12911 occurrences across the corpus

The Babylonian Talmud

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:460

Rava said to Abaye: according to you who say that the edge of the roof [is regarded as though it] descends and fills in [the space, is a sukkah valid] even if the middle wall is missing? .He answered him, In that case I agree with you [that the Sukkah is invalid] since it would be like an alley-way that is open on two opposite sides.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:461

Shall we say that Abaye and Rava disagree on the same principle as that on which Rav and Shmuel differed for it was stated: If an exedra was in a field: Rav declares that it is permitted to carry [on Shabbat] over the whole extent of it, since we say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in the space; While Samuel said that it is forbidden to carry in it except within four cubits, since we do not say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in [the space]?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:461

Shall we say that Abaye and Rava disagree on the same principle as that on which Rav and Shmuel differed for it was stated: If an exedra was in a field: Rav declares that it is permitted to carry [on Shabbat] over the whole extent of it, since we say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in the space; While Samuel said that it is forbidden to carry in it except within four cubits, since we do not say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in [the space]?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:461

Shall we say that Abaye and Rava disagree on the same principle as that on which Rav and Shmuel differed for it was stated: If an exedra was in a field: Rav declares that it is permitted to carry [on Shabbat] over the whole extent of it, since we say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in the space; While Samuel said that it is forbidden to carry in it except within four cubits, since we do not say that the edge of the roof descends and fills in [the space]?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:463

They only differ with regard to the opinion of Rav. Abaye agrees with Rav, while Rava can say that Rav ruled then only in that case, since the partitions are made for the exedra, but in the case here, since they are not made for this purpose [he would] not [rule thus].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:493

And this is what was meant: If a large mat of reeds is made specifically for reclining upon, it is susceptible to [ritual] uncleanliness and is invalid as skhakh. The reason is that it was made specifically for reclining upon, but ordinarily it is regarded as though it was made for a covering, and is valid as skhakh. A small [mat], if made for a covering, is valid as skhakh. The reason is that it was made specifically for covering, but ordinarily it is regarded as though made for reclining upon, and is invalid for a Sukkah-covering. [This is the view of the first Tanna] And R. Eliezer comes to say that whether it is small, or large, if made without specific purpose, it is valid as skhakh.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:500

We have learned elsewhere: All [hotzlot] mats are [liable to become] impure by corpse impurity, the words of Rabbi Dosa. But the Sages say: [Also by] midras impurity.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:501

[Can it mean] to the uncleanliness of midras but not to that of a corpse! But haven't we learned: Whatever is susceptible to uncleanliness of midras is also susceptible to uncleanliness from a corpse? Say rather also to the uncleanliness of midras.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 1:507

It was objected: Mats of bamboo, of reed grass, of sackcloth or of goat's-hair are susceptible to corpse uncleanliness, the words of R. Dosa, But the sages say: they are also susceptible to midras uncleanliness. It goes well according to him who says [that hozlot means] ‘bags filled with foliage’, since those of bamboo and of reed-grass can be used for a basket fruit, while those of sackcloth and goat's-hair can be used for sacks or baskets,

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:1

He who sleeps under a bed in the sukkah has not fulfilled his obligation. Rabbi Judah said: we had the custom to sleep under a bed in the presence of the elders, and they didn’t say anything to us.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:18

And if you like[you may say that] R. Judah follows his own view that a Sukkah must be a permanent abode; and since a bed is but a temporary abode, while a Sukkah is a permanent ‘tent’, a temporary tent cannot annul a permanent one.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:19

But does not R. Shimon also say that a Sukkah must be a permanent abode, and yet [he holds that] a temporary tent does annul a permanent tent? It is in this that they differ One Master holds that a temporary tent can come and annul a permanent tent, while the other Master holds that a temporary tent cannot annul a permanent tent.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:21

But why does he not say, From the words of R. Gamaliel"? He informs us of something [else] by the way, like that which R Aha b. Ada, and others say, R. Aha b. Ada in the name of R. Hamnuna said in the name of Rav: From where do we know that even the casual conversation of disciples of the sages demands study? As it says, "And whose leaf does not wither" (Psalms 1:3).

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:21

But why does he not say, From the words of R. Gamaliel"? He informs us of something [else] by the way, like that which R Aha b. Ada, and others say, R. Aha b. Ada in the name of R. Hamnuna said in the name of Rav: From where do we know that even the casual conversation of disciples of the sages demands study? As it says, "And whose leaf does not wither" (Psalms 1:3).

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:29

Abaye stated, this applies only where there are not three handbreadths of distance between one reed and another, but if there are three handbreadths between one and another, it is invalid. Rava says, even if there are three handbreadths between one and another we also do not say [that it is invalid] unless the upper reed is not a handbreadth wide but if the upper reed is a handbreadth wide, it is valid, since we apply to it the law of "beat and cast it down."

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:30

Rava said: From where do I say that if the upper reed is a handbreadth wide we apply to it the law of ‘beat and throw it down,’ and if it is not so wide we do not apply it? From what we have learned: 1) [With regard to] the roof beams of a house and of the upper story which have no plaster ceiling upon them and are in a line, [the upper ones exactly above the lower]: a) If there is uncleanness beneath one of them, all beneath that one becomes unclean.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:40

He replied, solve it and say it this way: 1) Provided that the upper one is not more than twenty [cubits from the ground], but within the twenty [cubits], and the lower one is near it within less than three [handbreadths], 2) Alternatively provided that the lower one is not less than ten [cubits from the ground] but more than ten, and the upper one is near it within less than three [handbreadths], 3) But if they were three [handbreadths apart] since [the upper beam] is not a handbreadth [wide], we do not apply the law of ‘beat and throw down’.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:42

There is no difficulty, since the former refers to above and the latter to below. R. Papa said, this is like what people say, ‘the size of a zuz above becomes the size of an issar below’.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:52

If he used an animal as a wall of the Sukkah: R. Meir declares it invalid and R. Judah valid, for R. Meir used to say, Whatever contains the breath of life cannot be used as a wall for a Sukkah, nor a side-post for an alley nor boards around wells, nor a covering stone for a grave n the name of R. Yose the Galilean they said, Nor may a get be written upon it.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:58

But did Abaye say that R. Meir is concerned because of the possibility of death while R. Judah is not concerned? But haven't we learned: If the daughter of an Israelite was married to a priest, and her husband went to a country beyond the sea, she may eat of terumah on the presumption that he is still alive

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:61

As it has been taught, If a man buys wine from Samaritans he may say, ‘Two log which I intend to set aside are terumah, ten are the first tithe, and nine the second tithe’, and then he redeems it and may drink it at once, the words of R. Meir.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:71

Rather R. Aha b. Jacob said that R. Meir holds that any partition which is upheld by wind is not a valid partition. There are others who say that R. Aha b. Jacob said that R. Meir holds that any partition which is not made by the hands of man is no partition.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:76

And the Rabbis? If Scripture had written "In a scroll", [it would be] as you say, but now that it is written "a scroll" it refers to the recital of the words.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:79

They need [this terminology to teach that the get must be] one which severs them [completely], as it has been taught. [If a man say,] Here is your get on condition that you do not drink wine, or go to your father's house ever, it is not a proper severance. For thirty days, it is a severance.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:87

But if so, it should be permitted to carry objects over its whole area; why then did R. Huna the son of R. Joshua say: One may not carry any objects there

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:94

Are we not discussing one who is traveling to perform a mizvah, and the Merciful One said that he should read it? If so, then let the verse say "in sitting and in going". What is [the reason for] "in your sitting and in your going?" One who is going for himself is obligated. This one traveling to perform a mitzvah is exempt.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:96

And all who are preoccupied, they too should be exempt? But from that, one who is preoccupied from losing his ship at sea, he should also be exempt. And would you say here also? But Rav Abba bar Zavda said in the name of Rav: A mourner is obligated in all of the mitzvot in the Torah, except for tefillin, as behold, they are spoken of as splendor.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:110

It has been taught: R. Hanania b. Akavya said: Scribes writing [Torah] scrolls, tefillin and mezuzot, their agents and their agents’ agents, and all who are engaged in holy work including sellers of blue [for tzitzit] are exempt from the obligation of prayer and tefillin and all the commandments mentioned in the Torah, to confirm the words of R. Yose the Galilean, for R. Yose the Galilean used to say: He who is occupied with the performance of a mitzvah is [at that time] exempt from other mitzvot

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:124

but he should not hold the box, the words of R. Yaakov. The sages say: one may sleep casual sleep in his tefillin but not a regular sleep. And what constitutes a casual sleep? The time it takes to walk one hundred cubits.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:129

Shall we say that R. Yose is of the opinion that a man who has seminal emission may not wear his tefillin? Abaye answered: We are dealing here with the case of young men in the company of their wives, lest they grow accustomed to the practice.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:132

And when they gave Rabbi Zadok food less than the bulk of an egg, he took it in a napkin, ate it outside the sukkah and did not say a blessing after it.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:134

and they said, “Bring them up to the sukkah.” And when they gave Rabbi Zadok food less than the bulk of an egg, he took it in a napkin, ate it outside the sukkah and did not say a blessing after it.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:135

But if it was the bulk of an egg, he must [eat it in] the Sukkah. Should we say that this is a refutation of R. Joseph and Abaye? Perhaps [it means that] less than the bulk of an egg does not necessitate washing of the hands and the benediction, but if it was the bulk of an egg, it necessitates washing of the hands and the benediction.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:136

Rabbi Eliezer says: a man is obligated to eat fourteen meals in the sukkah, one on each day and one on each night. But the sages say: there is no fixed number, except on the first night of the festival alone.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:137

Furthermore Rabbi Eliezer said: if one did not eat in the sukkah on the first night of the festival, he may make up for it on the last night of the festival. But the sages say: there is no compensation for this, and of this was it said: “That which is crooked cannot be made straight, and that which is lacking cannot be counted” (Ecclesiastes 1:15).

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:143

R. Eliezer further said…. But didn't R. Eliezer say that a man is obliged to eat fourteen meals in the sukkah, one on each day and one on each night? Bira said in the name of R. Ammi: R. Eliezer changed his mind.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:144

How does one make up for it? If you say with bread, he's just eating the [obligatory] meal of the festival day? Rather how does he make up for it? By eating various kinds of desert. So it has also been taught: If he made up [for a meal he has missed] with various kinds of desert he fulfilled his obligation.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:146

He also asked him: [A man] such as I who has two wives, one in Tiberias and one in Tzippori, and two sukkahs, one in Tiberias and one in Tzippori, may I go from one Sukkah to the other and thus be free from my obligation? He answered him, No! For I say that he who goes from one Sukkah to another annuls the mitzvah of the first.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:148

"We don't leave from one Sukkah to another Sukkah, and we do not make Sukkot in the normal days of the festival." And the Sages say, "We do leave from one Sukkah to another Sukkah, and we do make Sukot in the normal days of the festival." And they are in agreement that if it fell, he can return and build it in the normal days of the festival.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:152

The sages say: Although they said that one cannot fulfil his obligation on the first day of the Festival with the lulav belonging to his fellow, he may nevertheless fulfill his obligation with the Sukkah of his fellow, since it is written, "All that are homeborn in Israel shall dwell in Sukkot" (Leviticus 23:42) this teaches that all of Israel are fit to sit in one Sukkah

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:155

Our rabbis have taught: It once happened that R. Ila'i went to greet R. Eliezer his master in Lod on a Festival. He said to him, Ila'i, aren't you one of those that stay in place on the Festival, for R. Eliezer used to say, I praise the lazy who do not go out of their houses on the Festival since it is written, "And you shall rejoice, you and your household" (Deuteronomy 14:26).

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:156

But is it so? But didn't R. Yitzchak say, From where do we know that a man is obliged to greet his master on the Festival? As it says, "Why are you going to him today? It is neither Rosh Hodesh nor Shabbat" (II Kings 4:23) from which it follows that on Rosh Hodesh and Shabbat one is obligated greet his master?’ There is no difficulty. The latter refers to where he can go and return [to his house] on the one day; the former to where he cannot go and return on the same day.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:157

Our rabbis have taught: It happened that R. Eliezer spent Shabbat in the Upper Galilee in the sukkah of R. Yohanan son of R. Ila'i in Caesarea or, as some say, in Caesarion and when the sun reached the Sukkah he said to him: Can I spread a cloth over it?’ He said to him, "There was no tribe in Israel which did not produce a judge."

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:159

How did R. Eliezer do this? Did not R. Eliezer say, "One may not go from one Sukkah to another?" It was on another Festival.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:160

But did not R. Eliezer say, "I praise the lazy who do not leave their houses on the Festival? It was a Shabbat.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:161

But could he not deduce [the answer] from his own statement, for we have learned: A window-shutter: R. Eliezer says if it is fastened or hung [on the window-frame] one may shut a window with it [on Shabbat], but if not, one may not shut a window with it; but the Sages say: in either case one may shut the window with it?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:164

They said to him, "All of your words are nothing except from rumors." He said to them, "You have bound me to say something that I did not hear from my teachers [by asking me these questions.] In all my days, a person never came before me to the House of Study, And neither did I sleep in the House of Study, neither a permanent sleep nor a temporary sleep, and never did I leave a man in the House of Study and exit, and never did I converse in everyday conversation, and I never said anything which I did not hear from my teacher at any time."

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:169

Mishnah: 1) One whose head and the greater part of his body were within the sukkah and his table within the house: i) Bet Shammai say: it is invalid and Bet Hillel say it valid. 2) Bet Hillel said to Bet Shammai: Did it not in fact happen that the elders of Bet Shammai and the elders of Bet Hillel went to visit Rabbi Yohanan ben HaHoroni and found him sitting with his head and the greater part of his body within the sukkah and his table within the house, and they didn’t say anything to him? i) Bet Shammai said to them: From there [you bring] proof? Indeed they said to him, “If this is your custom, then you have never in your whole life fulfilled the commandment of the sukkah.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:169

Mishnah: 1) One whose head and the greater part of his body were within the sukkah and his table within the house: i) Bet Shammai say: it is invalid and Bet Hillel say it valid. 2) Bet Hillel said to Bet Shammai: Did it not in fact happen that the elders of Bet Shammai and the elders of Bet Hillel went to visit Rabbi Yohanan ben HaHoroni and found him sitting with his head and the greater part of his body within the sukkah and his table within the house, and they didn’t say anything to him? i) Bet Shammai said to them: From there [you bring] proof? Indeed they said to him, “If this is your custom, then you have never in your whole life fulfilled the commandment of the sukkah.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:169

Mishnah: 1) One whose head and the greater part of his body were within the sukkah and his table within the house: i) Bet Shammai say: it is invalid and Bet Hillel say it valid. 2) Bet Hillel said to Bet Shammai: Did it not in fact happen that the elders of Bet Shammai and the elders of Bet Hillel went to visit Rabbi Yohanan ben HaHoroni and found him sitting with his head and the greater part of his body within the sukkah and his table within the house, and they didn’t say anything to him? i) Bet Shammai said to them: From there [you bring] proof? Indeed they said to him, “If this is your custom, then you have never in your whole life fulfilled the commandment of the sukkah.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:172

The Master has said: ‘The homeborn’ excludes women. That is to say "homeborn" implies both men and women? But has it not been taught: "The homeborn" includes the homeborn women that they must afflict themselves [on Yom Kippur], which shows that [only] "homeborn" implies men [only]? Rabbah answered: They are traditions but the Rabbis applied a Scriptural verse to them.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:177

And now that you say that Sukkah is a traditional law, what is the verse for? To include converts. Lest I would have said "the homeborn in Israel," the Torah said, but not converts, therefore it informs us that it is not so.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:184

But is this so? But did not Rava say, Scripture and Mishnah [should be studied] in the Sukkah, but reciting outside the Sukkah? There is no difficulty, One refers to reciting, one refers to examination.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:186

Raba said: drinking vessels may be kept in the Sukkah, eating vessels outside the Sukkah Earthenware pitchers and wooden pails [must be kept] outside the Sukkah. A lamp [may be kept] within the Sukkah, while some say [that it must be kept] outside the Sukkah; but they do not disagree, here refers to a large Sukkah and here refers to a small one.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:190

They asked them: Does it say שיעור (until he wakes up) or שיאור (until dawn)? Come and hear: Until it gets light (שיאור) and the dawn appears. Both? Rather say until he wakes up (שיעור) and the dawn appears.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:190

They asked them: Does it say שיעור (until he wakes up) or שיאור (until dawn)? Come and hear: Until it gets light (שיאור) and the dawn appears. Both? Rather say until he wakes up (שיעור) and the dawn appears.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 2:195

If its face is red as blood, [it is a sign that] the sword is coming to the world; if it is like sack-cloth, the arrows of famine are coming to the world; if it resembles both, the sword and the arrows of famine are coming to the world. If the eclipse is at sunset calamity will be delayed; if at dawn, it will come quickly: but some say the order is to be reversed

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:6

It makes sense, to say before the owner's despair: "A person, when he brings from his," said the Merciful one, and it (the stolen animal) is not his. But after the owner's despair- hasn't he taken ownership when the owner despaired? Rather, it is for the reason that it is for him a commandment that is fulfilled through a transgression.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:10

Questioned Rabbi Nachman the son of Yitzchak, "A Lulav that is stolen or dry is invalid; doesn't [it exempt] a borrowed [Lulav as] valid? When [is it exempted as valid]? If you would say on the first day of the holiday, isn't it written, 'For you'- [meaning] from that which is yours? And isn't [a borrowed Lulav] not belonging to him? Rather, [it means] on the second day of the holiday, and as [the mishnah] taught, a stolen [Lulav] is invalid.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:11

(Rava said), Really, [the Mishnah applies] on the first day of the holiday, and we do not need to state [the other case of a borrowed Lulav]. We do not need to state [the law about a] borrowed Lulav [being invalid], for it is not his. However, [with a] stolen [Lulav], I say that outright robbery includes the despair of the [original] owners, and so it resembles being his. We can learn from this [the halakha].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:16

And even if you find [that we need] to say that a Lulav requires a tie, a change that does not affect the actual object (lit. goes back to its original form) it is, and a change that goes back to its original form is not called a change [for halakhic purposes].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:21

And the Sages [rule] according to their opinion, as they say, 'A person fulfills his obligation with his fellow's Sukkah, And land cannot be stolen, and so it is a borrowed Sukkah [which is allowed].'

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:27

This is obvious! How is it different than [normal] wood? You might have said, "Wood is commonly found, but these [i.e. beams] are not common, I would say not [a valid argument], and we can learn from this [i.e. Ravina's statement].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:33

No. For didn't Rava say [about Rabbi Yehudah's use of the phrase 'with its own species'], "[One can bind the Lulav] even with the vines, and even with the bark, of the palm [which are not beautiful]. Rather, what is the reasoning for Rabbi Yehudah's [statement] there? He had thought, "A Lulav needs binding, and if he brings another species [as binding material], it would be for him five species."

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:44

And rather, for Rabbi Yehuda, does it not say [in reference to the Etrog] "Beautiful ['Hadar']"?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:46

(Mishnah:) [A Lulav] of a worshipped tree or of a wayward city is invalid. (Gemara:) And that of a worshipped tree is invalid? But didn't Rava say, "A Lulav of idol worship should not be taken [for the Mitzvah], but if it was taken, it is valid [as opposed to the Mishnah's ruling]?"

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:53

R. Nahman said: At the sides is the same as at the front, and some say, the same as at its back.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:57

since it is entirely lacking There are those that say: R. Yohanan said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi:

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:66

R. Marion said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi, and others say that Rabbah b. Mari taught in the name of R. Yohanan b. Zakkai: here are two palms in the valley of Hinnom, and smoke goes up between them, and it is in that connection that we have learned the thorn-palms of the Iron Mountain are valid, and it is the entrance to Gehenna.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:69

Have we not learned, a lulav which is three handbreadths in length, long enough to wave, is valid? Say " and long enough to wave"; and each one explains it according to his own view.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:74

Do not then two statements of Shmuel contradict one another, for here Rav Judah says in the name of Shmuel, The [minimum] length of the hadas and the aravah is three [normal handbreadths], and elsewhere R. Huna said in the name of Shmuel that the halakhah is in accordance with R. Tarfon? [Shmuel] was not precise. Say that we can say that one is not precise when [this results in] a stringency but not when [it results in] a leniency?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:74

Do not then two statements of Shmuel contradict one another, for here Rav Judah says in the name of Shmuel, The [minimum] length of the hadas and the aravah is three [normal handbreadths], and elsewhere R. Huna said in the name of Shmuel that the halakhah is in accordance with R. Tarfon? [Shmuel] was not precise. Say that we can say that one is not precise when [this results in] a stringency but not when [it results in] a leniency?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:78

Gemara. Our Rabbis taught, "Branches of a thick tree" [means] [the kind of tree] whose branches completely cover its trunk Now what [tree] is this? You must say that it is the myrtle (hadas). But perhaps it is the olive? It must be wreathed, but [the olive] is not.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:81

Our Rabbis taught: Plaited like a plait and similar to a chain—that is the myrtle. R. Eliezer b. Yaakov said "The branches of a thick tree" [means] a tree the taste of whose wood and whose fruit is similar: Say, then, it is the myrtle.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:96

Can we say that these are according to the following tannaim? If he transgressed and picked them off, it is invalid, the words of R. Elazar b. Zadok. But the sages declare it valid. They thought to explain his in the following way: According to all the lulav does not need binding, and even if you find to say that it does need binding, we do not deduce [the laws of] lulav from those of Sukkah of which it is written, "You shall make’ [which implies] but not from that which is already made.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:96

Can we say that these are according to the following tannaim? If he transgressed and picked them off, it is invalid, the words of R. Elazar b. Zadok. But the sages declare it valid. They thought to explain his in the following way: According to all the lulav does not need binding, and even if you find to say that it does need binding, we do not deduce [the laws of] lulav from those of Sukkah of which it is written, "You shall make’ [which implies] but not from that which is already made.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:99

And if you want you can say: If we held that the lulav needs binding all would have agreed that we deduce [the laws of] lulav from [those of] Sukkah; But they disagree here on whether the lulav needs binding, and concerning the dispute of the following tannaim: Our Rabbis have taught: A lulav, whether [the other prescribed species were] bound with it or not, is valid. R. Judah says: If it is bound [with the others] it is valid; if it is unbound, it is invalid.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:107

If he reduced their number, it is valid. When did he reduce them? If you say, before he bound them, this is obvious? Rather after he bound them? This then is a case of "set aside" from the very outset! Deduce from here that if something is "set aside" from the outset it is not [permanently] "set aside"?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:109

But one may not reduce them [the berries] on Yom Tov. But if he transgressed and did pluck them it is valid. But then, when did it become black? If you will say that it became black from the previous day, then it is a case of "set aside" from the very outset. Deduce from here that something that is "set aside" from the very outset is not [permanently] set aside?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:113

R. Ashi said: This is a case where he plucked them for food, and R. Eliezer son of R. Shimon holds the same opinion as his father who said that a work which is done without intention is permitted. But do not both Abaye and Raba say that

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:138

R. Eliezer said to him: It is possible that the etrog should be bound with them in one bundle, [to this] you can say, is it written, "the fruit of a goodly tree and branches of palmtrees"? It says only, "branches of palm-trees." And from where do we know that lack of fulfillment of one prevents fulfillment of the others? Scripture says, "And you shall take" [implying] that the taking must be complete.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:141

What is his reason? If you say that it is because he is lenient, why did he not expound to them as R. Akiva who is even more lenient? Three with broken tips are common, one with an unbroken tip is uncommon.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:144

The rabbis taught: "The fruit of a goodly tree" (Leviticus 23:40) a tree the taste of whose ‘fruit’ and ‘wood’ is the same. Say then that it is the etrog.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:145

Say that it is pepper, as it has been taught: R. Meir used to say, From that which it says, "And you have planted all manner of trees," (Leviticus 19:23) do I not know that the reference is to a tree for food? What then does Scripture teach by "for food"? A tree whose fruit and wood taste the same. Say then that it is pepper. This is to teach you that the pepper tree is subject to the law of orlah and that the Land of Israel lacks nothing, as it is said, "You shall not lack anything in it"?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:145

Say that it is pepper, as it has been taught: R. Meir used to say, From that which it says, "And you have planted all manner of trees," (Leviticus 19:23) do I not know that the reference is to a tree for food? What then does Scripture teach by "for food"? A tree whose fruit and wood taste the same. Say then that it is pepper. This is to teach you that the pepper tree is subject to the law of orlah and that the Land of Israel lacks nothing, as it is said, "You shall not lack anything in it"?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:145

Say that it is pepper, as it has been taught: R. Meir used to say, From that which it says, "And you have planted all manner of trees," (Leviticus 19:23) do I not know that the reference is to a tree for food? What then does Scripture teach by "for food"? A tree whose fruit and wood taste the same. Say then that it is pepper. This is to teach you that the pepper tree is subject to the law of orlah and that the Land of Israel lacks nothing, as it is said, "You shall not lack anything in it"?

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:147

Rabbi said: Read not hadar but ha-dir; just as the stable contains large and small [animals], perfect and blemished ones, so also [the fruit spoken of must have] large and small, perfect and blemished. But don't other fruits have large and small, perfect and blemished? Rather this is what you should say: Before the small ones come, the large are still existent [on the tree].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:148

R. Abbahu said: Read not hadar, but ha-dar, a fruit which lives upon its tree from year to year. Ben Azzai said: Read not hadar, but hudor for in Greek water is called hudor. Now what fruit is it that grows by every water? Say it is the etrog.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:156

R. Papa raised a difficulty: his is well with regard to dough, since it is written, "The first of your dough" (Numbers 15:20). And with regard to the etrog also it is written, "To you" it must be yours. But with regard to matzah, does Scripture say, "your matzah"? Rabbah bar Shmuel, or as some say, R. Yemar bar Shelemia said: It can be deduced from the word "bread" which is common to both passages. It is written here, "The bread of affliction" (Deuteronomy 16:3) and there it is written,

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:156

R. Papa raised a difficulty: his is well with regard to dough, since it is written, "The first of your dough" (Numbers 15:20). And with regard to the etrog also it is written, "To you" it must be yours. But with regard to matzah, does Scripture say, "your matzah"? Rabbah bar Shmuel, or as some say, R. Yemar bar Shelemia said: It can be deduced from the word "bread" which is common to both passages. It is written here, "The bread of affliction" (Deuteronomy 16:3) and there it is written,

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:158

Can we say that the following supports [this view]: Dough of second tithe is exempt from hallah, according to R. Meir, while the Sages say that it is liable? Can we say that the following supports [this view]! It is the identical statement!

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:158

Can we say that the following supports [this view]: Dough of second tithe is exempt from hallah, according to R. Meir, while the Sages say that it is liable? Can we say that the following supports [this view]! It is the identical statement!

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:158

Can we say that the following supports [this view]: Dough of second tithe is exempt from hallah, according to R. Meir, while the Sages say that it is liable? Can we say that the following supports [this view]! It is the identical statement!

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:159

Rather [the question was whether we can say that] since they dispute in this instance, they also dispute in the others or perhaps dough is exceptional because Scripture says the words "your dough."

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:165

And Bet Shammai: a poor man may not eat demai; as we have learned, Poor men and quartered troops may eat demai and R. Huna said: A tanna taught: Bet Shammai say that poor men and quartered troops may not be fed with demai, while Bet Hillel say that poor men and quartered troops may be fed with demai.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:165

And Bet Shammai: a poor man may not eat demai; as we have learned, Poor men and quartered troops may eat demai and R. Huna said: A tanna taught: Bet Shammai say that poor men and quartered troops may not be fed with demai, while Bet Hillel say that poor men and quartered troops may be fed with demai.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:176

Come and hear: An etrog which is swollen, decayed, pickled, boiled, Ethiopian (black), white or speckled, is invalid. An etrog which is round as a ball is invalid. And some say: also if two are grown together. An etrog which is half-ripe, R. Akiva declares it invalid, and the sages valid. If it was grown in a cast, so that it has the appearance of another species, it is invalid.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:182

And there is nothing more [to say about it].

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:186

There are those who say: Rav ruled that "goodly" since R. Hanina tasted a part [of an etrog] and fulfilled his obligation [with the remainder]. But is not our Mishnah a difficulty against R. Hanina? There is no contradiction since the former refers to the first day of the Festival, while the latter refers to the second day.

Babylonian Talmud Sukkah 3:195

But did R. Judah really say that the four species can be used but not anything else? Was it not taught: If he covered it with planks of cedar wood which are four handbreadths wide, everyone holds it is invalid. If they are not four handbreadths wide, R. Meir declares it invalid and R. Judah valid. And R. Meir agrees that if there is a space of one plank between every two planks, he may place valid skhakh between them and the sukkah is valid.