reason
2574 occurrences across the corpus
The Babylonian Talmud
What is R. Nathan's reason ? Because it is written, "So Gideon, and the hundred men that were with him, came unto the outermost part of the camp in the beginning of the middle watch " (Judges vii 19). Hence he teaches that there cannot be a "middle watch" unless one precedes and follows.
What is Rabbi's reason [for declaring there are four watches] ? R. Zerika stated that R. Ammi said in the name of R. Joshua b. Levi : One verse states, "At midnight I will rise to give thanks unto Thee because of Thy righteous ordinances" (Ps. cxix. 62) and another verse states, "Mine eyes forestalled the night-watches" (ibid. 5:148). How is this? There must be four watches in the night.
They certainly agree with Rabban Gamaliel, and the reason they say Until midnight is to keep a man far from transgression. This is like the teaching: The Sages made a "fence" to their words, so that a man shall not come from the field in the evening and say, "I will go home, eat a little, drink a little, sleep a little, and after that I will read the Shema' and say the Tefillah"; for slumber may overcome him and as a result he may sleep through all the night. Rather should a man come from the field in the evening and enter a Synagogue ; if he is accustomed to read [the Scriptures], let him read; if he is accustomed to study, let him study. Then let him read the Shema' and say the Tefillah; after that he should eat his meal and say Grace.
What is the reason?
No, the reason is that it contains the verse, "Thou openest Thy hand and satisfiest every living thing with favour" (Ps. cxlv. 16). Then let him say the Great Hallel which includes "Who giveth food to all flesh" (ibid. cxxxvi. 25)!
"Let him trust in the name of the Lord" (ibid.). For what reason [is the light denied him] ? Because he should have trusted in the name of the Lord, but did not.
But they spoke to him thus : The Rabbis differ from thee, and where an individual differs from the many, the Halakah is in accord with the many. Or perhaps, the Rabbis agree with thee, and the reason that they declare [that the evening Shema' may be read] "Until midnight" is in order to keep a man far from transgression ? He answered them. The Rabbis hold the same view as myself, and you are under the obligation [to read the Shema']; and the reason they say "Until midnight" is to keep a man far from transgression.
But they spoke to him thus : The Rabbis differ from thee, and where an individual differs from the many, the Halakah is in accord with the many. Or perhaps, the Rabbis agree with thee, and the reason that they declare [that the evening Shema' may be read] "Until midnight" is in order to keep a man far from transgression ? He answered them. The Rabbis hold the same view as myself, and you are under the obligation [to read the Shema']; and the reason they say "Until midnight" is to keep a man far from transgression.
Nay, thus spake Rabban Gamaliel to his sons : Even according to the Rabbis who say "Until midnight," the obligation continues until the rise of dawn ; and the reason they say "Until midnight" is to keep a man far from transgression.
For what reason? Rab Judah said : So that [the child] may not gaze at the place of nakedness. Rab Mattena said : So that it should not have to suck from a part of the body which is foul.
He asked him, "Why all this [severe punishment]?" He replied, "Because thou hast not performed the duty of begetting children. " Hezekiah said to him, "The reason is that I have seen by the aid of the Holy Spirit, that worthless children will issue from me."
GEMARA It is all very well that Bet Hillel explain their reasons and the reason of Bet Shammai ; but why do not Bet Shammai agree with Bet Hillel?
Should the reason [of exemption] be on account of anxiety, then it ought also to apply to one whose ship has sunk at sea ! Shouldest thou say that he likewise is exempt, why does R. Abba b. Zabda declare in the name of Rab : A mourner is under the obligation to observe all the commandments mentioned in the Torah except Tefillin, because they are called an adornment ; as it is said, "Bind thine adornment upon thee" (Ezek. xxiv. 17)?
Shouldest thou, on the other hand, maintain that they recited "With abounding love," how would it follow that the benedictions do not invalidate one another? Perhaps the reason they omitted "Who formest light" was because it was not yet time for that prayer, and when the proper time arrived, they said it!
What is the reason ? Because dates likewise nourish.
Samuel asked : What is Rab's reason ? Because it is written, "The Lord raiseth up them that are bowed down" (ibid, cxlvi. 8).
What is the reason ? Are we to suppose it is because it is written, "There is none of you that is sorry for me or discloseth unto me" (ibid. xxii. 8)? Perhaps it is different in the case of a king! Nay, [derive the reason] from the following : "But as for me, when they were sick, my clothing was sackcloth, I afflicted my soul with fasting ; and my prayer, may it return into mine own bosom" (Ps. xxxv. 13).
What is the reason ? Are we to suppose it is because it is written, "There is none of you that is sorry for me or discloseth unto me" (ibid. xxii. 8)? Perhaps it is different in the case of a king! Nay, [derive the reason] from the following : "But as for me, when they were sick, my clothing was sackcloth, I afflicted my soul with fasting ; and my prayer, may it return into mine own bosom" (Ps. xxxv. 13).
Perhaps it is different with a community? Nay, [derive the reason] from the following: "And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed ; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams; therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do" (I Sam. xxviii. 15). Saul did not mention [having inquired through] the Urim and Tummim,
Nay ; R. Jose b. Abin said : [The reason is] because it is written therein, "He couched, he lay down as a lion, and as a lioness ; who shall rouse him up?" (ibid. xxiv. 9).
MISHNAH V The exodus from Egypt must be mentioned at night. R. Eleazar b. 'Azariah said : Behold I am like one seventy years old, and I have never been worthy [to hear the reason] why the exodus from Egypt should he mentioned at night, until Ben Zoma expounded it [as follows].
What is Rabbi's reason ? The text states, "And these words shall be" (Deut. vi. 6); i.e. as they are, so must they remain.
And what is the reason of the Sages? The text states, "Hear, O Israel" (ibid. v. 4); i.e. in any language which thou hearest.
R. Abbahu said in the name of R. Johanan : The Halakah is in accord with R. Judah who maintains that one may not interrupt between "I am the Lord your God" and "True and firm." R. Abbahu [also] said in the name of R. Johanan: What is R. Judah's reason? Because it is written,
But derive the reason [for the order of the paragraphs] from the statement of R. Joshua b. Karhah! [He gave] one reason and now another is added; viz. : [the first is] in order that a man shall first receive upon himself the yoke of the kingdom of heaven and afterwards receive upon himself the yoke of the commandments ; and the second reason is because the first paragraph contains these other references.
But derive the reason [for the order of the paragraphs] from the statement of R. Joshua b. Karhah! [He gave] one reason and now another is added; viz. : [the first is] in order that a man shall first receive upon himself the yoke of the kingdom of heaven and afterwards receive upon himself the yoke of the commandments ; and the second reason is because the first paragraph contains these other references.
But derive the reason [for the order of the paragraphs] from the statement of R. Joshua b. Karhah! [He gave] one reason and now another is added; viz. : [the first is] in order that a man shall first receive upon himself the yoke of the kingdom of heaven and afterwards receive upon himself the yoke of the commandments ; and the second reason is because the first paragraph contains these other references.
GEMARA What is R. Jose's reason [for declaring that unless the Shema' is read audibly the requirements of the law have not been fulfilled]? Because it is written, "Hear O Israel," i.e. let thine ear hear what thou issuest from thy mouth. And the first Tanna ? He holds that "Hear" [means that the Shema' may be read] in any language which thou hearest.
Dost thou suppose that R. Judah's reason is because the text states, "[And the priest] shall write"? His reason is because the text states, "[And the priest shall write] these curses," i.e. the curses shall be written, but not the words of the command.
Dost thou suppose that R. Judah's reason is because the text states, "[And the priest] shall write"? His reason is because the text states, "[And the priest shall write] these curses," i.e. the curses shall be written, but not the words of the command.
Should the reason [of exemption] be on account of anxiety, then it ought to apply also to one whose ship has sunk at sea ! Why, then, does R. Abba b. Zabda declare in the name of Rab : A mourner is under the obligation to observe all the commandments mentioned in the Torah except Tefillin, because they are called an adornment; as it is said, "Bind thine adornment upon thee" (Ezek. xxiv. 17)?
GEMARA What was Rabban Gamaliel's reason? He was of the opinion that the application of the laws of mourning in the night is a Rabbinical injunction; for it is written, "And the end thereof as a bitter day" (Amos viii. 10); and in the case of a person in delicate health, the Rabbis do not so decree.
Rab Judah said in the name of Rab : Who finds diverse kinds in his garment must divest himself thereof even in the street. What is the reason ? [As it is said,] "There is no wisdom nor understanding nor counsel against the Lord" (Prov. xxi. 30) — i.e. wherever the Divine Name is liable to be profaned, we pay no respect to a teacher.
R. Jose b. Hannina said : From the following passage [did R. Johanan derive his reason] : "And let them grow [weyidgu] into a multitude in the midst of the earth" (ibid. xlviii. 16) ; i.e. as the fishes [dagim] in the sea are covered by the water and the Evil Eye has no power over them,
But, said Raba, [the correct reason why they have to "sanctify" the Sabbath is because] the Scriptures declare, "Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy" (Exod. xx. 8) and "Observe the Sabbath to keep it holy" (Deut. v. 12) — everyone who has to "observe" must likewise "remember"; and since women must "observe," so must they "remember."
Also, according to thy reason, is a minor under the obligation [to say Grace] ? Nay, with what case are we here dealing ? With one who, for instance, has eaten the minimum quantity ordained by the Rabbis [as making the saying of Grace necessary] ; and thus one who is enjoined by the Rabbis [to say Grace] comes and exempts one [whose observance is likewise commanded] by the Rabbis.
But Tefillah is also a matter with which the Community is engaged, and there is a Mishnaic teaching: If he was standing in the Tefillah and recollected that he is a Ba'al Keri, he should not interrupt [his prayer] but shorten it. The reason is because he had already commenced it ; hence, if he had not commenced it, he should not do so !
Rab Judah said : If one is in doubt whether he has read the Shema' or not, he does not repeat it ; if he is in doubt whether he said "True and firm" or not, he does repeat it. What is the reason ? Because the reading of the Shema' is ordained by the Rabbis, but saying "True and firm" by the Torah.
And for what reason should he say this benediction ? If because it contains a reference to the Exodus from Egypt, he has already mentioned that in the Shema' !
R. Judah prohibits a man to marry one outraged or seduced by his father. Rab Giddel asked in the name of Rab : What is R. Judah 's reason? Because it is written, "A man shall not take his father's wife and shall not uncover his father's skirt" (Deut. xxiii. 1) — i.e. the skirt which his father had seen shall he not uncover. But how do we know that this refers to one outraged by his father ?
But this is what he means to say : This question [of carrying Tefillin in a regular privy but not a chance one] thou mayest argue with a reason; but thou must not argue it by means of a fortiori deduction, for if thou usest this method of argument, it is an argument which cannot be refuted.
Raba said : Although it is stated that the refutation of Samuel remained unanswered, nevertheless the Halakah is in accord with his view. What is the reason?
It has been reported : If there be filth upon his body, or his hand is placed within a privy, Rab Huna said : It is permitted to read the Shema' ; Rab Hisda said : It is forbidden to read it. Raba asked : What is Rab Huna's reason ? Because it is written, "Let everything that hath breath praise the Lord" (Ps. el. 6).
And Rab Hisda said : It is forbidden to read the Shema' [in such circumstances] — what is the reason ? Because it is written, "All my bones shall say, Lord who is like unto Thee" (ibid. xxxv. 10).
Rab Iwya was ill and did not attend Rab Joseph's discourse. The next day when he arrived, Abbai wished to set Rab Joseph's mind at rest ; so he said to him, "For what reason did not the master attend the discourse?" He replied, "My heart was faint and I could not." He asked him, "Why didst thou not eat something and come?" He answered, "Does not the master agree with the opinion of Rab Huna who said : It is forbidden a man to eat anything before praying the additional Tefillah?" He replied, "Then the master should have said the additional Tefillah by himself and eaten something and attended." He said to him, "Does not the master agree with the opinion of R. Johanan who declared : A man is forbidden to anticipate the congregational Tefillah by praying alone?" He replied, "But has it not been reported in this connection : R. Abba said : This teaching applies only when he is with the Congregation?"
Why should he not repeat it if praying with a Congregation? Because he can hear it from the Precentor. If so [the reason stated above] "because he can include it in 'Who hearkenest unto prayer'" should rather be, because he can hear it from the Precentor !
Rab Ashe said to Amemar : Since Rab has stated a reason, what has it to do whether the month is full or defective ! Certainly there is no difference.
Nay more, I have reason to feel abashed before my ancestors. For now will they say, 'Behold the leader whom He appointed over them ! He sought greatness for himself and begged not mercy on their behalf!"
R. Eleazar also said : Greater is fasting than charity. What is the reason ? The former [demands the sacrifice] of the person, the latter of money.
R. Hiyya taught : Bread made into Kuttah is exempt from Hallah. But there is a teaching ; It is subject to Hallah ! Yes, but there it mentions the reason, viz. : R. Judah says : The way they are made decides.
Mar b. Rab Ashe also said : Over the honey of the date-palm we use the benediction "...By Whose word all things exist." What is the reason ? Because it is only the moisture [of the tree].
Rab Pappa said : All agree that on Passover one should place the piece together with the whole and break them both. What is the reason ? "Bread of affliction" (Deut. xvi. 3) it is written.
R. Abba said : On the Sabbath one should break bread over two loaves. What is the reason ? "Twice as much bread" (Exod. xvi 22) it is written.
Rab Mari said in the name of R. Johanan : He who makes it a habit to eat lentils once in thirty days keeps croup away from his house ; but not every day. What is the reason ? Because it is bad for the breath of the mouth.
R. Mari also said in the name of R. Johanan : He who makes it a habit to eat mustard once in thirty days keeps illnesses away from his house ; but not every day. What is the reason ? Because it is bad for heartweakness.
But R. Judah declares : "...Who createst divers kinds of herbs." R. Zera (another version : R. Hinnana b. Pappa) said : The Halakah is not in accord with R. Judah. R. Zera (another version: R. Hinnana b. Pappa) also said: What is R. Judah's reason? The Scriptures state, "Blessed be the Lord day by day" (Ps. Ixviii. 20) — are we to bless Him by day and not by night ! Nay, it means to tell thee : Day by day give Him the appropriate blessing ; so here also, for every species of food give Him an appropriate benediction.
He should not recline in the company of 'Amine ha'ares. What is the reason ? He may perhaps be induced to be drawn after them.
GEMARA What is Rabban Gamaliel's reason? Because it is written, "A land of wheat and barley and vines and fig-trees and pomegranates" (Deut. viii. 8), and it is written, "A land wherein thou shalt eat bread without scarceness" (ibid. v. 9), and it is written "And thou shalt eat and be satisfied, and bless the Lord thy God" (ibid. v. lO).
R. Isaac also said : It is forbidden to converse with him who has eaten [raw] herbs before the fourth hour of the day. For what reason ? Because of the evil odour. R. Isaac also said : It is forbidden for a man to eat raw herbs before the fourth hour of the day.
It is to be concluded that it was Rab who said above, "If they wish to arrange Zimmun, they may not" ; for Rab Dimai b. Joseph said in the name of Rab : If three ate together, and one of them went out into the street, they call to him [that they desire to include him for Zimmun, and should he consent, even in his absence] they may reckon him in for Zimmun. The reason [why they can have Zimmun without him is] that they called to him ; hence if they did not call to him, they are not [to have Zimmun].
But the Halakah is in agreement with Mar Zotra. What is the reason ? Since it is necessary to mention the Divine Name, which is not customary with less than ten.
Rab Judah b. Rab Samuel b. Shelat said in the name of Rab : If nine ate corn-food and one ate vegetables, they are to be reckoned together. R. Zera said, "I asked Rab Judah, 'How is it with eight or seven ?' He replied, 'It makes no difference.' Concerning six there was no need for me to ask." R. Jeremiah said to him, "Well hast thou done in not asking [about six]. What is the reason there? Because there is a majority [who have eaten cornfood]." But here also [with six] there is a majority ! But R. Zera was of opinion that we require a clearly recognisable majority.
Our Rabbis have taught : Whence do we derive the Grace after meals from the Torah? As it is said, "And thou shalt eat and be satisfied and bless" (Deut. viii. 10) — this refers to the benediction "Who feedest"; "the Lord thy God" (ibid.)— to the benediction of Zimmun; "for the land" (ibid.) — to the benediction of "the land" ; "the good" (ibid.) — to "Who. . . rebuildest Jerusalem," for so it states "That goodly hill-country and Lebanon" (ibid. iii. 25); "which He hath given thee" (ibid. viii. 10) — to "Who art kind and dealest kindly." I have here only the Grace after meals ; whence do we derive the Grace before meals ? Thou canst reason by a fortiori argument — if a man should bless God when satisfied, how much more so when he is hungry !
What is the reason that we do not conclude with two ? We must not perform commandments in bundles.
Rab Abin asked Rab 'Amram, "Why is the Tefillah different from the Grace after meals in this respect?" He replied, "To me also that was a difficulty and I put the question to Rab Nahman, who told me, 'I have not heard the reason from the master, Samuel' ; but let us see : With regard to the Tefillah which is an obligation, we make him repeat it ; but with regard to the Grace after meals, where one can eat or not eat just as he pleases, we do not make him repeat it."
R. Jose b. R. Hannina said: The Sages agree with R. Eliezer that over a cup of wine intended for the Grace we do not say the benediction until water is added. What is the reason ? Rab Osha'ya answered : We require a commandment to be performed with the choicest.
But Bet Hillel say : One pronounces the benediction over the wine and then over the day, because the wine causes the Sanctification to be said. Another reason is : The benediction over the wine is constant but that over the day is not constant, and when we have that which is constant and not constant, the former takes precedence. The Halakah is in agreement with Bet Hillel.
Why is this other reason necessary ? Shouldest thou say that there [Bet Shammai offer] two reasons but here [Bet Hillel offer] only one, therefore here also we have two reasons. "The benediction over the wine is constant but that over the day is not constant, and when we have that which is constant and not constant, the former takes precedence.
Bet Hillel, on the other hand, hold that it is permitted to use a cup whose exterior has become defiled by a liquid, saying that spillings are not frequent ; but there is reason to fear lest the moisture on the hand contract defilement on account of the cup.
Another reason is that the meal follows immediately on the washing of the hands.
Why this other reason? Thus said Bet Hillel to Bet Shammai : According to you who maintain that it is forbidden to use a cup whose exterior has been defiled because of the fear of spillings, even so it is better [to wash the hands last] because the meal follows immediately on the washing of the hands.
Another reason is : The washing of the hands for non-holy food is not ordained by the Torah.
Why this other reason ? Thus said Bet Hillel to Bet Shammai : Should you ask what difference is there that in the case of food we are concerned [about defilement] but in the case of the hands we have no concern ? Even so [our view] is better because the washing of the hands for non-holy food is not ordained by the Torah ; therefore it is preferable that the hands should be defiled, since that has no basis in the Torah, rather than food should be defiled, for which there is a basis in the Torah.
Our Rabbis have taught : Bet Shammai say : They clear up and then we wash the hands [before Grace] ; for if thou sayest that we wash the hands first, the consequence may be that thou wilt spoil some food. (Bet Shammai do not hold that the washing of the hands comes first. What is the reason? On account of the pieces of breads.)
R. Hannina of Sura said : [In the sequel] he merely states the reason : What is the reason that we do not say a benediction over the light or spices of the gentiles ? Because the assumption is the banquet of gentiles is dedicated to idolatry.
R. Hannina of Sura said : [In the sequel] he merely states the reason : What is the reason that we do not say a benediction over the light or spices of the gentiles ? Because the assumption is the banquet of gentiles is dedicated to idolatry.
It is quite right that Bet Hillel explain the reason [for their view] ; but what is the reason of Bet Shammai ? They hold that it will cause an interruption in the House of Study.
It is quite right that Bet Hillel explain the reason [for their view] ; but what is the reason of Bet Shammai ? They hold that it will cause an interruption in the House of Study.
We may not say the benediction over the light or spices of the dead. What is the reason ? The light which is kindled [for the dead] is in its honour and the spices are used to remove the odour.
R. Shela flogged a certain man who had had intercourse with a gentile woman ; so he went and laid a charge against him before the king, saying, "There is a certain Jew who judges without the king's consent." The king sent an official for him [to appear]. When R. Shela came he was asked, "For what reason didst thou flog this person?" He replied, "Because he had intercourse with a she-ass." They said to him, "Hast thou witnesses?" He answered, "Yes." Elijah came in human guise and gave evidence. They said to him, "In that case, his punishment is death." He said to them, "From the day we were exiled from our land, we have no power to inflict the death-sentence ; but you do with him as you please."
it has the appearance of having been torn away [from the star] ; and the reason that the 'Ajish follows the Kimah is that it says to it, "Give me back my children." For when the Holy One, blessed be He, sought to bring the flood upon the world. He took two stars from the Pleiades and thus brought the flood upon the world ; and when He sought to stop it, He took two stars from the Bear and stopped it.
Rab Kattina said, "The necromancer lies and his words are false; for in that case, there should be one rumbling noise followed by another!" But it is not so ; there is really one rumbling noise followed by another, and the reason that Kattina did not acknowledge the necromancer's statement was that people should not be led astray after him.
Rab said : The reason why the inhabitants of Mahoza are so shrewd is because they drink the waters of the Tigris ; the reason why they are red-spotted is because they indulge in sexual intercourse in the daytime ; and the reason why their eyes are unsteady is because they dwell in dark houses.
Rab said : The reason why the inhabitants of Mahoza are so shrewd is because they drink the waters of the Tigris ; the reason why they are red-spotted is because they indulge in sexual intercourse in the daytime ; and the reason why their eyes are unsteady is because they dwell in dark houses.
Rab said : The reason why the inhabitants of Mahoza are so shrewd is because they drink the waters of the Tigris ; the reason why they are red-spotted is because they indulge in sexual intercourse in the daytime ; and the reason why their eyes are unsteady is because they dwell in dark houses.
Whose ruling is followed in the statement made by R. Yoshia in the name of Rav that the difference of opinion is where the walls do not reach the covering, but where the walls do reach the covering the sukkah is valid, even if it is higher than twenty amos? Whose ruling is followed? Like Rabbah's, whose reason is that:
Master says: ‘It is free from the obligations of Mezuzah, and parapet, does not become tamay from leprosy, is not irredeemable among the houses of a walled city, nor does one return on account [of it just being built] from the war’ What is the reason? Because the term ‘house’ occurs in all [these commandments].
‘Nor does an Eruv be prepared for it, nor Shittuf, nor does one place within an Eruv’. What is the reason? Because it is unsuitable as a dwelling. Now the Eruv of courtyards is not placed within, but a Shittuf may be placed within.
What is the reason? Since it is no worse than a courtyard within an alleyway, The Tana says: ‘The Eruv of courtyards [are placed] in a courtyard, and the shittuf of an alley in the alley’.
(Now going back to the Barissa)‘Nor make of it an extension between two cities’. Since it is not regarded even as an outpost. What is the reason? Outposts are suitable for their purpose, but this [the four amah house] is unsuitable for anything.
R. Huna could answer you: They disagree about poles in the middle of the roof, and likewise also about those on the edge. And the reason why the dispute concerns the middle of the roof is in order to show you how far R. Jacob's view extends that even where the poles were in the middle of the roof he holds [the Sukkah] to be valid.
R. Matanah said: The reason of R. Shimon is a derivation from the following verse: "And there shall be a Sukkah for shade during the day from the heat, and for a refuge and for a cover from storm and from rain" (Isaiah 4:6).
Rav Yemar b. Shelemiah said in the name of Abaye: What is the reason of R. Yoshayah? As it is written: "And you shall cover the ark with the veil" (Exodus 40:3). Now since the ‘veil’ was a partition and the Torah called it a ‘covering’ it is evident that a partition [for the sukkah] must be as [close] as the covering.
What then is Bet Shammai's reason? -There is another Scriptural verse "You shall make the festival of Sukkoth for seven days" (Deuteronomy 16:13). This implies that we require a sukkah made expressly for the sake of the Festival.
Ten [handbreadths]. What is the reason of Shmuel? As its validity, so is its invalidity. Just as its validity [is effected by a height of] ten handbreadths, so is its invalidity [effected by] ten handbreadths
Gemara. R. Hisda stated: [Our mishnah] speaks only [of a sheet spread] because of falling [leaves], but if [it was spread] in order to beautify [the sukkah], it is valid But is not this obvious! For did we not learn in the mishnah, "because of falling [leaves]? One might have said that the law is the same even [where the sheet was intended] to beautify [the sukkah] and that the reason why it was stated, because of falling [leaves], is that he mentions what is the common practice, therefore he [R. Hisda] teaches us this.
This stands to reason also, since it was stated in the final clause To what can it be compared? To a man standing naked in a house, in which case he may not put his head out of the window and read the Shema’. Learn from this.
If he had said, "the halachah is according to R. Judah," I might have presumed that this applies only to a bed which is made [to be slept] upon, but not to a canopied bed which, is made [to be slept] within, hence he teaches us that the reason of R. Judah is that a temporary tent cannot nullify a permanent one, no matter whether it be an ordinary bed or a canopied bed.
How so? If you say that it is a case where one did not cut them, why did he give the reason ‘"You shall make" but not from that which is already made’? Let him rather give the reason that they are joined to the ground? Consequently it must be a case where he cut them, and yet it is taught that they are invalid. Learn from this that we do not say that their cutting is their making. And this is a refutation of Rav?
How so? If you say that it is a case where one did not cut them, why did he give the reason ‘"You shall make" but not from that which is already made’? Let him rather give the reason that they are joined to the ground? Consequently it must be a case where he cut them, and yet it is taught that they are invalid. Learn from this that we do not say that their cutting is their making. And this is a refutation of Rav?