when
21884 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
Said R. Zeriḳa to R. Safra: Come and see the difference between the imperious men of Palestine and the pious men of Babylonia. The pious men of Babylonia (namely R. Huna and R. Ḥisda), when there was need of rain, would say: "Come let us meet together in prayer; peradventure the Holy One, blessed be He, will accept our prayer and rain will come;" but as to the imperious men of Palestine, there is, for example, R. Jonah, the father of R. Mani, who, when they needed rain, would go into the house and say: "Get me my haversack and I will go and buy grain for a zuz," whereupon he would go to some cave-like, hidden place, cover himself in sackcloth and pray until rain came. When he came back he was asked, "Did you bring anything?" "No," he answered, "I thought that after this rainfall there would be relief everywhere."
R. Mani, the son of R. Jonah, was annoyed by members of the Patriarchal house, so he went and prostrated himself upon the burial cave of his father. One day when members of the Patriarchate happened to pass before the cave, the legs of their horses were caught in the ground and they could not move until they took upon themselves not to annoy R. Mani again.
The collectors of charity funds used to hide themselves whenever they saw Eleazar of the village of Bartota, because he was in the habit of giving them everything he happened to possess. One day he was going to the market in order to buy a wedding outfit for his daughter, when the collectors espied him and tried to hide themselves. Eleazar, however, followed them and said: "I adjure you to tell me for what purpose you are collecting?" "For a marriage between an orphaned boy and an orphaned girl," they replied. "By the Service of the Temple! they have precedence over my daughter," exclaimed he, and putting together all that he had, he gave it to them, except one zuz that remained in his possession. For this he bought wheat and deposited it in the granary. Thereupon his wife inquired of her daughter what her father had brought her. "All that he brought he took up to the granary," the daughter replied. The wife then went up to the granary and found it full of wheat, to the extent that it came through the door hinges. When Eleazar returned from the Bet ha-Midrash, she said to him, "Come and see what thy Friend (God) has done for thee!" Said he: "By the service of the Temple! This wheat shall be sacred property and thy share in it shall not be more than that of any among the poor of Israel."
The collectors of charity funds used to hide themselves whenever they saw Eleazar of the village of Bartota, because he was in the habit of giving them everything he happened to possess. One day he was going to the market in order to buy a wedding outfit for his daughter, when the collectors espied him and tried to hide themselves. Eleazar, however, followed them and said: "I adjure you to tell me for what purpose you are collecting?" "For a marriage between an orphaned boy and an orphaned girl," they replied. "By the Service of the Temple! they have precedence over my daughter," exclaimed he, and putting together all that he had, he gave it to them, except one zuz that remained in his possession. For this he bought wheat and deposited it in the granary. Thereupon his wife inquired of her daughter what her father had brought her. "All that he brought he took up to the granary," the daughter replied. The wife then went up to the granary and found it full of wheat, to the extent that it came through the door hinges. When Eleazar returned from the Bet ha-Midrash, she said to him, "Come and see what thy Friend (God) has done for thee!" Said he: "By the service of the Temple! This wheat shall be sacred property and thy share in it shall not be more than that of any among the poor of Israel."
The Patriarchal house once ordered a fast (during which they prayed for rain), but rain failed to come. 'Osha'yah, the younger from Ḥabraya, therefore, quoted to them the verse (Num., 15. 24): "Then it shall be, if it be done in error by the congregation, it being hid from their eyes," and illustrated it by the following simile: As long as a bride (in her paternal house) has beautiful eyes, the rest of her body needs no examination, but if her eyes are not beautiful, her entire body must be examined. Hearing this, the servants of the Patriarch seized 'Osha'ya, put a towel (sudary) around his neck and began to choke him, but some townspeople who saw it said to them: "Let him go, for he used to harass us too, but when we saw that all his deeds were for the sake of Heaven we let him alone."
Rabbi once ordered a fast, and 'Ilfa or, as some say, R. 'Ilfi, went down at Rabbi's request to the praying desk, and as soon as he said the words, "He causes the wind to blow," a wind blew, and when he said, "He causes the rain to come down," rain fell. Rabbi thereupon asked him, "What is thy occupation?" to which he replied: "I live in a poverty-stricken place (where there is no wine for Ḳiddush and Habdalah), but I make efforts and obtain wine for Ḳiddush and Habdalah and thus make the community discharge their duty."
Rab happened to come to a certain place, where he ordered a fast. The reader of the congregation then went down to the praying desk and recited, "He causes the wind to blow," and immediately a wind blew, and when he recited, "He causes the rain to fall," rain fell. Rab therefore asked him: "What is thy occupation?" "I am a teacher of young children," he replied, "and I teach the children of the poor as well as those of the rich, and if any one is so poor that he is unable to pay, I take no fee from him. I possess a fish-pond, and if a child is careless in his studies, I bribe him by giving him some of the fish and thus win him over to study."
Raba ordered a fast, prayed for rain, but rain did not come. He was therefore asked: "Why is it that when R. Judah ordered a fast rain came?" "What can I do?" replied Raba. "As far as learning goes, we are superior to them; for in his time all studies
were confined to the Section Neziḳin (Damages), while our studies embrace much more; when R. Judah reached in his studies the Mishnah (Ṭeharot, II, 1): 'If a woman was pressing vegetables in a pot,' or, as some say, the Mishnah ('Uḳḳaẓin, II, 1): 'Olives which have been pressed with their leaves are clean,' he would say: 'I see here problems as difficult as the discussions of Rab and Samuel,' while we to-day teach the tractate 'Uḳḳaẓin in thirteen different recensions. [And yet when R. Judah took off one of his shoes rain fell, while we cry (for rain) the whole day and nobody heeds us! Should it be because of our conduct—if there is anybody who has noticed anything wrong, let him testify against me.] However, what can the leaders do when the generation does not appear good enough in the eyes of God!"
were confined to the Section Neziḳin (Damages), while our studies embrace much more; when R. Judah reached in his studies the Mishnah (Ṭeharot, II, 1): 'If a woman was pressing vegetables in a pot,' or, as some say, the Mishnah ('Uḳḳaẓin, II, 1): 'Olives which have been pressed with their leaves are clean,' he would say: 'I see here problems as difficult as the discussions of Rab and Samuel,' while we to-day teach the tractate 'Uḳḳaẓin in thirteen different recensions. [And yet when R. Judah took off one of his shoes rain fell, while we cry (for rain) the whole day and nobody heeds us! Should it be because of our conduct—if there is anybody who has noticed anything wrong, let him testify against me.] However, what can the leaders do when the generation does not appear good enough in the eyes of God!"
were confined to the Section Neziḳin (Damages), while our studies embrace much more; when R. Judah reached in his studies the Mishnah (Ṭeharot, II, 1): 'If a woman was pressing vegetables in a pot,' or, as some say, the Mishnah ('Uḳḳaẓin, II, 1): 'Olives which have been pressed with their leaves are clean,' he would say: 'I see here problems as difficult as the discussions of Rab and Samuel,' while we to-day teach the tractate 'Uḳḳaẓin in thirteen different recensions. [And yet when R. Judah took off one of his shoes rain fell, while we cry (for rain) the whole day and nobody heeds us! Should it be because of our conduct—if there is anybody who has noticed anything wrong, let him testify against me.] However, what can the leaders do when the generation does not appear good enough in the eyes of God!"
R. Judah, seeing two men who were using bread in a wasteful manner, said: "It seems that there is too great plenty in the world." He cast an angry look about him and a famine came. Said the Rabbis to R. Kahana, son of R. Neḥunya, the disciple of R. Judah: "Try thou, who art his disciple, to prevail upon him (R. Judah) that he should go out to the market-place." He (R. Kahana) prevailed upon him. R. Judah went to the market, and noticing people crowding together, he asked: "What is the matter?" He was told that they were standing around a mass of offals of ground dates which was for sale. "There is evidently a famine in the country," said R. Judah, and ordered his disciple to pull his shoes from his feet. The disciple pulled off one of his master's shoes, and when he was about to pull off the other, Elijah appeared to him saying: "If you pull off the other shoe, you will destroy the world."
A certain man was sentenced in the court of Raba to be lashed because he had sexual intercourse with a Gentile woman. Raba had the lashing administered to him, and the man died of the effects. The matter came to the hearing of king Shabur (Sapor), who wanted to punish Raba for the deed, but 'Ifra 'Ormuzd, mother of king Shabur, said to him: "Have no quarrels with the Jews, because anything they ask of their God, He does for them." Said he: "What, for instance?" "They pray for rain," she replied, "and rain comes." Said he: "That is because it is the season when rain is due, let them pray for it now, in the equinox of Tammuz, and bring down rain!" 'Ifra 'Ormuzd thereupon sent word to Raba that he should concentrate his mind and pray for rain. Raba did so, but no rain came. Said he: "Master of the world! 'O God, we have heard with our ears, our fathers have told us, what work Thou didst in their days, in the days of old' (Ps., 44.2), but we did not see it with our own eyes." Immediately a heavy rain fell, so that the gutters of Maḥuza carried the water into the Tigris. Thereupon Raba's father appeared to him in a dream, saying: "Is there another man who puts Heaven to so much trouble! Change thy place." (He did so and) the next morning he found that his bed was scratched with knives.
R. Ḥanina b. Dosa once travelled on the road, when it began to rain. Said he: "Master of the world! The whole world is at ease, but Ḥanina alone is in distress!" The rain stopped. When he came home, he said again: "Master of the world! The whole world is in distress, while Ḥanina alone is at ease!" The rain came again. Said R. Joseph, what good did the prayer of the high priest do if R. Ḥanina could make it to naught? For we read in a Mishnah that the high priest used to recite a short prayer in the outer hall. What was the prayer? R. 'Abin b. R. 'Adda and Raba b. R. 'Adda said, both in the name of R. Judah, the prayer ran thus: "May it be Thy will, Lord our God, that this year be one of heat and rain." Is a hot year of any benefit? On the contrary, it is a calamity! But the prayer read thus: "If the year is to be hot, let it also be blessed with ample rain, and may the prayers of travellers find no hearing before Thee." R. Aḥa the son of Raba reported in the name of R. Judah the following conclusion (of the prayer): "May the rulership never depart from the house of Judah and may Thy people Israel never be in need of supporting one another or of assistance from other people."
R. Ḥanina b. Dosa once travelled on the road, when it began to rain. Said he: "Master of the world! The whole world is at ease, but Ḥanina alone is in distress!" The rain stopped. When he came home, he said again: "Master of the world! The whole world is in distress, while Ḥanina alone is at ease!" The rain came again. Said R. Joseph, what good did the prayer of the high priest do if R. Ḥanina could make it to naught? For we read in a Mishnah that the high priest used to recite a short prayer in the outer hall. What was the prayer? R. 'Abin b. R. 'Adda and Raba b. R. 'Adda said, both in the name of R. Judah, the prayer ran thus: "May it be Thy will, Lord our God, that this year be one of heat and rain." Is a hot year of any benefit? On the contrary, it is a calamity! But the prayer read thus: "If the year is to be hot, let it also be blessed with ample rain, and may the prayers of travellers find no hearing before Thee." R. Aḥa the son of Raba reported in the name of R. Judah the following conclusion (of the prayer): "May the rulership never depart from the house of Judah and may Thy people Israel never be in need of supporting one another or of assistance from other people."
Once the wife of R. Ḥanina said to her husband: "Pray that some of the good which is stored up for the righteous in the world to come may be given to you here." He prayed and a leg of a golden table was swung into his house, but subsequently he saw in a dream that all other people would dine on a table with three legs, while he would dine on a table with two legs. She then said to him: "Pray that they should take it (the golden leg) back." He did so and it was taken back. It was taught in a Baraita that the latter miracle was greater than the former, for there is a tradition that things prayed for may be granted, but (when granted) are never taken back.
R. Eleazar b. Pedat was greatly distressed by poverty. One day he was bled, and after the operation had nothing to eat. He found some garlic and swallowed it, whereupon he fainted. Some of the Rabbis went to visit him and noticed that he was weeping and laughing, and that a ray of light proceeded from his forehead. When he awoke, they asked him: "Why did you weep and laugh, and why did a ray of light proceed from your forehead?" "I saw the Shekinah," he replied, "and complained before her, saying, 'how long shall I continue to live in this poverty?' and the Shekinah replied to me: 'Would it be acceptable to thee that I should destroy the world and create it anew? Perhaps thou wilt then be born in an hour that will betoken plenty for thee.' I said, 'So much trouble for a mere perhaps?' [I further said: 'Is the time which I have already lived greater than the time I am yet to live, or the reverse?' I was told: 'The time thou hast lived is greater.' 'If so,' said I, 'I do not care to be reborn.'] I then asked: 'What wilt thou give me in the world to come?' 'Thou wilt be given,' the answer was, 'thirteen rivers flowing with balsam oil, in which thou wilt find pleasure.' Said I, 'Is that all?' [The Shekinah replied: 'What am I to give to thy fellowmen if thou takest everything?' But I said: 'Do I ask it of one who is not in a position to give?']. I was then struck on my forehead by the snapping of a thumb and was asked: 'Eleazar my son, do my arrows irritate thee?'"
R. Ḥanina b. Ḥama ordered a fast, but no rain came. The people asked, "Why is it that when R. Joshua b. Levi orders a fast rain does fall?" R. Ḥanina replied: "I am I (Ḥanina) and he is the son of Levi!" They sent for him (R. Joshua), and R. Ḥanina said to him: "Come let us put our minds in the right spirit of prayer; perchance the community too will become contrite and pray, and rain will come." They all prayed, but there was no rain. R. Ḥanina then said: "Is it your desire that rain shall descend for our sake?" They said "Yes!" R. Ḥanina then called: "Sky! sky! cover thy face (with clouds)!" But the sky did not cover itself. Then he said: "How impudent art thou, O sky!" The sky thereupon covered itself and rain came.
R. Ḥiyya b. Luliani overheard the clouds saying: "Let us pour rain on Ammon and Moab." Said he to them: When the Holy One, blessed be He, offered His Torah to the various nations and tongues they did not accept it, until Israel came and accepted it. Now ye are ready to pass over Israel and pour your rain upon Ammon and Moab! Pour down the rain on the spot below you! And they did so.
R. Eleazar said: When the libation is offered during the Feast of Tabernacles, one deep says to the other: "Let thy water spring forth, I hear the voice of two comrades," for it is said (Ps., 42. 8): "Deep calleth unto deep at the voice of Thy cataracts." Said Rabbah bar Bar Ḥanah, I saw that Ridya; he resembles a heifer of three years old; his lip is split and he is stationed between the upper and the lower deep; to the upper deep he says: "Pour down thy water," and to the lower deep: "Let thy water spring up," as it is said (Cant., 2. 12): "The flowers appear on the earth; the time of the singing is come, and the voice of the turtle is heard in our land."
Samuel the Little ordered a fast and rain came before sunrise. The people therefore thought that it was due to the merit of the congregation, but Samuel said, I will illustrate the event to you by a simile: The situation is to be compared to that of a slave who asks reward of his master, and the master says to his servants, "Give it to him so that I may hear his voice no more." Another time Samuel the Little ordered a fast and rain came after sunset. The people again thought that it was due to the merits of the congregation, but Samuel said to them, I will explain the matter by a simile: The situation is to be likened unto that of a slave who asks the master for his reward, and the latter says to his servants: "Wait until he shows contrition and is worried, and then you can give it to him." But if this interpretation of Samuel the Little is accepted, how will it ever be possible to recognize the merit of a congregation? It can be recognized if when the reader recites: "He causes the wind to blow," a wind blows, and when he recites: "He causes the rain to descend," rain descends.
Samuel the Little ordered a fast and rain came before sunrise. The people therefore thought that it was due to the merit of the congregation, but Samuel said, I will illustrate the event to you by a simile: The situation is to be compared to that of a slave who asks reward of his master, and the master says to his servants, "Give it to him so that I may hear his voice no more." Another time Samuel the Little ordered a fast and rain came after sunset. The people again thought that it was due to the merits of the congregation, but Samuel said to them, I will explain the matter by a simile: The situation is to be likened unto that of a slave who asks the master for his reward, and the latter says to his servants: "Wait until he shows contrition and is worried, and then you can give it to him." But if this interpretation of Samuel the Little is accepted, how will it ever be possible to recognize the merit of a congregation? It can be recognized if when the reader recites: "He causes the wind to blow," a wind blows, and when he recites: "He causes the rain to descend," rain descends.
when the appetite is satisfied and the stomach filled. This is not so, for did not R. Papa once chance to be in the synagogue of 'Abi Gubar, where he ordered a fast and rain fell before noon-time (of the fast-day), yet he advised them: "Read the great Hallel and then eat and drink!" With city people it is different, as drunkenness is a frequent occurrence among them.
2. This is the order of the Ma'amadot [It is said (Num., 28.2): "Command the children of Israel, and say unto them: My food which is presented unto Me for offering made by fire of a sweet savour unto me, shall ye observe to offer unto me in its due season." Now, how can the offering of a person be presented, if he does not stand by it? The Early Prophets have therefore instituted twenty-four divisions. (Corresponding to each division there was present in Jerusalem a post of priests, Levites and Israelites.) When the turn of a division came to go up to Jerusalem, the priests and Levites (as well as the lay representatives of the Israelites) of that division went up to Jerusalem, while the bulk of the Israelites belonging to that division assembled in the synagogues of their respective towns and read the chapter on Creation (Gen., 1. 1-31; 2. 1-3)]:
4. On days when Hallel is recited, there is no Ma'amad service in the morning (שחרית); on days when an additional (Musaf) offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer; on days when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah (closing) prayer; this is the opinion of R. 'Aḳiba. Ben 'Azzai said to him: thus R. Joshua taught: On days when an additional offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah prayer, but when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer. R. 'Aḳiba then accepted the version of Ben 'Azzai.
4. On days when Hallel is recited, there is no Ma'amad service in the morning (שחרית); on days when an additional (Musaf) offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer; on days when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah (closing) prayer; this is the opinion of R. 'Aḳiba. Ben 'Azzai said to him: thus R. Joshua taught: On days when an additional offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah prayer, but when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer. R. 'Aḳiba then accepted the version of Ben 'Azzai.
4. On days when Hallel is recited, there is no Ma'amad service in the morning (שחרית); on days when an additional (Musaf) offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer; on days when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah (closing) prayer; this is the opinion of R. 'Aḳiba. Ben 'Azzai said to him: thus R. Joshua taught: On days when an additional offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah prayer, but when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer. R. 'Aḳiba then accepted the version of Ben 'Azzai.
4. On days when Hallel is recited, there is no Ma'amad service in the morning (שחרית); on days when an additional (Musaf) offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer; on days when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah (closing) prayer; this is the opinion of R. 'Aḳiba. Ben 'Azzai said to him: thus R. Joshua taught: On days when an additional offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah prayer, but when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer. R. 'Aḳiba then accepted the version of Ben 'Azzai.
4. On days when Hallel is recited, there is no Ma'amad service in the morning (שחרית); on days when an additional (Musaf) offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer; on days when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah (closing) prayer; this is the opinion of R. 'Aḳiba. Ben 'Azzai said to him: thus R. Joshua taught: On days when an additional offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Ne'ilah prayer, but when a wood-offering is brought, there is no Ma'amad service during the Minḥah prayer. R. 'Aḳiba then accepted the version of Ben 'Azzai.
R. Judah said in the name of Rab, R. Meir's view is law; R. Huna said, it is established usage; R. Johanan said, the people adopted it as a usage. [The opinion of him who says that a view is law, carries with it that we must teach it in the school sessions; if one says that a view is established usage, it means that we do not teach it in the school sessions, but, if asked, decide accordingly; if one says that the people have adopted a view as usage, it means that we do not even decide according to it, but that when someone has already acted in accordance with it, we do not nullify his action.] R. Naḥman said, R. Jose's view is law and, indeed, R. Jose's view has been recognized as law. Why then do the priests nowadays spread their hands during the Minḥah service of public fasts? Inasmuch as they do it close to sunset, it is as if it were done during the Ne'ilah service.
Twenty-four divisions [corresponding to each division there was present in Jerusalem a post of Israelites] of priests, Levites, and Israelites. When the turn of a division came to go up to Jerusalem, the priests and Levites of that division went up to Jerusalem.
The Rabbis have taught: Twenty-four divisions were in the land of Israel and twelve in Jericho (and twelve in Jericho? That would amount to more than twenty-four! Read "twelve thereof were in Jericho"). When the turn of a division arrived, half of the division would go up to Jerusalem, while the other half would go to Jericho, in order to supply from there water and food to their brethren in Jerusalem.
Said R. Ḥisda in the name of R. Ḥama b. Gurya, who had it in the name of Rab: Moses instituted for the Israelites eight divisions, four from the descendants of Eleazar and four from those of Ithamar; later, Samuel brought the divisions up to sixteen; finally, David brought them up to twenty-four, as it is said (I Chron., 26. 31): "In the fortieth year of the reign of David they were sought for, and there were found among them mighty men of valour at Jazer of Gilead." An objection was raised from the following: Moses instituted eight divisions for the Israelites, four from the descendants of Eleazar and four from those of Ithamar; later, David and Samuel (conjointly) brought them up to twenty-four, as it is said (I Chron., 9. 22): "Whom David and Samuel the seer did ordain in their set office!" This passage is to be understood thus: From the original institution of Samuel the Ramathite the number was increased by David to twenty-four. Another objection was raised from the following: Moses instituted for the Israelites sixteen divisions, eight from the family of Eleazar and eight from that of Ithamar, but when the children of Eleazar became more numerous than those of Ithamar they were redivided into twenty-four, as it is said (ibid., 24.4): "And there were more chief men found of the sons of Eleazar than of the sons of Ithamar; and thus were they divided: of the sons of Eleazar there were sixteen, heads of fathers' houses; and of the sons of Ithamar, according to their fathers' houses, eight"; further it is said (ibid., 24. 6): "One father's house being taken from Eleazar, and proportionately for Ithamar." Now why does this Baraita add "further it is said"? Because you might otherwise assume that just as the divisions of the sons of Eleazar increased in number (from four to sixteen), so also those of the sons of Ithamar increased (from four to eight), and that originally each had only four divisions. The Baraita therefore calls your attention to the verse: "One father's house being taken for Eleazar, and proportionately for Ithamar." This Baraita is thus a refutation of the view of R. Ḥisda! R. Ḥisda can answer your objection by saying that there are two different opinions of Tannaim on this matter, and that he agrees with that Tanna (who says that Moses instituted only eight divisions, four of each).
The bulk of the Israelites belonging to that division assembled in the synagogues of their respective towns and read the Chapter on Creation. What is the basis for this provision? Said R. Jacob b. 'Aḥa in the name of R. 'Asi: Were it not for the Ma'amadot, heaven and earth would not exist, as it is said (Gen., 15. 8): "And he (Abraham) said, O Lord, whereby shall I know that I shall inherit it?" Abraham said to the Holy One, blessed be He: "Master of the world! Peradventure the Israelites will sin before Thee, and Thou wilt then do unto them as Thou hast done unto the generation of the Flood and the generation of the Dispersion!" The Holy One replied: "No" (I will not do so unto them)! Whereupon Abraham said: "Master of the world! Whereby shall I know it?" The Holy One then said to him (ibid., 15. 9): "Take me a heifer of three years old." Abraham again said: "Master of the world! This may well be done when the Temple is in existence, but what shall become of them when the Temple is not in existence?" Said the Holy One: "I have already ordained for them the recitation of the order of sacrifices. Whenever they will recite it, I will account it unto them as if they offered up the sacrifices themselves and thus forgive them all their sins."
The bulk of the Israelites belonging to that division assembled in the synagogues of their respective towns and read the Chapter on Creation. What is the basis for this provision? Said R. Jacob b. 'Aḥa in the name of R. 'Asi: Were it not for the Ma'amadot, heaven and earth would not exist, as it is said (Gen., 15. 8): "And he (Abraham) said, O Lord, whereby shall I know that I shall inherit it?" Abraham said to the Holy One, blessed be He: "Master of the world! Peradventure the Israelites will sin before Thee, and Thou wilt then do unto them as Thou hast done unto the generation of the Flood and the generation of the Dispersion!" The Holy One replied: "No" (I will not do so unto them)! Whereupon Abraham said: "Master of the world! Whereby shall I know it?" The Holy One then said to him (ibid., 15. 9): "Take me a heifer of three years old." Abraham again said: "Master of the world! This may well be done when the Temple is in existence, but what shall become of them when the Temple is not in existence?" Said the Holy One: "I have already ordained for them the recitation of the order of sacrifices. Whenever they will recite it, I will account it unto them as if they offered up the sacrifices themselves and thus forgive them all their sins."
On days when Hallel was to be recited, there was no Ma'amad, etc. Why should there be such a distinction between the one (the day with a Musaf offering) and the other (the day with a wood offering)? Answer: The Musaf offering is a biblical ordinance and therefore requires no additional protection by the Rabbis (hence it is enough when it is made to supersede the Ma'amad during Minḥah service only), but the wood offering is a rabbinical enactment and therefore must have special protection (hence the wood offering is made to supersede both the Minḥah and the Ne'ilah services of the Ma'amad).
On days when Hallel was to be recited, there was no Ma'amad, etc. Why should there be such a distinction between the one (the day with a Musaf offering) and the other (the day with a wood offering)? Answer: The Musaf offering is a biblical ordinance and therefore requires no additional protection by the Rabbis (hence it is enough when it is made to supersede the Ma'amad during Minḥah service only), but the wood offering is a rabbinical enactment and therefore must have special protection (hence the wood offering is made to supersede both the Minḥah and the Ne'ilah services of the Ma'amad).
There were nine days on which the priests and the people used to bring their wood offerings. Our Rabbis have taught: Why was it necessary to set special days for the wood offerings of the priests and those particular families? Because it is reported that when the Babylonian exiles returned to Jerusalem, they found no wood in the chamber and the families here enumerated donated wood of their own, wherefore it was ordained by the prophets of their generation that even if the chamber was full of wood, these families should have the privilege of donating from their own, as it is said (Neh., 10. 35): "And we cast lots, the priests, the Levites, and the people for the wood-offering, to bring it into the house of our God, according to our fathers' houses, at times appointed, year by year, to burn upon the altar of the Lord our God, as it is written in the Law."
With the family of Zattu wood was offered also by priests, Levites, and all Israelites who were not sure of their tribe, as also by those who deceived (the Romans) by a pestle and dry figs. Our Rabbis have taught: Who is meant by "those who deceived the Romans by a pestle and dry figs?" It is reported that once persecution was decreed by the wicked government (of Rome) upon the Israelites, forbidding them to bring their first fruit-offerings to Jerusalem and placing guards on the roads, as did Jeroboam the son of Nebat, to prevent the people from journeying as pilgrims to Jerusalem for the festivals. What did the sin-fearing men of that generation do? They took baskets containing first fruits, covered them with dry figs, put a pestle on their shoulders and proceeded. When they reached the guards and the latter asked them where they were going, they replied: With this pestle on our shoulders we are going to make two cakes of pressed figs in that mortar, yonder! As soon as they passed the guards they decorated the first fruits in the baskets and brought them to Jerusalem.
It was taught that the sons of Salmai of Netofah were also among the donors of wood. Who are meant by the sons of Salmai of Netofah? It was reported that at one time the wicked government decreed persecution over Israel, forbidding them to bring wood for the altar and placing guards on the roads, as did Jeroboam the son of Nebat, to prevent the people from going to Jerusalem for the festivals. What did the sin-fearing men of that generation do? They took pieces of wood, formed them into a sort of ladders, put them on their shoulders and proceeded. When they came to the guards and the latter asked them where they were going, they replied: We are going to fetch two doves from that dove-cote yonder by means of the ladders on our shoulders. As soon as they passed the guards, they took the ladders apart and carried the wood thereof as an offering to Jerusalem. Of them and their like it is said (Prov., 10. 7): "The memory of the righteous shall be for a blessing," but of Jeroboam and his like it is said (ibidem): "But the name of the wicked shall rot."
(On the ninth of Ab) the second Temple was destroyed. Whence is this known? It is taught in a Baraita: R. Jose said, fortunate events are assigned to a lucky day, but calamities are assigned to an unlucky day. It was reported that when the Temple was destroyed for the first time it was on the ninth of Ab which happened to be on a Sunday, while the year was one following immediately upon a sabbatical year; further it was in the week in which the division of priests from the house of Jehojarib was on duty; the Levites were standing on their platform. [What song did they intone? They sang the verse (Ps., 94. 23): "And He hath brought upon them their own iniquity, and will cut them off in their own evil;" but before they were able to add the words: "The Lord our God will cut them off," the heathen came in and subdued them.] All this happened also in the second Temple.
The City of Jerusalem was plowed over. This is a tradition. We read in a Baraita: When the wicked Tyrant (Titus Annius) Rufus plowed the site of the Temple Hall, Rabban Gamaliel was condemned to death. A certain general then appeared and, standing up in the school-house, said, "The man with the nose is wanted! the man with the nose is wanted!" When Rabban Gamaliel heard the call, he hid himself from the Romans, but the general called on him secretly and said to him: "If I save you will you bring me to the future world?" "Yes!" replied R. Gamaliel. "Swear it unto me!" and R. Gamaliel swore it unto him. The Roman thereupon went up to the roof, threw himself down and died. The decree against R. Gamaliel was then annulled, because there was a custom that if a decree was issued and one of those who signed it died, the decree was annulled. A heavenly voice then came forth declaring that the general was sure to have a share in the life of the world to come.
The City of Jerusalem was plowed over. This is a tradition. We read in a Baraita: When the wicked Tyrant (Titus Annius) Rufus plowed the site of the Temple Hall, Rabban Gamaliel was condemned to death. A certain general then appeared and, standing up in the school-house, said, "The man with the nose is wanted! the man with the nose is wanted!" When Rabban Gamaliel heard the call, he hid himself from the Romans, but the general called on him secretly and said to him: "If I save you will you bring me to the future world?" "Yes!" replied R. Gamaliel. "Swear it unto me!" and R. Gamaliel swore it unto him. The Roman thereupon went up to the roof, threw himself down and died. The decree against R. Gamaliel was then annulled, because there was a custom that if a decree was issued and one of those who signed it died, the decree was annulled. A heavenly voice then came forth declaring that the general was sure to have a share in the life of the world to come.
Our Rabbis have taught: When the first Temple was destroyed, groups of young priests assembled and, holding the keys of the Temple court in their hands, went up to the roof of the Temple and said: Master of the world! Since we have not been considered worthy of being Thy treasurers, we hand over the keys to Thee. So saying, they threw the keys towards heaven, and something like a hand appeared and received the keys from them, whereupon they threw themselves down into the fire beneath. In allusion to them Isaiah laments (Is., 22. 1-2): "The burden concerning the valley of vision. What aileth thee now, that thou art wholly gone up to the housetops, thou that art full of uproar, a tumultuous city, a joyous town? Thy slain are not slain with the sword, nor dead in battle." And even the Holy One, blessed be He, cried over them like a hen that clucks for her chickens, for it is said (ib., 22. 5): "Kir shouting and crying at the mount."
During the week in which the ninth of Ab falls one should not cut one's hair or wash (one's clothes). Said R. Naḥman, this applies only to washing for immediate wear, but it is allowed to wash the clothes in order to lay them aside (for future wear). R. Sheshet, however, said, even to wash and lay aside is also forbidden. Said R. Sheshet, you can derive it from the fact that (during the week preceding the ninth of Ab) the fullers of the house of Rab were idle. R. Hamnuna raised an objection from the following sentence of the Mishnah: On Thursday it is allowed (to wash clothes) in honor of the Sabbath. Now what is the supposed purpose of the washing to which the Mishnah here refers? Will you say that it refers to washing for immediate wear? What has washing for such purpose to do with the honoring of the Sabbath? The Mishnah can thus mean only washing for the purpose of putting aside (for a later time), and yet the reason given for its permission is that it is Thursday, when the washing is done in honor of the next Sabbath, but in the preceding days of the week it would not be allowed! You may nevertheless say that the Mishnah refers to washing for immediate wear, but has in view one who possesses only one shirt, which interpretation is in keeping with what was said by R. Asi in the name of R. Johanan, namely, that one who possesses only one shirt is allowed to wash it on the Half-festivals.
R. Benjamin b. Jephet also said in the name of R. Eleazar that the prohibition of washing refers only to washing for immediate wear, but washing for the purpose of putting aside is allowed. An objection was again raised from the following Baraita: It is not allowed to wash before the ninth of Ab (within the same week) even when the intention is to put the clothes aside for use after the ninth of Ab; our (Babylonian) fine laundry work is under the same rule as their (Palestinian) plain washing; linen garments are not subject to the law forbidding laundering! This, indeed, is a refutation.
R. Dimi b. Joseph said in the name of R. Naḥman, the fifteenth of Ab is the day on which the last one of the generation that was doomed to die in the desert, died; for it was stated by some authority, God did not address Himself to Moses until the last one of that generation had died, as it is said (Deut., 2. 16-17): "So it came to pass, when all the men of war were consumed and dead from among the people, that the Lord spoke unto me saying," that is to say: To me then came a message through speech.
They objected: “R. Judah said: When [does this rule apply]? When the years are reckon from it, only when the years are properly fixed and Israel reside on their own soil. But today, since we can calculate [the date, the Megillah] is to be read only on the proper day”.
They objected: “R. Judah said: When [does this rule apply]? When the years are reckon from it, only when the years are properly fixed and Israel reside on their own soil. But today, since we can calculate [the date, the Megillah] is to be read only on the proper day”.
They objected: “R. Judah said: When [does this rule apply]? When the years are reckon from it, only when the years are properly fixed and Israel reside on their own soil. But today, since we can calculate [the date, the Megillah] is to be read only on the proper day”.
Rather, it must be according to the Rabbis, and [even according to them] we read [on the other days] at any rate when the years are properly fixed and Israel reside on their own soil! This is refutation of R. Yohanan.
It has also been taught: “R. Judah said: When does this rule apply? When the years are properly fixed and Israel reside upon their own soil, but in these days, since people reckon from it, it is read only on the proper day.”
It has also been taught: “R. Judah said: When does this rule apply? When the years are properly fixed and Israel reside upon their own soil, but in these days, since people reckon from it, it is read only on the proper day.”
[He said]: Can R. Judah really have said that in these days, since people reckon from it, it is read only on the proper day? And this is contradicted by the following: R. Judah said, When [do they push forward the reading]? In places where the villagers go to town on Monday and Thursday; but in places where they do not go to town on Monday and Thursday, it is read only on the proper day.
But when all is said and done, [we have the text] “These are the commandments” which implies that no prophet was destined ever to introduce an innovation hereafter? Rather, they forgot them and then they went back and reestablished them.
But is the [Temple] service more important than the study of the Torah? Surely it is written, “And it came to pass when Joshua was by Jericho, that he lifted up his eyes and looked, and behold there stood a man over against him, . . . and he fell on his face” (Joshua 5:13).
But is that of an individual unimportant? Have we not learned: Women [when mourning] on a festival may make a dirge but they do not beat their chests. R. Ishmael says: If they are near the bier, they can beat their chests. On Rosh Hodesh, Hanukkah and Purim they may make a dirge and beat their chests, but on neither the one nor the other do they wail.
They thought this means that t hey should read the Megillah at night, and teach the Mishnah [about it] in the morning. Jeremiah said to them: It has been explained to me by R. Hiyya b. Abba [that the word “repeat” here has the same meaning] as when, for instance, people say, I will go through this section and repeat it.
Come and hear [again]: R. Judah says: When [is the reading pushed forward]? In places where the villagers come into town on Mondays and Thursdays, but in places where they do not come into town on Mondays and Thursdays it is read only on the proper day. Now if you assume that the regulation is for the benefit of the cities, because they do not come into town on Mondays and Thursdays; are the cities to be deprived of the benefit?
Rav said: The Megillah, in its proper time, can be read even by an individual; Rav Asi said: But [when read] not in its proper time, it should be read only in a company of ten. Such a case actually occurred and Rav gave consideration to the opinion of R. Asi
Although they said that they should be moved up but not postponed, it is permissible to mourn, to fast, and to distribute gifts to the poor [on these earlier days]. Rabbi Judah said: When is this so? In a place where people gather on Mondays and Thursdays, but in places where people do not gather on Mondays and Thursdays, the Megillah is read only on its proper day.
But how could Rabbi have planted a sapling on Purim? Has not R. Joseph taught: [We read in connection with Purim] rejoicing and feasting and a good day; “Rejoicing”: this teaches that it is forbidden on these days to mourn; “Feasting”: this teaches that it is forbidden on them to fast; “A good day”: this teaches that it is forbidden on them to work. Rather Rabbi was from a place which kept Purim on the fourteenth, and when he planted, it was on the fifteenth.
Is this so? But Rabbi was in Tiberias, and Tiberias was walled in the days of Joshua son of Nun? Rather Rabbi was in a place which kept on the fifteenth, and when he planted it was the fourteenth.
R. Yohanan said: When I was a boy, I said something which I afterwards questioned the old men about,
Rava said: Is there anyone who can maintain that Rakat is not Tiberias. But when a person dies here [in Babylonia] they mourn for him there [in Tiberias] as follows: “Great was he in Sheshach and he has a name in Rakat”, and when the coffin is taken there they mourn for him thus: “You lovers of the remnants, dwellers in Rakat, go forth and receive the slaughtered of the depths.”
Rava said: Is there anyone who can maintain that Rakat is not Tiberias. But when a person dies here [in Babylonia] they mourn for him there [in Tiberias] as follows: “Great was he in Sheshach and he has a name in Rakat”, and when the coffin is taken there they mourn for him thus: “You lovers of the remnants, dwellers in Rakat, go forth and receive the slaughtered of the depths.”
When R. Zera died, a certain eulogizer opened his eulogy thus: “The land of Shinar conceived and bore him, the beauteous land brought up her delight. Woe to me, says Rakat, for her precious instrument is lost.”
R. Abbahu said: “Ekron shall be rooted up” (Zephaniah 2:4); this is Caesarea the daughter of Edom, which is situated among the sands, and which was a thorn in the side of Israel in the days of the Greeks. When the House of the Hasmoneans grew powerful and conquered them, they called it “The capture of the tower of Shir.”
Or if you like I may say that both refer to one’s own affairs, and still there is no contradiction: the one is addressed to one who is wholly righteous, and the other to one who is not wholly righteous, as R. Huna said: What is the meaning of the verse, “Why do you look upon those who deal treacherously, and are silent when the wicked swallows up the man that is more righteous than he?” (Habakkuk 1:13). He can swallow up one that is more righteous than himself, he cannot swallow up one that is completely righteous.
Or if you like I can say that when fortune is smiling on him, the case is different.
Rava said: They can all be refuted except that of Shmuel, which cannot be refuted. Against the proof of R. Elazar it may be objected that it is reasonable [to suppose that Haman would think so] because there was no one who was so high in the esteem of the king as he was, and that when he spoke at length [to Ahashverosh], he was only speaking concerning himself.
Abaye said: When I went out of the Master’s [Rabbah’s] house, I was already full, but when I reached the other place they set before me sixty dishes of sixty different preparations, and I had sixty pieces from them. The last preparation was called pot-roast, and [I liked it so much that] I wanted to lick the dish after it.
Abaye said: When I went out of the Master’s [Rabbah’s] house, I was already full, but when I reached the other place they set before me sixty dishes of sixty different preparations, and I had sixty pieces from them. The last preparation was called pot-roast, and [I liked it so much that] I wanted to lick the dish after it.
It was taught there: What constitutes a vow? When one says: “It is incumbent upon me to bring an olah.” And what constitutes a freewill-offering? When one says: “Behold, this shall be an olah.” What is the [practical] difference between vows (neder) and freewill offerings (nedavah)? In the case of vows, if they die or are stolen, one is responsible for their replacement; In the case of vows, if they die or are stolen, one is responsible for their replacement; But in the case of freewill offerings, if they die or are stolen, one is not responsible for their replacement. Whence is this rule derived? —
It was taught there: What constitutes a vow? When one says: “It is incumbent upon me to bring an olah.” And what constitutes a freewill-offering? When one says: “Behold, this shall be an olah.” What is the [practical] difference between vows (neder) and freewill offerings (nedavah)? In the case of vows, if they die or are stolen, one is responsible for their replacement; In the case of vows, if they die or are stolen, one is responsible for their replacement; But in the case of freewill offerings, if they die or are stolen, one is not responsible for their replacement. Whence is this rule derived? —
Now that you have said that the words “from his issue” are to be used for a derashah, “And when he that had an issue is cleansed from his issue” (Leviticus 15:13) what do you derive from it?
That is required for the following, as it has been taught: “And when he that had an issue is cleansed”: when the issue ceases. “From his issue”: from his issue [only], and not from both his issue and his leprosy. “From his issue, then he shall count”: this teaches us that a zav who has had two observations must count seven days [without issue].
That is required for the following, as it has been taught: “And when he that had an issue is cleansed”: when the issue ceases. “From his issue”: from his issue [only], and not from both his issue and his leprosy. “From his issue, then he shall count”: this teaches us that a zav who has had two observations must count seven days [without issue].
And should you say that this word is required to show that the text refers to one who is cleansed of his issue [only] and not [of his issue and] his leprosy. If so let the verse say, “And when he that has an issue is cleansed” and no more. Why do I have “from his issue”? This teaches that one with an issue who has two observations is required to count seven days.
Abaye said to him: If that is so, then when it says, “All the days during which the plague is in him he shall be unclean” (Leviticus 13:46), are we to say that one whose scale disease is due to his state of body is required to be sent out of the camp, but one whose scale disease is not due to his state of body is not to be sent out of the camp?
What I must say therefore is, Our Rabbis permitted them to be written only in Greek. And it teaches, R. Judah said: Even when our teachers permitted Greek, they permitted it only for a scroll of the Torah. This was on account of the case of King King Ptolemy,
How have you explained [the Mishnah]? As not agreeing with R. Meir. What about the end of the mishnah: There is no difference between a serving [high] priest and one whose time has passed except the bull of Yom HaKippurim and the tenth of the ephah. But we can infer that in all other matters they are the same; and so we come to the view of R. Meir, as it has been taught, If something happened to disqualify him and they appointed another priest to take his place, when the first returns to his service the second is still liable to all the obligations of the high priesthood, the words of R. Meir. R. Yose said: The first returns to his service whereas the second is not qualified to act as a high priest or as an ordinary priest.
There is a difference of Tannaim on this point, as we have learnt. R. Eliezer said: I have heard that when they were building the hekhal [in the second Temple] they made curtains for the hekhal and for the courtyard, the difference being that in the hekhal they built [the walls] outside [the curtains] and in the courtyard they built [the walls] within [the curtains].
Rather it follows the following Tannaim: R. Ishmael son of R. Yose said: Why did the Sages list these? Because when the exiles returned they found these cities [still walled] and sanctified them; the others were annulled when the land’s [sanctity] was annulled. Thus he holds that the first holiness sanctified it for its time but not for the future.
Rather it follows the following Tannaim: R. Ishmael son of R. Yose said: Why did the Sages list these? Because when the exiles returned they found these cities [still walled] and sanctified them; the others were annulled when the land’s [sanctity] was annulled. Thus he holds that the first holiness sanctified it for its time but not for the future.
And they raised a contradiction with the following: R. Ishmael son of R. Yose said: Were these all? Has it not already been said, “Sixty cities, all the region of Argob”, And it is written, “All these were fortified cities with high walls” (Deuteronomy 3:4-5)? Why then did the Sages list these? Because when the exiles returned, they found these [still walled] and sanctified them.
Vayehi in the days of Ahashverosh (Esther 1:1) — there was Haman. Vayehi in the days when the judges judged (Ruth 1:1) — there was a famine. Vayehi when man began to multiply (Genesis 6:1) — then God Saw that the wickedness of man was great.
Vayehi in the days of Ahashverosh (Esther 1:1) — there was Haman. Vayehi in the days when the judges judged (Ruth 1:1) — there was a famine. Vayehi when man began to multiply (Genesis 6:1) — then God Saw that the wickedness of man was great.
Vayehi, as they journeyed east (Genesis 11:20) — then they said, come let us build a city. Vayehi in the days of Amrafel (Genesis 14:1) — then they made war. Vayehi when Joshua was in Jericho (Joshua 5:13) — then his [the angel’s] sword was drawn in his hand. And the Lord was [vayehi] with Joshua (Joshua 6:27) — then the children of Israel trespassed. Vayehi a certain man of Ramataim-Zophim (I Samuel 1:1) — then, for he loved Hannah but the Lord had shut up her womb.
Vayehi when Shmuel was old (I Samuel 8:1) — then, his sons walked not in his ways. And David had [vayehi] great success in all his ways (I Samuel 18:14) — then, And Saul had enmity with David. Vayehi when the king dwelt in his house (II Samuel 7:1) — then, Nevertheless you shall not build the house.
Vayehi when Shmuel was old (I Samuel 8:1) — then, his sons walked not in his ways. And David had [vayehi] great success in all his ways (I Samuel 18:14) — then, And Saul had enmity with David. Vayehi when the king dwelt in his house (II Samuel 7:1) — then, Nevertheless you shall not build the house.
But is it not written, Vayehi on the eighth day (Leviticus 9:1), and it has been taught: On that day there was joy before the Holy One, blessed be He, as on the day when heaven and earth were created. For it is written, And it came to pass [vayehi] on the eighth day, and it is written there, And there was [vayehi] one day?
But is it not written, “Vayehi in the four hundred and eightieth year” (I Kings 6:1), “Vayehi when Jacob saw Rachel” (Genesis 29:1), and it is also written, “Vayehi was evening and there was morning one day” (Genesis 1:5), and there is the second day and the third, and there are many other cases?
Five times we find the expression: “Vayehi in the days" “Vayehi in the days of Ahashverosh” (Esther 1:1), “Vayehi in the days when the Judges judged” (Ruth 1:1), “Vayehi in the days of Amrafel” (Genesis 14:1), “Vayehi in the days of Ahaz” (Isaiah 7:1) “And it came to pass in the days of Yehoiakim” (Jeremiah 1:3).
“For we are servants; yet God has not forsaken us in our bondage, but has extended mercy unto us in the sight of the kings of Persia” (Ezra 9:9). When was this? In the time of Haman.
Yohanan began his discourse on this section with the following text: “He has remembered his mercy and his faithfulness to the house of Israel, all the ends of the earth have seen the salvation of our Lord” (Psalms 98:3). When did all the ends of the earth see the salvation of our Lord? In the days of Mordecai and Esther.
Nahman b. Isaac began his discourse on this section with the following text: “A Song of Ascents: If it had not been for the Lord who was for us let Israel now say, If it had not been the Lord who was for us when a man rose up against us” (Psalms 124:1-2) — “a man” and not a king.
Rava began his discourse on this section from here: “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice, but when the wicked rules the people sigh” (Proverbs 29:2). “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice” — this is Mordecai and Esther, as it is written, “And the city of Shushan shouted and was glad” (Esther 8:15). “But when the wicked rules the people sigh” — this is Haman, as it is written, “But the city of Shushan was perplexed” (Esther 3:15).
Rava began his discourse on this section from here: “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice, but when the wicked rules the people sigh” (Proverbs 29:2). “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice” — this is Mordecai and Esther, as it is written, “And the city of Shushan shouted and was glad” (Esther 8:15). “But when the wicked rules the people sigh” — this is Haman, as it is written, “But the city of Shushan was perplexed” (Esther 3:15).
Rava began his discourse on this section from here: “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice, but when the wicked rules the people sigh” (Proverbs 29:2). “When the righteous are increased the people rejoice” — this is Mordecai and Esther, as it is written, “And the city of Shushan shouted and was glad” (Esther 8:15). “But when the wicked rules the people sigh” — this is Haman, as it is written, “But the city of Shushan was perplexed” (Esther 3:15).