The Sages did not make it obligatory to mention the dew and the winds in the prayer, but if one wishes to mention them, he may do so. What is the reason? Said R. Ḥanina, because dew and winds are never withheld. Whence do we know that dew is never withheld? It is written (I Kings, 17.1): "And Elijah the Tishbite, who was of the settlers of Gilead, said unto Ahab: 'As the Lord, the God of Israel, liveth, before whom I stand, there shall not be dew nor rain these years, but according to my word.'" Further on it is written (ib. 18.1): "Go show thyself unto Ahab, and I will send rain upon the land," but dew is not mentioned. Now, what is the reason for this omission? Certainly the reason is
Whence do we know that winds are not withheld? Scripture says (Zech., 2.10): "For I have spread you abroad as the four winds of the heaven, saith the Lord." Now what did God mean to say? Did the Holy One, blessed be He, intend to say: I have scattered you to the four corners of the world? If so, why ke-arba' ("as the four")? He should have said be-arba' ("to the four")! The verse therefore means to intimate that just as the world cannot exist without the four winds, so it could not exist without Israel.
Said R. Ḥanina: If, during the summer months, one says in the prayer: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again correctly, but if he says: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read it over again; during the winter months if he fails to say: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again, but if he fails to say: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read the prayer over again. Moreover, even if he says: "He causes the wind to subside and the dew to vanish," we do not order him to read the prayer over again.
Said R. Ḥanina: If, during the summer months, one says in the prayer: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again correctly, but if he says: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read it over again; during the winter months if he fails to say: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again, but if he fails to say: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read the prayer over again. Moreover, even if he says: "He causes the wind to subside and the dew to vanish," we do not order him to read the prayer over again.
Said R. Ḥanina: If, during the summer months, one says in the prayer: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again correctly, but if he says: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read it over again; during the winter months if he fails to say: "He causes the wind to blow," we do not order him to read the prayer over again, but if he fails to say: "He causes the rain to fall," we order him to read the prayer over again. Moreover, even if he says: "He causes the wind to subside and the dew to vanish," we do not order him to read the prayer over again.
We read in a Baraita: The Sages did not make it obligatory to mention the clouds and the winds, but if one wishes to mention them, he may do so. What is the reason? The reason is that they are never withheld. Are they not withheld? Did not R. Joseph transmit the tannaitic teaching: "The verse (Deut., 11.17): 'He will shut up the heaven,' indicates the withholding of clouds and winds; I say 'clouds and winds,' is it not possible, you may object, that it indicates only the withholding of rain? No, for Scripture adds (in the same verse): 'and there shall be no rain,' rain is thus explicitly stated; what then is implied in the preceding 'He will shut up the heaven'? No doubt the withholding of clouds and winds?" Evidently, then, this (teaching of R. Joseph) contradicts that of the preceding Baraita as regards both clouds and winds! No, there is no contradiction as regards clouds, because the Baraita refers to clouds that appear before the rain (which are not withheld), while R. Joseph refers to such as appear after the rain (which are withheld). Nor is there a contradiction as regards winds, for the one refers to common (moderate) winds (which are not withheld), the other to uncommon (strong) winds (which are withheld). But are not even strong winds needed for winnowing? Winnowing can be done with sieves.
R. 'Ashi said: A scholar who is not hard like iron is not a real scholar, as it is said: "And like a hammer that breaketh the rock in pieces." Said R. 'Abba to R. 'Ashi, you derive it from that verse, we derive it from the following (Deut. 8.9): "A land whose stones are iron"; do not read 'ābānēha (its stones), but bōnēha (its builders, i.e., the scholars). Said Rabina: It is nevertheless one's duty to train oneself to be gentle, as it is said (Eccl., 11.10): "Remove anger from thy heart and put away evil from thy flesh."
R. Judah says in the name of Ben Bathyra, of those who go before the ark, etc. A contradiction was pointed out (by quoting the following Mishnah): Until what time is one to pray for rain? R. Judah says, until Passover is over; R. Jose says, until after Nisan. Said R. Ḥisda, there is no contradiction, for the one passage of the Mishnah refers to praying, the other to mentioning; one may continue to pray until the end of Passover, but the mention of rain must cease on the first day. Said 'Ulla, what is here said by R. Ḥisda is "as vinegar to the teeth, and as smoke to the eyes" (Prov., 10.26), for if one is allowed to mention the rain even when one is not allowed to pray for it, is it not logical that one should be allowed to mention it also at times when one is allowed to pray for it? 'Ulla therefore suggested that there existed two different recensions of R. Judah's statement. R. Joseph said, do you know what "until Passover is over" means? It means until the time for the first reader of the first day of the festival is over. 'Abbayi, however, objected: Is there any opportunity at all to mention rain in the holiday prayer? Yes, answered R. Joseph, the Interpreter prays for rain. Does the Interpreter ever pray for anything which is not needed by the congregation? 'Ulla's answer is, therefore, the best. Rabbah said, do you know what "until Passover is over" means? It means until the time for slaughtering the Pascal lamb is over, for the discontinuing of the reference to rain must be like the beginning thereof: Just as in the beginning one mentions the rain, although one does not pray for it, so also at the end of the season one should mention it though not pray for it. 'Abbayi objected: It is quite correct at the beginning of the season to mention the rain without praying for it, because the mention is to serve the purpose of propitiating (God) preparatory to praying, but at the end of the season, what need is there for propitiation (since it is not to be followed by praying)? It is therefore best to accept the answer of 'Ulla.
R. Judah says in the name of Ben Bathyra, of those who go before the ark, etc. A contradiction was pointed out (by quoting the following Mishnah): Until what time is one to pray for rain? R. Judah says, until Passover is over; R. Jose says, until after Nisan. Said R. Ḥisda, there is no contradiction, for the one passage of the Mishnah refers to praying, the other to mentioning; one may continue to pray until the end of Passover, but the mention of rain must cease on the first day. Said 'Ulla, what is here said by R. Ḥisda is "as vinegar to the teeth, and as smoke to the eyes" (Prov., 10.26), for if one is allowed to mention the rain even when one is not allowed to pray for it, is it not logical that one should be allowed to mention it also at times when one is allowed to pray for it? 'Ulla therefore suggested that there existed two different recensions of R. Judah's statement. R. Joseph said, do you know what "until Passover is over" means? It means until the time for the first reader of the first day of the festival is over. 'Abbayi, however, objected: Is there any opportunity at all to mention rain in the holiday prayer? Yes, answered R. Joseph, the Interpreter prays for rain. Does the Interpreter ever pray for anything which is not needed by the congregation? 'Ulla's answer is, therefore, the best. Rabbah said, do you know what "until Passover is over" means? It means until the time for slaughtering the Pascal lamb is over, for the discontinuing of the reference to rain must be like the beginning thereof: Just as in the beginning one mentions the rain, although one does not pray for it, so also at the end of the season one should mention it though not pray for it. 'Abbayi objected: It is quite correct at the beginning of the season to mention the rain without praying for it, because the mention is to serve the purpose of propitiating (God) preparatory to praying, but at the end of the season, what need is there for propitiation (since it is not to be followed by praying)? It is therefore best to accept the answer of 'Ulla.
Said R. 'Asi in the name of R. Johanan, the law is in accordance with R. Judah. Said R. Zera to R. 'Asi: Did R. Johanan really say so? Did we not read (above, p. 2): On the third of Marḥeshwan we begin to pray for rain; R. Gamaliel says on the seventh thereof. Now R. Eleazar, commenting upon the statement, said, the law is in accordance with R. Gamaliel! Said R. 'Asi: Do you pit one authority (R. Eleazar) against another (R. Johanan)?! Moreover, I can say that there is no contradiction between the two, for the one refers to praying and the other to mentioning. But did not R. Johanan say, whenever one prays for rain one also mentions it? This statement refers only to the time of discontinuation. But was not reference made to both, R. Johanan saying explicitly, when one begins to mention the rain he begins to pray for it, and when he stops praying for it he stops mentioning it? Nevertheless there is no difficulty, for in the one statement he has reference to us (the Babylonians), in the other to them (the Palestinians). Why such difference? Is it because we have produce in the field? (Then there should be no difference, because) they have pilgrims! R. Johanan speaks of the time after the destruction of the Temple. Now that we have arrived at this point we can say that both statements have reference to them (Palestinians), and yet there will be no contradiction, for the one refers to the time before, and the other to that after the destruction of the Temple.
What is the proper course for us, who keep two festival days? Rab says, we should begin to mention the rain in the Musaf prayer (of the first day), omit the mention in the Afternoon, Evening, and Morning prayers, and take it up again in the Musaf prayer (of the second day). Samuel, however, said to the scholars (who reported Rab's view): go and say to 'Abba: "After having declared the day holy, art thou going to declare it again a week-day?" Samuel then decided that one should begin to mention the rain in the Musaf prayer and continue to do so in the Afternoon prayer, but omit it in the Evening and Morning prayer and take it up again in the Musaf prayer.
R. Naḥman further asked R. Isaac, how do you explain the verse (Hos., 11.9): "The Holy One in the midst of thee, and I will not enter into the city?" Surely it can not mean, because the Holy One is in the midst of thee, I shall not enter into the city?! "Thus said R. Johanan," R. Isaac replied, "the Holy One, blessed be He, meant to say: I will not enter into the heavenly Jerusalem until I can enter into the earthly Jerusalem." But is there a heavenly Jerusalem? Yes, for it is written (Ps., 122.3): "Jerusalem, that art builded as a city that is compact together."
R. Naḥman further asked R. Isaac, how do you explain the verse (Jer. 10.8): "But they are altogether brutish and foolish: the vanities by which they are instructed are but a stock"? "Thus said R. Johanan," replied R. Isaac, "there is one thing that sweeps the wicked into Gehenna, and that is idolatry; for Scripture has here: 'the vanities by which they are instructed are but a stock,' and elsewhere (ib., 10, 15): 'They are vanity, a work of delusion.'"
R. Naḥman further asked R. Isaac, how do you explain the verse (ibid., 2.13): "For My people have committed two evils: They have forsaken Me, the fountain of living waters?" Only two did they commit? Did they not commit also twenty-two other evils? Or did He remit twenty two? "Thus said R. Johanan," replied R. Isaac, "(they committed) one that
R. Naḥman further asked R. Isaac, how do you explain the verse (I Sam., 8.1): "And it came to pass, when Samuel was old"? Did Samuel become old at all? Indeed, Samuel only reached the age of 52, for it is said (Mo'ed Ḳaṭan, 28a) that if one dies at the age of 52, he has attained to the age reached by Samuel the Ramathite. "Thus said R. Johanan," replied R. Isaac, "Samuel grew old prematurely, for it is said (ibid., 15.11): 'It repenteth me that I have set up Saul to be king, for he is turned back from following Me, and hath not performed My commandments. And it grieved Samuel; and he cried unto the Lord all night,' saying: Master of the world! Thou hast declared me equal to both Moses and Aaron, for it is written (Ps., 99.6): 'Moses and Aaron among His priests, and Samuel among them that call upon His name.' Now just as their work was not destroyed during their life-time, so should my work not be destroyed during my life-time. The Holy One, blessed be He, then said to Himself, what shall I do? Shall I cause Saul to die? Samuel will not let me. Shall I cause Samuel to die? Seeing he is still young, people will speak ill of him. Shall I spare both Saul and Samuel? The time for the kingdom of the house of David has arrived, and the term set for one kingdom must not overlap that of another even by a hair's breadth. Immediately Samuel was overtaken by old age, and hence it is written (I Sam., 22.6): 'And Saul was sitting in Gibeah, under the tamarisk tree in Ramah.' Now what relation is there between Gibeah and Ramah? The idea therefore is that what had enabled Saul to sit (as king) in Gibeah two and a half years was the prayer of Samuel the Ramathite." But is the life of one man set aside (cut short) on account of that of another? Yes, for R. Samuel b. Naḥamani said in the name of R. Jonathan: What is the meaning of the verse (Hos., 6.5): "Therefore have I hewed them by the prophets; I have slain them by the words of My mouth"? It is not said by the works of their hands, but "by the words of My mouth", which proves that one man may be set aside on account of another.
R. Naḥman further asked R. Isaac, how do you explain the verse (I Sam., 8.1): "And it came to pass, when Samuel was old"? Did Samuel become old at all? Indeed, Samuel only reached the age of 52, for it is said (Mo'ed Ḳaṭan, 28a) that if one dies at the age of 52, he has attained to the age reached by Samuel the Ramathite. "Thus said R. Johanan," replied R. Isaac, "Samuel grew old prematurely, for it is said (ibid., 15.11): 'It repenteth me that I have set up Saul to be king, for he is turned back from following Me, and hath not performed My commandments. And it grieved Samuel; and he cried unto the Lord all night,' saying: Master of the world! Thou hast declared me equal to both Moses and Aaron, for it is written (Ps., 99.6): 'Moses and Aaron among His priests, and Samuel among them that call upon His name.' Now just as their work was not destroyed during their life-time, so should my work not be destroyed during my life-time. The Holy One, blessed be He, then said to Himself, what shall I do? Shall I cause Saul to die? Samuel will not let me. Shall I cause Samuel to die? Seeing he is still young, people will speak ill of him. Shall I spare both Saul and Samuel? The time for the kingdom of the house of David has arrived, and the term set for one kingdom must not overlap that of another even by a hair's breadth. Immediately Samuel was overtaken by old age, and hence it is written (I Sam., 22.6): 'And Saul was sitting in Gibeah, under the tamarisk tree in Ramah.' Now what relation is there between Gibeah and Ramah? The idea therefore is that what had enabled Saul to sit (as king) in Gibeah two and a half years was the prayer of Samuel the Ramathite." But is the life of one man set aside (cut short) on account of that of another? Yes, for R. Samuel b. Naḥamani said in the name of R. Jonathan: What is the meaning of the verse (Hos., 6.5): "Therefore have I hewed them by the prophets; I have slain them by the words of My mouth"? It is not said by the works of their hands, but "by the words of My mouth", which proves that one man may be set aside on account of another.
Our Rabbis have taught (Sifrē, Deut. § 42): The former rain is called yoreh (Deut., 11.14), because it teaches the people to plaster their roofs, to gather in their fruit, and to make all other preparations for the winter. Another opinion is that it is so called because it falls gently, not vehemently. Still another opinion is: because it saturates the earth and waters it to its very depth, as it is said (Ps., 65.11): "Watering her ridges abundantly, settling down the furrows thereof. Thou makest her soft with showers; Thou blessest the growth thereof." But is it not possible that it is so called because of its damaging effect in making the fruit drop (from the trees) and in washing away the seeds? No, because Scripture has here also malḳōsh (the latter rain), and just as the latter rain comes as a blessing, so also the former rain. But may not the latter rain be called malḳōsh because it causes the houses to fall, breaks the trees, and brings the crickets? No, because Scripture has in the same verse also yoreh (the former rain), and just as the former rain comes as a blessing, so also the latter rain. But whence do you know that the former rain is a blessing? From the following verse (Joel 2.23): "Be glad then, ye children of Zion, and rejoice in the Lord your God; for He giveth you the former rain in just measure."
R. 'Abahu further said: The first rainfall is satisfactory if there is enough of it to enter the ground to the depth of a handbreadth; the second is satisfactory when the soil is fit to be used for sealing the mouth of a cask. R. Ḥisda said: If there is rainfall enough to make the soil fit to be used for sealing the mouth of a cask, the verse in Deuteronomy (11.17): "He will shut up (the heavens)," etc., has no application. R. Ḥisda further said: If rain fell before the reading of the verse just mentioned in the Shema', the verse in question no longer has application. Said 'Abbayi, this applies to the Shema' read in the evening, but if rain falls before the reading of the Shema' in the morning, the verse in question still has application, for R. Samuel, son of R. Isaac, said (Berakot, 59a): Those morning clouds have no real value, as it is written (Hos., 6.4): "Your goodness is as a morning cloud, and as the dew that early passeth away." Said R. Papa to 'Abbayi: But do not people say: "If there is rain at the opening of the doors (in the morning)—lay down thy bag, O ass-driver, and sleep"? That is no contradiction, for the proverb refers to a case when the rain pours down from a heavy cloud, while R. Samuel refers to a case when the rain comes from a light cloud.
Said R. Ḥisda: Auspicious is the year whose Ṭēbēt is a widow (without rain). Some say this is so because in that case the fields do not have to lie waste; others say, because the grain of such a year will not be subject to blast. But did not R. Ḥisda say: Auspicious is the year whose Ṭēbēt is slushy (rainy)? This is no contradiction, for in the one case he has in mind a year in which there was rain previously, in the other a year in which there was no rain during the previous months.
R. Jeremiah said to R. Zera: Come, Master, teach me something. R. Zera replied: My heart feels faint, and I cannot do it. Then (said R. Jeremiah) tell me something haggadic. R. Zera thereupon said: Why is it written (Deut., 20.19): "For man is the tree of the field?" Is man, indeed, a tree of the field? But the explanation is this: Having said immediately before: "for thou mayest eat of them, and thou shalt not cut them down," the Bible adds the expression in question to intimate that if a scholar is a worthy man, thou mayest eat (learn) from him and shalt not cut him down, but if not, thou shalt destroy and cut him down.
R. Ḥama b. Ḥanina said: What is the meaning of the verse (Prov., 27.17): "Iron sharpeneth iron; so a man sharpeneth the countenance of his friend"? It indicates that just as one piece of iron sharpens the other, so do scholars sharpen one another's minds in the study of the Law.
R. Ḥisda said: Rain is withheld only on account of the neglect to give the heave-offering and the tithes, as it is said, "Drought and heat consume the snow waters." How do you derive your statement? Answer: A disciple of the school of R. Ishmael said: On account of the things which I have commanded you for the summer and which you did not carry out, you will be deprived of the snow waters in the winter.
Rabbah b. R. Huna said: A man who is insolent may be called wicked to his face, as it is said (Prov., 21.29): "A wicked man hardeneth his face." R. Naḥman b. Isaac said, it is commendable to hate him, as it is said (Eccl., 8.1): "And the hardness of his face is changed," do not read yeshunne (is changed), but yissane (is hated).
R. 'Ami further said: What is the meaning of the verse (Eccl., 10.10): "If the iron be blunt and one do not whet the edge"? If thou seest a generation over which the heavens are as tough as iron, sending neither dew nor rain, it is due to the people's corrupt deeds, as it is said, "and one do not whet the edge." What is the remedy? They should pray much, as it is said (ibid.): "Then must he put to more strength, but wisdom is profitable to direct," the latter part of which means to say that the additional praying will prove more profitable if the people's deeds are still good. Resh Laḳish explains it thus: When thou seest a scholar
R. 'Ami further said: What is the meaning of the verse (Eccl., 10.10): "If the iron be blunt and one do not whet the edge"? If thou seest a generation over which the heavens are as tough as iron, sending neither dew nor rain, it is due to the people's corrupt deeds, as it is said, "and one do not whet the edge." What is the remedy? They should pray much, as it is said (ibid.): "Then must he put to more strength, but wisdom is profitable to direct," the latter part of which means to say that the additional praying will prove more profitable if the people's deeds are still good. Resh Laḳish explains it thus: When thou seest a scholar
to whom his studies are as tough as iron, it is because his lesson is not properly ordered in his mind, as it is said, "and one do not whet the edge." What is his remedy? He should attend more diligently the sessions of the scholars, as it is said, "then must he put to more strength, but wisdom is profitable to direct," the latter part of which means to say that increased diligence will prove still more profitable if the scholar's studies have always been well ordered. Resh Laḳish used to arrange his studies in proper order forty times, corresponding to the forty days during which the Torah was given to Israel, before he appeared before R. Johanan. R. 'Adda b. 'Ahabah used to arrange his lessons in proper order twenty-four times, corresponding to the number of the books of the Pentateuch, Prophets, and Hagiographa, before he appeared before Raba.
Raba explained the above verse as follows: If thou seest a disciple to whom his studies are as tough as iron, it is due to his master's lack of kindness toward him, as it is said, "and one do not whet the edge." What is his remedy? He should send many friends to the master, as it is said, "then must he put to more strength, but wisdom is profitable to direct," which means to say that the intercession of the friends will prove the more profitable when prior to that the pupil's ways had been improved before his master.
R. 'Ami further said: What is the meaning of the verse (Eccl., 10.11): "If the serpent bite before it is charmed, then the charmer hath no advantage"? When thou seest a generation over whom the heavens are rust-colored like copper and do not let down dew or rain, it is because there are no whisperers in that generation. What is their remedy? They should turn to one who understands to whisper and he shall whisper. But if he who understands to whisper is unwilling to do it—what benefit will there accrue to him? Again, if he does whisper and obtains his desire, but then becomes presumptuous, he brings wrath upon the world, as it is said (Job, 36.33): "The cattle also concerning the storm that cometh up."
R. 'Ami further said: What is the meaning of the verse (Eccl., 10.11): "If the serpent bite before it is charmed, then the charmer hath no advantage"? When thou seest a generation over whom the heavens are rust-colored like copper and do not let down dew or rain, it is because there are no whisperers in that generation. What is their remedy? They should turn to one who understands to whisper and he shall whisper. But if he who understands to whisper is unwilling to do it—what benefit will there accrue to him? Again, if he does whisper and obtains his desire, but then becomes presumptuous, he brings wrath upon the world, as it is said (Job, 36.33): "The cattle also concerning the storm that cometh up."
R. 'Ami further said: One's prayer is not accepted unless he puts his heart in his hands, as it is said (Lam., 3.41): "Let us lift up our heart with our hands unto God in the heavens." After R. 'Ami had left, R. Samuel b. Nahamani placed an Amora by his side and discoursed as follows: "But they beguiled Him with their mouth, and lied unto Him with their tongue. For their heart was not steadfast with Him, neither were they faithful in His covenant." And yet "He, being full of compassion, forgiveth iniquity" (Ps., 78.36-38). Do not R. 'Ami and R. Samuel contradict one another? No, one refers to individual, the other to communal, prayers.
In the days of R. Samuel b. Nahamani there was a famine accompanied with pestilence. Said the Rabbis, what are we to do? One cannot pray at once for the cessation of two afflictions; let us therefore pray for the staying of the pestilence and let us suffer famine. But R. Samuel b. Nahamani advised: Let us pray for the cessation of the famine, for when the Merciful gives plenty, He gives it to the living, as it is said (Ps., 145.16): "Thou openest Thy hand and satisfiest every living thing with favour." But whence do we know that it is not proper to pray for two things at the same time? It is written (Ezra, 8.23): "So we fasted and besought our God for this." The word "this" implies that there was yet another thing to pray for. In Palestine it was derived in the name of R. Zera from this verse (Dan., 2.18): "That they would desire mercies of the God of heaven concerning this secret." The implication of "this" is that there was also another thing to be desired.
In the days of R. Samuel b. Nahamani there was a famine accompanied with pestilence. Said the Rabbis, what are we to do? One cannot pray at once for the cessation of two afflictions; let us therefore pray for the staying of the pestilence and let us suffer famine. But R. Samuel b. Nahamani advised: Let us pray for the cessation of the famine, for when the Merciful gives plenty, He gives it to the living, as it is said (Ps., 145.16): "Thou openest Thy hand and satisfiest every living thing with favour." But whence do we know that it is not proper to pray for two things at the same time? It is written (Ezra, 8.23): "So we fasted and besought our God for this." The word "this" implies that there was yet another thing to pray for. In Palestine it was derived in the name of R. Zera from this verse (Dan., 2.18): "That they would desire mercies of the God of heaven concerning this secret." The implication of "this" is that there was also another thing to be desired.
Another time R. Johanan again met the same child and said to him: Tell me thy verse! The boy replied: "The foolishness of man perverteth his way; and his heart fretteth against the Lord" (Prov., 19.3). After pondering for a while over the matter R. Johanan said, is it possible that there is something in the Hagiographa to which Moses did not allude in the Pentateuch? Said the boy: "Is not this verse alluded to in the Pentateuch? Is it not written (Gen., 42.28): 'And their heart failed them, and they turned trembling one to another, saying, what is this that God hath done unto us?'" R. Johanan lifted his eyes and looked at the boy (in astonishment). The boy's mother then came in and took him away, saying: "Get away from him, that he may not do to you as he did to your father!"
R. Johanan further said: Rain is granted for the sake of an individual, means of sustenance are granted for the sake of a multitude only. That rain is granted for the sake of an individual we learn from the verse (Deut., 28.12): "The Lord will open unto thee His good treasure, the heaven, to give the rain of thy land." That means of sustenance are granted for the sake of a multitude only, we learn from the verse (Exod., 16.4): "Behold I will cause to rain bread from heaven for you." But are not means of sustenance granted also for the sake of an individual? Do we not read: "R. Jose b. Judah said, three good leaders have arisen for Israel; they are Moses, Aaron and Miriam; and three precious gifts were presented to Israel for their sake. These are, the well, the pillar of cloud and the manna. The well was given for the merits of Miriam, the pillar of cloud for the merits of Aaron, and the manna for the merits of Moses. When Miriam died the well was taken away, for it is said (Num., 20.1): 'And Miriam died there,' and immediately after it is written: 'And there was no water for the congregation.' Subsequently the well came back on account of the merits of Moses and Aaron. When Aaron died the pillar of cloud disappeared, as it is said (ibid., 21.1): 'And the Canaanite, the king of Arad, heard.' What did he hear? He heard that Aaron had died and the clouds of glory were taken away from Israel, so he thought that now permission was given to wage war against them. Therefore it is written (ibid., 20.29): 'And all the congregation saw that Aaron was dead,' [concerning which R. 'Abahu said that one should not read 'they saw,' but 'they were seen'—agreeing herein with what Resh Laḳish said, namely, that ki (כי) has four meanings: if, perhaps (lest), but, because]. Both (well and cloud) later came back on account of the merits of Moses, but when Moses died all three disappeared, as it is said (Zech., 11.8): 'And I cut off the three shepherds in one month.' But is it true that they died in one month? Did not Miriam die in Nisan, Aaron in Ab, and Moses in Adar? The meaning therefore can only be that the three precious gifts which had been given to Israel through them were taken away in one month." Now, does it not follow from the foregoing Baraita that means of sustenance are granted also for the sake of an individual?! Moses is an exception; since all his requests were for a multitude, he was himself regarded as a multitude.
Resh Laḳish was likewise of the opinion that rain is granted also for the sake of an individual, for he said, whence do we infer that rain is granted for the sake of an individual? It is written (Zech., 10.1): "Ask ye of the Lord rain in the time of the latter rain, even of the Lord that maketh lightnings; and He will give them showers of rain, to every one grass in the field." Now, from the words "He will give them," one might conclude that He gives it only when everybody needs it; Scripture therefore adds "to every one"; but if it said only "to every one," we might think that He gives it only when that one needs it for all his fields; Scripture therefore says "field" (singular); but the word "field" might still be understood to mean a whole (large) field; Scripture therefore says "grass." This finds its illustration in the following case: R. Daniel b. R. Ḳeṭina had a garden which he used to examine every day, and say: This bed needs rain, and this one does not need it. The next day it was found that rain fell upon the one, but not upon the other.
Who is meant by "individuals"? Said R. Huna, Scholars. R. Huna further said, the individuals fast three days, Monday, Thursday and Monday. What does he teach us? Do we not read: Public fasts should not be decreed to begin on Thursday in order not to cause a sudden rise in market prices, but the first three fast-days should be in the order of Monday, Thursday, and Monday? Answer. You might think that this refers only to congregational fasts but not to the fasts of individuals, therefore he teaches us (that it applies also to fasts of individuals). The same is taught in a Baraita: Individuals fast three days, Monday, Thursday and Monday, but must refrain from fasting if these days coincide with the New moon
Our Rabbis have taught: Not every one who wants to act as a distinguished individual may do so, but students may; this is the view of R. Meir; R. Jose says, everybody is entitled thereto and deserves to be well thought of, for so acting brings him no distinction, but rather causes him suffering.
Another Baraita reads: Not every one who wishes to act as a distinguished individual is entitled to do so; students, however, are entitled thereto: this is the view of R. Simeon b. Eleazar, Rabban Simeon b. Gamaliel says, if it is a case where acting as a distinguished individual would bring him distinction, he may not do so, if it would bring him suffering, he is well entitled to it.
Another Baraita reads: Not every one who wishes to act as a distinguished individual is entitled to do so; students, however, are entitled thereto: this is the view of R. Simeon b. Eleazar, Rabban Simeon b. Gamaliel says, if it is a case where acting as a distinguished individual would bring him distinction, he may not do so, if it would bring him suffering, he is well entitled to it.
Our Rabbis have taught: If one is fasting for the recovery of a sick person and in the meantime the person has recovered, or for the relief from some affliction and in the meantime the affliction has passed, he must nevertheless fast to the end of the day. One who, while fasting, goes from a place where the people fast to a place where they do not fast, must fast to the end of the day; if he goes from a place where the people do not fast to a place where they fast, he must fast with the latter. If, forgetting his fast, he ate or drank, he must not make it appear before the people, nor must he indulge himself in delicacies.
Our Rabbis have taught: If one is fasting for the recovery of a sick person and in the meantime the person has recovered, or for the relief from some affliction and in the meantime the affliction has passed, he must nevertheless fast to the end of the day. One who, while fasting, goes from a place where the people fast to a place where they do not fast, must fast to the end of the day; if he goes from a place where the people do not fast to a place where they fast, he must fast with the latter. If, forgetting his fast, he ate or drank, he must not make it appear before the people, nor must he indulge himself in delicacies.
"And Jacob said unto his sons, Why do ye look one upon another?" (Gen., 42. 1). Said R. Judah in the name of Rab, Jacob said to his sons, make no show of your plenty before the sons of Esau and of Ishmael, lest they become jealous of you.
"See that ye fall not out by the way" (ib., 45.24)—Joseph said to his brethren, Do not engage in discussions of the Law, lest the road become unsafe for you. This cannot be so! For R. 'El'ai b. Berechiah said: Two scholars who travel on the road and do not discuss among themselves the words of the Torah deserve to be burned, as it is said (II Kings, 2. 11): "And it came to pass, as they still went on, and talked, that behold, there appeared a chariot of fire and horses of fire, which parted them both asunder," which shows that the reason they were saved (from the fire) was that there was talking (about the Torah) among them, but had there been none, they would not have been saved! This is no contradiction, for in the one case reference is had to the mere recitation of one's studies, in the other to the speculation about them.
"See that ye fall not out by the way" (ib., 45.24)—Joseph said to his brethren, Do not engage in discussions of the Law, lest the road become unsafe for you. This cannot be so! For R. 'El'ai b. Berechiah said: Two scholars who travel on the road and do not discuss among themselves the words of the Torah deserve to be burned, as it is said (II Kings, 2. 11): "And it came to pass, as they still went on, and talked, that behold, there appeared a chariot of fire and horses of fire, which parted them both asunder," which shows that the reason they were saved (from the fire) was that there was talking (about the Torah) among them, but had there been none, they would not have been saved! This is no contradiction, for in the one case reference is had to the mere recitation of one's studies, in the other to the speculation about them.
We read in a Baraita: Joseph instructed his brethren, do not march in wide (hasty) steps, and bring the sun into town. "Do not march in wide (hasty) steps," because it was said a wide step takes away one five-hundredth of one's eye-sight, and "bring the sun into town," because it was said by R. Judah in the name of Rab, one should always enter (town) in day-time and leave it in day-time, for it is said (Gen., 44. 3): "As soon as the morning was light, the men were sent away."