should
12262 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
R. Eliezer, who holds that Purim is observed in Adar I makes sense for there is a principle that one should never pass up an opportunity to perform a mitzvah. But why would R. Shimon b. Gamaliel hold that Purim is delayed until Adar II.
R. Tabi says that R. Shimon b. Gamaliel wanted the redemption of Purim to be close to the redemption of Pesah. Therefore, they should be observed in adjacent months.
Against the proof of R. Akiva it may be objected that [verse should be interpreted like] R. Elazar, who said that these words show that to every man she appeared to belong to his own nation.
Against the proof of R. Meir it may be objected that perhaps that [verse should be interpreted like] R. Hiyya b. Abba who said that Bigtan and Teresh were two men from Tarsis.
We have learned elsewhere: If any who has incurred the penalty of karet is flogged — they are exempt from karet, as it says, “Lest your brother should be dishonored in your eyes” (Deuteronomy 25:3) once he has been flogged, he is like thy brother, the words of R. Hananiah b. Gamaliel. R. Yohanan said: R. Hananiah b. Gamaliel’s colleagues disagreed with him on this point.
But cannot this be deduced logically [as follows]? If he defiles bed and seat, should he not [all the more] be required to count seven days?
He replied: If you would think that that text is for the purpose of excluding, then the text could simply omit the word. And should you say, we could then derive the rule [that he is to count seven days] by a logical deduction, such a deduction could be confuted by the case of the woman who counts day for day.
And should you say that this word is required to show that the text refers to one who is cleansed of his issue [only] and not [of his issue and] his leprosy. If so let the verse say, “And when he that has an issue is cleansed” and no more. Why do I have “from his issue”? This teaches that one with an issue who has two observations is required to count seven days.
And should you reply that that is so, [how can this be] seeing that it states, There is no difference between a metzora who is under observation and one declared to be a definite metzora except the disheveling of hair and tearing the clothes., from which it may be inferred that in the matter of being sent out [of the camp] and defiling by entrance they are on the same footing?
Abaye said to him: How have you explained the other statement? As referring to their script. [If so], why should it say, “A Hebrew text written in Aramaic or an Aramaic text written in Hebrew”? The same would apply even to a Hebrew text which is written in Hebrew or an Aramaic text which is written in Aramaic, for it also teaches “until it is written in Assyrian on a scroll in ink”!
(Deuteronomy 17:3) "And he went and served other gods which I commanded should not be served."
They also wrote for him (Leviticus 11:6); “the beast with small legs” and they did not write “the hare” because the name of Ptolemy’s wife was hare, lest he should say, “The Jews are playing with me at me and put the name of my wife in the Torah.”
GEMARA. The pesah sacrifice and nothing else? Rather we should say, things like the pesah.
His disciples asked R. Shimon b. Yohai, Why did the enemies of Israel in that generation deserve extermination? He said to them: You answer. They said: Because they enjoyed the feast of that wicked one. [He said to them]: If so, those in Shushan should have been killed, not those throughout the rest of the world? They then said: You answer. He said to them: It was because they bowed down to an image.
None did compel. R. Elazar said: This teaches that each one was given to drink from the wine of his own country. That they should do according to every man’s [ish, ish] pleasure. Rava said: This means that they should do according to the will of Mordecai and Haman. Mordecai [is called ish] as it is written, “A Jewish man;” and Haman, [as it is written], “A man (ish), an adversary and an enemy.”
None did compel. R. Elazar said: This teaches that each one was given to drink from the wine of his own country. That they should do according to every man’s [ish, ish] pleasure. Rava said: This means that they should do according to the will of Mordecai and Haman. Mordecai [is called ish] as it is written, “A Jewish man;” and Haman, [as it is written], “A man (ish), an adversary and an enemy.”
Also Vashti the queen made a feast for the women in the royal house. It should have said, “the women’s house”? Rava said: Both of them [Ahashverosh and Vashti] intended to transgress. This is what people say, He with large pumpkins and his wife
That every man should reign in his house. Rava said: Had it not been for these first letters, there would have been left no shred or remnant of the [enemies of] Israel.
People said: What does he mean by sending us word that every man should reign in his own house? Of course he should! Even a weaver in his own house must be commander!
People said: What does he mean by sending us word that every man should reign in his own house? Of course he should! Even a weaver in his own house must be commander!
“There was a certain Jew in the fortress Shushan. a Benjamite.” What does this say? If it is to give the pedigree of Mordecai, it should trace it right back to Benjamin! Why then were only these specified?
What modesty did Saul display? — As it is written, “But concerning the matter of the kingdom of which Shmuel spoke he told him not” (I Samuel 10:16).He merited that Esther should descend from him. R. Elazar further said: When the Holy One, blessed be He, assigns greatness to a man, he assigns it to his sons and his sons’ sons for all generations, as it says, “[With kings on the throne;] He sets them forever and they are exalted” (Job 36:7). If, however, he becomes arrogant, God humiliates him, as it says, “And if they be bound in fetters etc” (Job 36:8).
Should you say that I will make a void in your kingdom, they are “scattered abroad among the peoples”. Should you say: There is some profit in them, I reply, “they are dispersed” [nifredu], like an isolated bough [peridah] that does not bear fruit. Should you say that they occupy one province, I reply, “they are in all the provinces of your kingdom”.
Should you say that I will make a void in your kingdom, they are “scattered abroad among the peoples”. Should you say: There is some profit in them, I reply, “they are dispersed” [nifredu], like an isolated bough [peridah] that does not bear fruit. Should you say that they occupy one province, I reply, “they are in all the provinces of your kingdom”.
Should you say that I will make a void in your kingdom, they are “scattered abroad among the peoples”. Should you say: There is some profit in them, I reply, “they are dispersed” [nifredu], like an isolated bough [peridah] that does not bear fruit. Should you say that they occupy one province, I reply, “they are in all the provinces of your kingdom”.
How did they derive it [from the Torah]? R. Hiyya b. Abin said in the name of R. Joshua b. Korha: If for being delivered from slavery to freedom we chant a hymn of praise, should we not do so all the more for being delivered from death to life?
If that is the reason we should say Hallel also? — [We do not do so] because Hallel is not said for a miracle which occurred outside of the land of Israel. How then can we say Hallel for the Exodus from Egypt which was a miracle which occurred outside the land of Israel?
“Abigail”, as it is written, “And it was so, as she rode on her donkey and came down by the hidden side of the mountain” (II Samuel 25:20). “By the hidden side [seter] of the mountain”? It should say “from the mountain”!
R. Yohanan said Jeremiah was not there, as he had gone to bring back the ten tribes. From where do we know that they returned? Because it is written, “For the seller shall not return to that which is sold” (Ezekiel 7:13). Now is it possible that after the Jubilee had already ceased the prophet should prophesy that it will cease? The fact is that it teaches that Jeremiah brought them back. Josiah the son of Amon ruled over them,
“Esther,” as it is written, “Now it came to pass on the third day that Esther clothed herself in royalty” (Esther 5:1). Surely it should say, “royal clothing”? What it shows is that she clothed herself in the Holy Spirit. It is written here, “And she clothed”, and it is written in another place, “Then the spirit clothed Amasai..” (I Chronicles 12:18).
The Rabbis taught: There have been four beautiful women in the world — Sarah, Rahab, Abigail and Esther. According to the one who says that Esther was green, Vashti should be inserted in place of Esther.
“Now it came to pass on the third day that Esther put on royalty” (Esther 5:1). Surely it should say, “royal clothing”? R. Elazar said in the name of R. Hanina: This tells us that the holy spirit clothed her. It is written here, “and she put on,” and it is written elsewhere, “And a spirit clothed Amasai” (I Chronicles 12:19).
“Yet all this is worth nothing to me” (Esther 5:13). R. Elazar said in the name of R. Hanina: Just because he saw Mordecai sitting in the king’s gate, was this any reason why he should say, ‘Yet all this is worth nothing to me?” As R. Hisda said, for R. Hisda said: The one came [to the court] as with his wealth and the other
She learned to do so from her father’s house, as it says. “If your enemy be hungry give him bread to eat” (Proverbs 25:21-22). R. Meir said: so that he should not form a conspiracy and rebel. R. Judah said:
So that they should not discover that she was a Jew. R. Nehemiah said: So that Israel should not say, We have a sister in the palace, and so should neglect [to pray for] mercy. R. Yose said: So that he should always be at hand for her. R. Shimon b. Menassiah said: [She said], Perhaps God will notice and perform a miracle for us
So that they should not discover that she was a Jew. R. Nehemiah said: So that Israel should not say, We have a sister in the palace, and so should neglect [to pray for] mercy. R. Yose said: So that he should always be at hand for her. R. Shimon b. Menassiah said: [She said], Perhaps God will notice and perform a miracle for us
So that they should not discover that she was a Jew. R. Nehemiah said: So that Israel should not say, We have a sister in the palace, and so should neglect [to pray for] mercy. R. Yose said: So that he should always be at hand for her. R. Shimon b. Menassiah said: [She said], Perhaps God will notice and perform a miracle for us
So that they should not discover that she was a Jew. R. Nehemiah said: So that Israel should not say, We have a sister in the palace, and so should neglect [to pray for] mercy. R. Yose said: So that he should always be at hand for her. R. Shimon b. Menassiah said: [She said], Perhaps God will notice and perform a miracle for us
“And they were read.” This teaches that they were read of themselves. And it was found [being] written. It should say, a writing [ketav] was found? This shows that
“Then Haman took the clothes and the horse.” He went and found [Mordecai] with the Rabbis sitting before him while he showed them the rules of the “handful.” When Mordecai saw him approaching and leading the horse, he became frightened and said to the Rabbis: This villain is coming to kill me. Get out of his way so that you should not be burned by his ember. Mordecai thereupon drew his robe around him and stood up to pray. Haman came in and sat down before them and waited until Mordecai had finished his prayer.
He came into the house, and there “Haman was falling upon the couch.” “Falling”? It should say, “had fallen”? R. Elazar said: This teaches us that an angel came and made him fall on it. Ahashverosh then said: Trouble inside, trouble outside! “And the king said, Will he also try to overcome the queen with me in the house?” (Esther 7:8)
should fall into the very mistake from which he himself had suffered? For Rava b. Mehasia said in the name of R. Hami b. Guria, who said it in the name of Rav: Through two sela’s weight of fine silk which Jacob gave to Joseph more than what he gave to his brothers, the matter was set rolling and our ancestors eventually went down to Egypt! Benjamin b. Japhet said: He gave him a hint that a descendant would issue from him who would go out before a king in five royal garments, as it says, “And Mordecai went out from the presence of the king in royal apparel of blue” (Esther 8:15).
“And Parshandata . . . the ten sons of Haman” (Esther 9:7-10). R. Adda from Yaffo said: The ten sons of Haman and the word “ten” [which follows] should be said in one breath. What is the reason? Because they all died in one breath. R. Yohanan said: The vav of Vaizata must be lengthened like a boat-pole of the river Librut. What is the reason? Because they were all strung on one pole.
What is the reason? So that they should never rise again from their downfall.
“But when she came before the king, he said along with the letter” (Esther 9:25). “He said”? It should read, “she said”? R. Yohanan said: She said: Let there be said by word of mouth what is written in the letter.
It speaks of keeping, as it is written, “That they would keep these two days (Esther 9:28) Rather from here, as it is written: “And these days should be remembered and kept” (Esther 9:28). “Remembering” is compared to “keeping”: just as keeping cannot be in the wrong order, so remembering also.
But the Sages too, is it not written, “And they shall be”? — They require this to teach that it should not be recited backwards. From where does Rabbi derive the rule that it should not be recited backwards? From “words” “the words.” The Sages do not accept a distinction between “words” and “the words.”
But the Sages too, is it not written, “And they shall be”? — They require this to teach that it should not be recited backwards. From where does Rabbi derive the rule that it should not be recited backwards? From “words” “the words.” The Sages do not accept a distinction between “words” and “the words.”
May we say that Rabbi holds that the whole Torah can be recited in any language? For should you assume that it must be recited] only in the holy tongue, why would I need the words “and they shall be”?
May we then say that the Sages held that the whole of the Torah could be recited only in the holy tongue, for should you assume that it could be recited in any language, why would it write “Hear”?
Our Rabbis taught: How do we know that the blessing of the Patriarchs should be said? Because it says, “Ascribe unto the Lord the sons of might” (Psalms 29:1). And from where do we know that we say the blessing of mighty deeds? Because it says, “Ascribe unto the Lord glory and strength” (Psalms 29:1). And from where do we know that we say sanctifications? Because it says, “Ascribe unto the Lord the glory due His name, worship the Lord in the beauty of holiness.” (Psalms 29:2)
If that is the reason, healing should be mentioned next to repentance? Do not think such a thing, since it is written, “And let him return to the Lord and He will have compassion upon him, and to our God, for He will abundantly forgive” (Isaiah 55:7).
R. Aha also said in the name of R. Elazar: How do we know that the Holy One, blessed be He, called Jacob El [God]? As it says, “And the God of Israel called him [Jacob] El” (Genesis 33:20). For should you think that [what the text means is that] Jacob called the altar El, then it should be written, “And Jacob called it.” Rather [it is written] “And He called to Jacob, El.” And who called him so? The God of Israel.
R. Aha also said in the name of R. Elazar: How do we know that the Holy One, blessed be He, called Jacob El [God]? As it says, “And the God of Israel called him [Jacob] El” (Genesis 33:20). For should you think that [what the text means is that] Jacob called the altar El, then it should be written, “And Jacob called it.” Rather [it is written] “And He called to Jacob, El.” And who called him so? The God of Israel.
But does he thereby fulfill his obligation? Has not R. Helbo said in the name of R. Hama b. Guria who said it in the name of Rav, The halakhah is according to the one who says that all of it [must be recited], and even according to the one who says that it is sufficient [to recite] from "A Jew was" (Esther 2:5), it is necessary that the whole should be [already] written?
Rava also said: A villager who has gone to a town reads with the rest in any case. What is the reason? He should read at the same time as the townspeople — and it is the Rabbis who made a concession to the villagers so that they might supply food and drink to their brothers in the large cities. Now this applies only so long as they are in their own place, but when they are in the town, they must read like the townspeople.
He who says that it should be read from “There was a Jew” [interprets thus]: What had Mordecai seen that he provoked Haman? “In that matter”, that he made himself an object of idolatry. “And what came upon them”? That a miracle occurred.
R. Hiyya b. Abba also said in the name of R. Yohanan: That a space should be left unstitched [in the Sefer Torah] is a halakhah from Moshe on Sinai and he at once protested the remark by saying: They only said this so that it should not be torn.
R. Hiyya b. Abba also said in the name of R. Yohanan: That a space should be left unstitched [in the Sefer Torah] is a halakhah from Moshe on Sinai and he at once protested the remark by saying: They only said this so that it should not be torn.
But how do we know that [our Mishnah] follows R. Yose and even if the deaf person has read, it does not count? Perhaps it follows R. Judah, and [what it means is that] the deaf person should not read, but if he has read, his reading is accepted?
(But perhaps the whole of the Mishnah states the opinions of R. Judah? — Is it possible that he should disqualify in the first and permit in the second?)
But perhaps the whole [of the Mishnah] is R. Judah, and he teaches of two kinds of minors, and the Mishnah is lacking and it should teach this: All are qualified to read the Megillah, except a deaf man, an imbecile and a minor. What is this speaking of? Of a minor who is not old enough to be educated in the mitzvot. But a minor who is old enough to be educated in the mitzvot may read even ab initio, since R. Judah declares a minor qualified!
What then will you say? That it follows R. Judah, and that he allows it even ab initio? What about this which has been taught: One should not bless birkat hamazon in his heart, but if he does do so, he has fulfilled his obligation. Whose opinion is this? It is neither that of R. Judah nor that of R. Yose. For if it were R. Judah, it would allow this even ab initio, and if R. Yose, it would disallow it even ex post facto.
as it has been taught: R. Judah says in the name of R. Elazar b. Azariah: One who recites the Shema should make it heard to his ears, as it says, “Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One”—Make heard to your ear what your mouth says. R. Meir says: “Which I command you this day upon your heart” according to the words follow the intention of the heart.
Mishnah: They do not read the Megillah, nor circumcise, nor go to the mikveh, nor sprinkling [purificatory waters], and similarly a woman keeping day for day should not take a ritual bath until the sun has risen. But if any of these things is done after dawn, it is valid.
Gemara. From where do we know this? Because the verse says, “And these days should be remembered and kept” (Esther 9:28) by day, but not by night. Shall we say that this is a refutation of R. Joshua b. Levi; for R. Joshua b. Levi said: One must read the Megillah by night and a second time by day? When the mishnah taught it, it referred to the day.
Neither should one circumcise. As it is written, “And on the eighth day he shall be circumcised” (Leviticus 12:3).
Neither should one immerse [in a mikveh] nor sprinkle. As it is written, “And the clean person shall sprinkle on the unclean . . . And on the seventh day” (Numbers 19:19) and immersing is compared to sprinkling.
And similarly a woman keeping day for day should not immerse until the sun has risen. This is obvious! Why should a woman keeping day for day be different from all others who are obligated to immerse?
And similarly a woman keeping day for day should not immerse until the sun has risen. This is obvious! Why should a woman keeping day for day be different from all others who are obligated to immerse?
It is necessary, lest you think that she should be the same as the first observation of one who had a genital discharge, and the first observation of one who had a genital discharge has been compared to one who had a seminal issue, as it is written, “This is the law of him that has had a genital discharge (zav) and of him from whom the flow of seed has gone out.” (Leviticus 15:32) Just as one with a seminal issue immerses during the day, so too this one immerses on the same day.
How then do I fulfil verse, “Before me continually” (Exodus 25:3)? [This is to show that] the table of the Lord should not be without bread.
R. Abbahu further said: How do we know that a rabbi should not sit on a couch and teach his students while they sit on the ground? Because it says, "But as for you, stand here with me." (Deuteronomy 5:27)
Where it is the custom to say a blessing, he should say it. Abaye said: They taught this only about the blessing after the reading, but before the reading it is a mitzvah to say a blessing, since Rav Judah said in the name of Shmuel: All of the mitzvoth—one says a blessing on them as one passes [over] them to perform them.
Shesheth from Katrazya happened [once to read] in the presence of R. Ashi, and he blessed M”N”H. Blessed are You, O Lord our God, king of the universe, [the God] who fought our fight and judged our judgment and avenged our vengeance and punished our adversaries for us and paid back retribution on all the enemies of our lives. Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel. Rava Says: [The concluding words are], “The God who saves.” R. Papa said: Therefore we should say both: “Blessed are You, O Lord, who pays back retribution to all the enemies of Israel, the God who saves.”
and we were somewhat perplexed by this. It is okay that “Let there be a firmament” can be read by one since it has three verses, but how can “In the beginning” be read by two, seeing that it has only five verses, and it has been taught, He who reads in the Torah should not read less than three verses.”
He who reads in the Torah should not read less than three verses.” Rav says he should repeat, and Shmuel says he should divide a verse.
He who reads in the Torah should not read less than three verses.” Rav says he should repeat, and Shmuel says he should divide a verse.
He who reads in the Torah should not read less than three verses.” Rav says he should repeat, and Shmuel says he should divide a verse.
Rav said he should repeat. Why did he not say “divide”? He was of opinion that any verse which Moses had not divided, we may not divide.
Now if it is as you said, then according to the one who says he should repeat, let him repeat, and according to the one who says he should divide, let him divide?
Now if it is as you said, then according to the one who says he should repeat, let him repeat, and according to the one who says he should divide, let him divide?
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
R. Tanhum, said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: The halakhah follows the "others says". R. Tanhum also said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi: Just as at the beginning of a section not less than three verses should be read, so too at the end of a section not less than three verses should be left.
But now with regard to the First Tanna: Why does he forbid leaving [less than three verses]? Because of people going out of synagogue. But at the beginning also he should take decree on account of people coming in? I can say that a person coming in asks [how much has been read].
It is also reasonable to assume that Rav read as kohen, because if you should think that he read as an Israelite, why did he say a blessing before reading? It was after the enactment.
If so, he should have said a blessing after reading also? It is different where Rav was present,
The Mishnah] is merely giving a sign that you should not say that the festivals and the intermediate days have the same rule, but rather you should take this general principle in your hands: For every additional distinguishing mark an additional person reads.
The Mishnah] is merely giving a sign that you should not say that the festivals and the intermediate days have the same rule, but rather you should take this general principle in your hands: For every additional distinguishing mark an additional person reads.
If that is the case, why is only Rav mentioned? All the rest should also have not done so! It was in front of Rav.
But did this cause his lameness? Did not R. Elazar Say: One should never cast words against Heaven, because a great man complained against heaven and he became lame; and who was he? Levi? Both things caused it.
Our Rabbis taught: All are qualified to be among the seven [who read], even a minor and a woman, only the Sages said that a woman should not read in the Torah out of respect for the congregation.
The question was raised: Should the person who takes the Maftir Aliyah be counted among the seven? R. Huna and R. Jeremiah b. Abba: One said that he does count and the other that he does not count. The one who says he does count, for he too reads, while the
one who says he does not count is like Ulla, who said: Why is it proper for the one who reads the haftarah from the Prophet to read in the Torah first? To show respect for the Torah. Since he reads [only] out of respect for the Torah, he should not be counted to make up the seven.
They objected: He who says the haftarah from the Prophet should not read less than twenty-one verses, corresponding to [those read by] the seven who have read in the Torah. Now if it is as you say, there are twenty-four? Since it is only out of respect for the Torah [that he reads],
GEMARA. From where do we know this? R. Hiyya b. Abba said in the name of R. Yohanan: Because the verse says, "But I will be sanctified among the children of Israel" (Leviticus 22:32): every act of sanctification should not be done with less than ten.
One who reads the Torah [in public] may not read less than three verses. And he should not read to the translator more than one verse [at a time],
And he should not read to the translator more than one verse [at a time], but [if reading from the book of a] prophet [he may read to him] three at a time. If the three verses constitute three separate paragraphs, he must read them [to the translator] one by one. For instance, [the three verses], “For thus says the Lord, you were sold for nothing” … For thus says the Lord God, my people went down to Egypt in times of yore”…; Now therefore what is there for me here, says the Lord” (Isaiah 52:3-5).
The Rabbis, however, hold that he does derive benefit, like R. Yose, as it has been taught: R. Jose said: ... All my life I was troubled by this verse, “And you shall grope at noonday as the blind gropes in darkness” (Deuteronomy 28:29). Now why should a blind person care whether it is dark or light?
A priest whose hands are deformed should not lift up his hands [to say the priestly blessing]. Rabbi Judah says: also one whose hands are colored with woad or madder should not lift up his hands, because [this makes] the congregation look at him.